News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jhgb on Sunday October 03, 2021 @04:56PM (#28740433)
> The HAWC vehicle operates best in oxygen-rich atmosphere, where speed and maneuverability make it difficult to detect in a timely way.

I'm reasonably sure that the infrared trace of a hypersonic vehicle doesn't make it difficult to detect. Likewise existing approaches to radar stealth are hard to reconcile with hypersonic speeds, which doesn't help avoid radar detection either.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Sunday October 03, 2021 @04:59PM (#28740451)
Plasma stealth is an existing approach to radar stealth that is made easier by hypersonic speeds.

Infrared targeting of multiple hypersonic missiles is easier said than done. The missile you're hitting them with is going to be heating up the air around the camera probably at the same temps as the missile it's intercepting, and a base station wouldn't have enough resolution to guide a missile accurately from 100+km away while being alert for other missiles.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jhgb on Sunday October 03, 2021 @05:05PM (#28740501)
> The missile you're hitting them with is going to be heating up the air around the camera probably at the same temps as the missile it's intercepting

That would only apply if it were to hit it at comparable speeds. That's not necessary in many cases, especially in point defense when the target is heading towards you. Furthermore the limited time of flight of the interceptor might also allow for active cooling of the IR window in that brief period.

Also, even detection from a fixed ground base (or from space - see SpaceX's newest missile detection project) is still detection in the first place, which is what I was commenting on. Wasn't even going to veer into interceptor guidance, but I'm sure there's multiple ways to do it.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:14PM (#28740970)
Interception against an actively manoeuvring target is a question of kinetic energy. If the intecepting missile is smaller all the hypersonic missile has to do is zig-zagging randomly and you're toast.

If you're going to wait for the hypersonic missile to be close enough that this isn't a problem, you have the issue that your missile won't be able to manoeuvre right and might still be building up velocity. Plus there won't only be one!

> the interceptor might also allow for active cooling of the IR window in that brief period.

The issue isn't the IR window, it's the air directly in front of the interceptor missile, which has to target from the frontal aspect.

>Also, even detection from a fixed ground base (or from space - see SpaceX's newest missile detection project) is still detection in the first place, which is what I was commenting on. Wasn't even going to veer into interceptor guidance, but I'm sure there's multiple ways to do it.

Detection is not enough. We can already detect missiles from satellites even. The issue is calculating their velocity accurately and locating them at +- 10m from 100km+ away is not feasible without really large apertures and pretty long focal lengths. You wouldn't be able to accurately track more missiles than you have optics and the optics would be mind-boggingly expensive. Besides that, the target acquisition radar to maintain a feasible or even physically possible relative aperture for target acquisition would be unable to resolve any detail about the missile, so it would have no way of telling the difference between a missile and a flare of the same brightness and color.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jhgb on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:33PM (#28741106)
> Interception against an actively manoeuvring target is a question of kinetic energy. If the intecepting missile is smaller all the hypersonic missile has to do is zig-zagging randomly and you're toast.

What you're describing is not a matter of kinetic energy (clearly if it were about kinetic energy, this would be defeated by making the interceptor weigh 30 tonnes) but a matter of transverse acceleration. On that matter, as far as I understand it, current AAMs/SAMs are somewhere in the 50g region. I strongly suspect that hypersonic vehicles due to their lower L/D are nowhere near that -- hell, many of them seem to have a hard enough time flying straight, if US military's experience is of any relevance here.

Also, due to low L/D ratio in the high Mach region, if your missile is zig-zagging randomly, it won't stay fast for long. And if it's not zig-zagging randomly, then the question is how it gets the information how to zig-zag, since the nose of a hypersonic vehicle seems to be an extremely poor sensor platform -- which you admitted yourself. It's virtually certain that it won't be able to see the interceptor.

> The issue isn't the IR window, it's the air directly in front of the interceptor missile, which has to target from the frontal aspect.

It seems unlikely that the interceptor will have to fly at a comparable speed in a frontal aspect interception situation (considering that it doesn't need to catch up).

But as for terminal interception, I suspect that here the inverse-fourth-power-of-distance operation of an active radar homing solution might help you if all else fails -- at a small enough distance this will work even better than the inverse square applicable to passive optical/IR detection.

