Found it:
https://odysee.com/@CyberLounge:a/even-if-youre-paying-youre...
Children have parents and many of them will shell out thousands of dollars a year so their kid can buy Fortnite skins. I don’t imagine a credit card requirement will keep kids off of social media.
For the purposes of addressing some of the data privacy concerns, I think it would be even easier to just restrict the collection and/or sale of personal information. Simply charging for the service doesn’t prevent or disincentivize companies from also selling your data.
Social media, for all its terrible ills, is the primary way many people get their real news too. By news, I mean municipal updates, weather alerts, local events, etc.
I don't think putting up a financial barrier to that by law is the solution.
Having public -- especially government -- information siloed in private services is its own problem that in my opinion also needs badly to be fixed.
But I don't really know how you could reasonably make this work for online communities. Is reading a blog and commenting on it participating in a "social network"? What about reading a blog without comments? Viewing a sponsored Twitch stream?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_social_platforms_with_...
And exclude messaging services eg. Telegram, or platforms which are focused on technical or professional knowledge sharing (eg. Quora, LinkedIn, Wikipedia).
I think the risk would be conglomeration - platforms would partner up so that the minimum fee could give access to multiple services. You'd also want to avoid the fee from just becoming a 'token' with advertising still driving 90%+ of revenue.
Old-fashioned antitrust enforcement might still be necessary (eg. separating Facebook from Instagram and Whatsapp), as well as setting a maximum % of gross revenue that can come from advertising, maybe 75%.
You also remove about 7-22% of the US population that is unbanked or underbanked (per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unbanked) from participation in democracy. Not to mention you then have an enforceable paper trail from an online account to some sort of government-backed ID (since you need that to open a bank account), which will lead to self-censorship issues.
Facebook and the Internet in general has become the virtual equivalent of townhalls and public "speakers corners".
So..now we need regulations to be free? Nice!
* https://www.cnn.com/2021/08/31/tech/china-ban-video-games-mi...
Their increasing push to gamify awards, while selling a currency to do so does annoy me though.
You remove kids by default (no credit card/bank card), and the focus of product managers is less on driving addictive browsing, and more on driving renewals (presumably through quality features, content, and fostering community).
The customer is no longer the advertisers (or shady Governmental data scrapers), but now the users.
Look at the generally higher quality of Netflix content compared to free-to-air TV.
You could apply the same regulation to other addictive products: p*rnography and games. These categories would also improve in quality, be less exploitative, and become less available to children, if a minimum payment was required for access.