* addictive
* network / peer pressure effects
* damaging (but insidiously only after long cumulative use)
* poorly regulated even after the negative externalities became known
* less developed (and even less regulated) markets the final "growth" act of the industry
We can thus extrapolate that usage will only stop when governments start actively warning people (instead of tacitly approving and bankrolling with gratuitous advertisement when they maintain presence on the platforms and invite their citizens to engage there)
Can we push the analogy towards a solution / better social media? There are various proto-alternatives in the fediverse space. But some look suspiciously like E-cigarettes. Maybe the only cure from (at least this type) of social networks is to just pull the plug. As long as the billions keep pouring in and financing this sick business model we'll never really have a proper exploration of possible healthy alternatives to online social media
Not just that, but like tobacco, FB was strategically, scientifically researched and optimized for addiction. In FB's case it was through emotional manipulation instead of chemical but capitalizing on biology in both cases.
- deliberately sowed doubt and misinformation about the harmful effects of their productt
- hired in-house researchers to produce bad science to counter the legitimate research finding the product is harmful
- insisted that "the science isn't settled" while hampering study into the harmful effects
But Instagram is not, and Facebook will keep adding ads and mind-tricks so they can further milk their addicts' attention.
And if not Facebook, TikTok will do so.
Marlboro may be in trouble, but the new Big Tobacco is doing-well-thank-you.
We might even see the name change while the social network is still up and running, resulting in some ridiculous re-brand like "Facebook by FB" (did you know that the actual Express service from Fedex is now called "FedEx Express"? :)
A fourth of the world population uses it daily, and a third uses it monthly. They are far from dead.
Sure, one day that will not be the case. But you can say that for any company out there.
Do you have any kind of stats or even anecdotal evidence to your claim, other than you left ("early" in your own words)?
Counter-anecdata: Many of my friends are unhappy with Instagram because of the (randomly![1]) filtered timelines, intrusive ads[2], etc.
[1] e.g. I see different timelines on web vs iOS with the same account. It's bafflingly stupid. I just want a chronologically sorted list of post from everyone I follow.
[2] Checking just now, scrolled through 25 timeline entries - 7 of them are ads.
I didn't mean no one had criticisms, maybe "very happy" was an exaggeration. I'm just saying I don't see the exodus the GP thinks is imminent, even on a small scale.
Hopefully, they will re-discover the joys and challenges of in-person communication and social networking.
The next frontier is vr metaverse.
The TV industry has been booming and the only issue is more advanced successors.
TV can be addicting, rage inducing, waste of time, ruining teenagers minds and giving them bad body images issues.
TV is also informative, educational, and makes people happy since it’s fun to watch at other times.
While some people have been for years complains about the destruction of human society by TV, the majority just nods and prefers having it to not.
(FB employee, opinions my own)
TV doesn't track me, doesn't tailor content to influence my behavior, TV doesn't try to build a model of my social network. And the big difference - TV actually creates content themselves.
The trend I've seen is the emergence of services that exclusively cater to an echo chamber (usually far right or far left) and will probably monetize by selling that audience out to interests who want to reach that demographic. That I'm afraid is even worse than Facebook since it puts people into permanent filter bubbles from which they will not escape unless they leave the network.
Facebook is like smoking in some ways, but there is one huge difference: the dynamics of the market forced Facebook to be like that or die. Since everything has to be "free" but nothing actually is, things can only be monetized in sleazy underhanded ways.
"Free" is really the central pillar of surveillance capitalism just like it was for classic wall-to-wall advertisements television.
The next FB could be smart enough (or regulated enough) to require this change.
All the financial incentives right now heavily incentivize sleaze.
Twitter and Instagram are just as bad as Facebook.
Reddit is magnitudes worse.
Isn't this true of any service, at least of a certain size? My Twitter feed is tightly, tightly curated, and even the comment replies to these extremely high-quality accounts are full of unbelievable levels of stupidity and hostility.
I closed my Reddit account after the last Danish parliment election, when it became clear that only left wing politic was considered “correct” and apparently any liberal party or candidate is not to be trusted, so no argumentation would considered valid.
But the core of what Facebook does is very good. Everyone I care to still be in touch with from high school, college, and multiple past jobs is there. That core feature is good, not bad.
And it's not at all obvious that those people are ever going to go somewhere else. Sure, teenagers are going to keep adopting new, fun stuff, but none of that new, fun stuff replaces that core feature of Facebook.
"Teenagers hanging out" is a different use case from "adult who wants to stay in touch with people he knew a decade ago." There's no competition for this latter use case.
That was announced to great fanfare and support in the NYT a decade ago, and it didn't turn out so great.
It sounds like you are predicting that their user base will shrink significantly? Since the stock price is essentially people estimating the expected value of the company, including future growth or decline, it seems to me like the stock price should be a good indicator of this?
Successful value investors like Warren Buffet have proven time and again that the stock price is often wrong. They are so rich only because others are so often so wrong (paraphrased from Charlie Munger).
> $81.5 of Warren Buffett’s $84.5 billion net worth came after his 65th birthday. (Housel)
1: https://www.lung.org/research/trends-in-lung-disease/tobacco... 2: https://www.morningstar.com/stocks/xnys/mo/trailing-returns 3: https://www.morningstar.com/stocks/xnys/pm/trailing-returns
It's also just about the least cool thing out there now. In the early days of FB, old people would sign up b/c FB was where they could get in touch with their grandchildren. Now 20 somethings keep their FB account around just to keep in touch with their Boomer grandparents. FB is the new Fox News. A financial juggernaut fueled by angry baby boomers.
Stock price is not an indicator of aliveness. Facebook is morally dead. It is the new smoking. Slowly but surely people will ween themselves off it, and a great diaspora will begin. To where? Who knows, but I imagine people will have a choice of multiple services instead of one or two big behemoths (i.e Facebook & Twitter).