> would be unable to resolve any detail about the missile, so it would have no way of telling the difference between a missile and a flare of the same brightness and color.

It would seem that the easiest way to distinguish a flare would be to look if it's in a controlled flight? Unlike a flare, the hypersonic vehicle will continue flying, and the difference is readily apparent. Besides, you can't have that many flares on it, so you can't keep firing them continuously -- again, the only thing that's available to you if you can't see the incoming interceptor.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sandworm101 on Monday October 04, 2021 @12:09AM (#28742959)
>> It would seem that the easiest way to distinguish a flare would be to look if it's in a controlled flight?

"This isn't one of your church picnic flare gun firings". Smarter people than Homer have been working on flare technology for 40+ years.

(2003) https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2003/11/30/...

>> Also, due to low L/D ratio in the high Mach region, if your missile is zig-zagging randomly, it won't stay fast for long.

These are not airplanes with wings. These are missiles very high in the atmosphere flying complex flight paths more accurately describes as trajectories. The air is thin, the drag low, the energies extraordinarily high. A successful zig-zag maneuver could be as small as one degree left or right, up or down. And sacrificing speed to escape an interceptor is a valid tradeoff considering that, not being an airplane, the missile intends to slam into the ground/target in a minute or two no matter what its speed.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Sunday October 03, 2021 @07:01PM (#28741288)
>What you're describing is not a matter of kinetic energy (clearly if it were about kinetic energy, this would be defeated by making the interceptor weigh 30 tonnes) but a matter of transverse acceleration. On that matter, as far as I understand it, current AAMs/SAMs are somewhere in the 50g region. I strongly suspect that hypersonic vehicles due to their lower L/D are nowhere near that -- hell, many of them seem to have a hard enough time flying straight, if US military's experience is of any relevance here.

Not so. AAMs/SAM can only pull anywhere close to 50g at gigantic cost in drag and can only do that once and briefly. It is a question of kinetic energy because the missile that can regenerate kinetic energy and that loses the least kinetic energy relative to it's mass is at a massive advantage.

>Also, due to low L/D ratio in the high Mach region, if your missile is zig-zagging randomly, it won't stay fast for long. And if it's not zig-zagging randomly, then the question is how it gets the information how to zig-zag, since the nose of a hypersonic vehicle seems to be an extremely poor sensor platform -- which you admitted yourself. It's virtually certain that it won't be able to see the interceptor.

Traditional aerodynamic designs suffer from poor L/D ratios, yes. Waverider designs probably have much fewer issues. Given the advent of HGVs, which are made to turn multiple times without any engine to back them up, we can be fairly confident that this is not the case.

As far as being a poor sensor, this is an oversimplification of a complex mechanism. Plasmas block radar up to a certain frequecy depending on their temperature. So you make it so that the radar is somewhere where the air is slightly colder and make its frequency higher. You don't even have to put the radar in the nose if the target you're trying to hit is sluggish and large enough.

It doesn't need to maneuver in response to the interceptor. The missile knows when it is in LOS to the target, and knows that the interceptor will be fired soon after. So it already knows when the missile will be fired and thus when the missile would hit. The window for interception is pretty short. It would have to do evasive maneuvers at maybe 4G for maybe 30 seconds, all the while gaining back Ke from reducing in altitude in combination with engines.

>It would seem that the easiest way to distinguish a flare would be to look if it's in a controlled flight? Unlike a flare, the hypersonic vehicle will continue flying, and the difference is readily apparent. Besides, you can't have that many flares on it, so you can't keep firing them continuously -- again, the only thing that's available to you if you can't see the incoming interceptor.

This is a REALLY hard problem, and it's the reason why imaging infrared guidance was invented. It takes a lot of time to be certain that a flare in a ballistic trajectory at high speed is different from a missile coming towards you! Those are precious seconds you can't afford. Remember that you have no way of estimating distance.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jhgb on Sunday October 03, 2021 @07:13PM (#28741373)
> Not so. AAMs/SAM can only pull anywhere close to 50g at gigantic cost in drag and can only do that once and briefly. It is a question of kinetic energy because the missile that can regenerate kinetic energy and that loses the least kinetic energy relative to it's mass is at a massive advantage.

