Like most addictive substances, the negative health benefits don't manifest themselves immediately, but often after years or decades, and those who haven't suffered claim all the benefits while the harms loom on the horizon. They change their tune later in life...sometimes.
As for the other harms, such as the amplification of violence, the loss of mental faculties – that same "social greasing" is the removal of inhibitions, including those that prevent people from committing certain crimes or harm against other people. How many alcohol-fueled rages would it take to make the equation flip for someone?
If the argument is that it is fine as long as it is done responsibly, how do we police that?
Will alcohol always be around? Of course. It's something that cannot be avoided, even in societies that have banned it for one reason or another. But to welcome it with all its complications, just because one enjoys it, and closing a blind eye to the harms, is imprudent.
And is alcohol truly a good solution as a self-medicant? I think you are spinning that as a net positive, but I highly doubt this is a professional's opinion on that matter, such as a therapist or a doctor.
Finally, to equate a negative view of alcohol as "...removing anything tasteful, fun, stupid..." and "...total boredom..." – to be honest, this is reducto ad absurdium, isn't it? If nothing is fun if there's no alcohol, then I think there's a different problem.
We will never be rid of alcohol, in my opinion. It's too simple and effective, and too deeply engrained in our society. What we can do is work to better educate and support society so that alcohol can exist in a safer atmosphere. Addicts don't get addicted just due to chemical means: there are deep social implications.
Should we police responsible consumption more than we currently do? Perhaps, it's worth discussing for sure.
Will alcohol always be around? Of course. It's something that cannot be avoided, even in societies that have banned it for one reason or another. But to reject it with all its benefits, just because it has harms, and closing a blind eye to the good, is imprudent.
And is alcohol truly always a _bad_ solution as a self-medicant? I think you are spinning that as a net negative, but I highly doubt this is professional consensus on the matter, such as among therapists or doctors.
Finally, I don't think there's anything wrong with making boring/stressful stuff less boring/stressful, sometimes you just gotta do boring/stressful stuff
The two drink a day meme is something I knew was totally bullshit, but could never really prove. Two of my uncles (one died recently) believed that meme and happily torched both their mental and physical health by drinking to excess. Their healthcare providers didn’t say anything either, until it was much too late, at which point the damage had become very obvious.
Excuse me, what? I certainly would, and I don't know how you could possibly think that nobody else would.
I believe that the idea that people are to blame for their alcohol problems is totally false and basically a conspiracy by the alcohol advertising industry. The problem is alcohol, not the people consuming it. It naturally induces almost every person to want to drink more alcohol while inhibiting their ability to make good decisions such as about continuing to drink.
The perennial issue is finding and designing the right levers to get the results that are wanted. Prohibition didn't work, moralistic pressure doesn't work, education doesn't work. The right incentives need to be discovered, and I think an acceptance that humans have a need for changing their state of mind will lead closer to answers.
Maybe if we could eliminate all the things that make people drink to extreme excess, or drink when it's dangerous, this would be a fun little quirk of the human species but as it is a huge amount of harm is correlated with heavy drinking and I think if you've only ever seen and understood the good side you are a very very lucky person.
Well, I can personally confirm that you can just as well train yourself to consciously overcome this specific restraint which is also a rather useful skill in itself. Sure, it takes work and effort but all things that don't "come to you naturally" require that.
And if where talking about cases of actual psychic illness, carefully chosen prescription drugs even when imperfect always beat self-treatment with alcohol.
We seem to be on the cusp of solving aging and dying problems to a massive degree.
200 years ago we knew nothing, in another 50 we might know all we need to achieve immunity to aging.
I would bet my net worth that we figure that out in the next 1,000.
Anyway I still don't optimize for longevity, but I think it makes sense, at least.
I also enjoy that alcohol connects across millenia. Lately I've been trying some things from a Slavic brewery, they brew some ancient mead recipes. One was unchanged since about 1300, according to the label. That's pretty cool. If you want to check it out, the one I have now is a honey apple wine called Ribe Mjod. Same company.
That elixir has changed names, but the concept is still around.
Aging is just another biological process. It's controlled by genetics and environment like everything else, and can be manipulated using similar principles.
It seems likely (thinking of CRISPR and similar inventions) the rudimentary tools for controlling aging are coming of age. I believe biological immortality is closer than we think.
Living biological processes by their nature resist decay, but that's an uphill battle... eventually entropy wins. Errors and waste products accumulate, materials become brittle and fragile, with every year lived the probability of dying before the next increases.
Can we help our biology to become more efficient at maintenance and repair? Probably, but not all that much. We are already very long lived. The only complex terrestrial beings that live longer do so by living very slowly... in terms of subjective time experienced, maybe they don't live any longer at all.
However, in medicine, most doctors will tell you that the doctors from 200+ years ago were idiots that did more harm than good.
Why is that? Is modern medicine too hubristic? Were the doctors of ages old really that dumb? Is this a trend that will repeat itself in 200 years?
So yes, 200 years ago doctors knew a great deal far less than today. I'm sure a doctor 200 years in the future looking back on today will feel similarly. There's still so much we don't know & there's a lot of guesswork involved. I wouldn't say they were idiots but the outcomes were certainly not at levels we'd accept today (just as the outcomes today won't be acceptable 200 years from now).
FWIW, the same is true in other disciplines. The 20th century marked a rapid exponential curve in learning. No one really studies any of the masters you note except for maybe Newton & Galileo. The former because the kinematics equations are actually extremely good approximations for Einstein's equations (& also his work on light and lenses remains accurate and foundational to this day). The latter as a warning of the dangers of putting ideology ahead of science and scientific thinking. Galileo's heliocentric model isn't actually used today except as a way to teach kids about the solar system because it's really simple & is good enough at that level (his work on gravity was an important influence for Newton's ideas on the topic).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignaz_Semmelweis [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louis_Pasteur
The way it is often done just creates trust issues for people who really care about accuracy...
Most artists (art consumers anyway) are very big on newness and rejecting tradition. Art historians even more so.
A safer bet there's never been, at least in the sense that unless life extension advances very soon, your expiration will pre-date your wager's.
And yet I do tend to agree, barring a dark age or human extinction event, both very possible.
I guess the way to bet on it is compounding interest, at least in the current world.
>it connects across millenia
Ya, just like all those other great constructs of human civilization: war, slavery...
(Obviously alcohol is not as harmful as those examples, just trying to illustrate how that line of thought is flawed.)
(At least for Europeans)
Alcohol is about self-medication, at the core of human civilization for a long, long time. China, India, Egypt so many early examples (https://www.cato.org/commentary/alcohol-caffeine-created-civ...).
How many people would be under more stress, have less relationships without alcohol? It absolutely works as social grease, loosens up nerves and is a very nice way of calming down.
I know so much in modern culture is about this weird asceticism, removing anything tasteful, fun, stupid and optimize for longevity - but what's the point to live in total boredom?
I like alcohol, it connects across millenia.