Except since the interceptor has only one chance at interception, the situations of the interceptor and the missile are not symmetrical. "Doing that once and briefly" seems quite acceptable for the interceptor. The missile pretty much must regenerate kinetic energy, or its subsequent suboptimal flight regime might make it even more vulnerable to the second interceptor incoming, or the third one after that.

> The window for interception is pretty short.

With early detection (orbital, for example), the window seems to be as long as the range of the longest-range applicable interceptor missile.

> It would have to do evasive maneuvers at maybe 4G for maybe 30 seconds

That definitely seems to be a "too little, too late" kind of situation. Especially in a point defense scenario where maneuvering away from your line to target means not hitting the target in the first place (which is as good as a successful hit of the interceptor), and where being close to the target really favors the short-range defense systems.

> Remember that you have no way of estimating distance.

You may very well have that way in the end if SpaceX's/L3Harris's system gets implemented.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by dotancohen on Monday October 04, 2021 @02:04AM (#28743557)

  > Plasma stealth is an existing approach to radar
  > stealth that is made easier by hypersonic speeds.
Does a vehicle traveling at such speeds that it compresses the air into a plasma have much aerodynamic control? I am aware that the space shuttle orbiters would roll during the plasma stage to control their rate of decent (less lift vector in the "up" direction) but could a missile maneuver to a target? Assuming that the sensors-through-plasma issue were resolved (which is another issue that I do not believe can be easily resolved).
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by nradov on Sunday October 03, 2021 @08:57PM (#28741925)
Sure hypersonic missiles will be detectible by infrared sensors. But those sensors have limited range, narrow field of view, and don't work well through clouds. And IR sensors can't give precise range data so they're less useful for targeting interceptors.
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jack_pp on Sunday October 03, 2021 @05:42PM (#28740757)
Isn't the point of these weapons that even if you can detect them they are too fast to intercept?
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 03, 2021 @05:44PM (#28740776)
> even if you can detect them they are too fast to intercept?

No. They still travel far slower than ballistic missiles. Their advantages are in being able to fly low and (theoretically) manoeuvre to avoid interceptors.

They’re an evolution of cruise missiles, not strategic ballistic missiles.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jhgb on Sunday October 03, 2021 @05:51PM (#28740813)
But maneuvering at high velocities won't be that easy. As far as I understand it, your lift/drag ratio decreases appreciably with increasing Mach numbers. So either you'd have to limit your maneuvering, or you'd have to have a propulsion unit with ridiculous amounts of thrust - at a situation when any amount of useful thrust is hard to obtain, since we still don't know really well how to do propulsion in this regime.
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:05PM (#28740904)
As a former aerospace engineer, I’m sceptical of the strategic value of hypersonics. Tactical? Sure. They’d have a better chance of taking out SAMs, light radar, et cetera. But the talk about these being carrier killers is, based on everything we’ve seen, off the mark. (Spending the cost of one hypersonic on a swarming attack would probably do more damage.)
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:27PM (#28741054)
The biggest difference between hypersonics and swarms of slow missiles is that the hypersonics can get there fast enough that you might not need high-quality targeting information. That's definitely a strategic advantage!

Also the 3M22 is estimated to only cost around 2 million dollars.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:51PM (#28741226)
> hypersonics can get there fast enough that you might not need high-quality targeting information

The strategic systems hypersonics are hyped to hit have been hardened against ballistics. Hypersonics are slower than ballistics. (Their plasma envelope also makes them easier to track by satellite.)

This is a tactical evolution. Meaningful. Helpful. But not a strategic shift.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Monday October 04, 2021 @11:25AM (#28747904)
The big issue is that a ballistic missile may not be able to deviate as much from the expected position as it can search away from it.

I agree that they're not that different from ballistics but they still have considerable advantages.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jhgb on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:55PM (#28741249)
> that you might not need high-quality targeting information

I don't see how this would work, unless of course you're talking about nuclear weapons. With a conventional warhead you still need to hit your target.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Sunday October 03, 2021 @09:56PM (#28742213)
You can locate your own target if it's close enough - say 10-30 miles or so - from where you expected it to be. With a slower missile your target will have drifted a lot more.
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by nurgasemetey on Monday October 04, 2021 @01:37AM (#28743416)
I think taking out SAMs is huge thing. Or I am wrong?
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:36PM (#28741135)
Thrust is not the issue, the issue is net thrust. Essentially the missile/engine is compressing so much air that trying to get more air to produce more thrust doesn't work, you have to manage to increase efficiency, by increasing compression, without melting or blowing apart your engine

Once you manage to make significant net thrust making a bit more isn't that big of deal, it's really a critical point you have to pass.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:55PM (#28741250)
> once you manage to make significant net thrust making a bit more isn't that big of deal

You’re still limited by your fuel and flight envelope. The latter which bleeds the former.

Hypersonic missiles will be harder to intercept than cruise missiles. Due to their novelty, they’ll also be harder than ballistics. (Ballistic projectiles don’t continuously illuminate their flight path. That permits for subterfuge options an air-breathing missile forfeits.)

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Sunday October 03, 2021 @09:53PM (#28742201)
These maneuvers are in the terminal phase. Knowing the reaction speed and the moment at which LOS is achieved as well as estimating the speed of the missile and it's acceleration one can calculate a relatively short period under which interception is possible. Outside of that there is basically no risk and thus no need for any maneuvers.

As for flight envelope we know from the X-15 that not that much is required to pull 10Gs at hypersonic speeds. There is no need for much more.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 03, 2021 @10:55PM (#28742513)
> maneuvers are in the terminal phase

One, this leaves the missile, which is screaming through the atmosphere, vulnerable in a way ballistics are not. (And visible in a way cruise missiles aren’t, either.) Two, if you have a carrier strike group in the middle of the ocean, this strongly restricts how much manoeuvring can be done. The target knows where you’re ultimately headed—if you tactfully manoeuvre into a blank patch of ocean, the strike group is fine.

> flight envelope we know from the X-15 that not that much is required to pull 10Gs at hypersonic speeds

The flight envelope restriction isn’t a structural one. If you have a known target, there is only so much manoeuvring the vehicle can aerodynamically do without slowing down to sub-scram speeds. Yes, you could supercharge the engine, but that cascades through another host of factors.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Monday October 04, 2021 @11:22AM (#28747864)
By the time that you're close enough to the strike group that you have a serious risk of seriously missing, it's already too late for the faster interceptors to be effective.

As far as only so much maneuvering you can do before being too slow for the engine, yes that's probably an issue for the HAWC, but scramjet missiles have been demonstrated to achieve Mach 9 in atmospheric flight which allows a lot of energy to bled out before you drop out below Mach 4.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jhgb on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:47PM (#28741200)
Yes, that's what makes it even worse. Flying as fast as you can means you have very little reserve for velocity losses from extensive maneuvering.
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by pageandrew on Sunday October 03, 2021 @07:10PM (#28741349)
They are slower than ballistic missiles, but fly more unpredictably. Ballistic missiles fly a parabolic trajectory and therefore an intercept can be calculated, whereas hypersonic missiles fly in the atmosphere at high speeds and can change their direction
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by JumpCrisscross on Sunday October 03, 2021 @07:27PM (#28741449)
> but fly more unpredictably

Ballistics cruise quietly. An RCS impulse can covertly re-aim it. Hypersonics scream bloody murder their whole flight path. Every satellite over the horizon will see it.

Hypersonic manoeuvres are, moreover, expensive. You have to deflect a lot of molecules to make small changes. That costs you in speed, fuel and time to arrival. If you need to maintain scram airspeed, your options are seriously limited.

This weapon has a place on the battlefield. But it’s not a strategic element.

Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jhgb on Sunday October 03, 2021 @05:47PM (#28740795)
They're too fast to catch up with (i.e., from behind). But if someone sprints straight into your fist, that person will be hurt even if your fist itself is fully stationary. In fact this probably makes them somewhat more vulnerable to an interceptor's warhead's shrapnel: even lesser damage, survivable for a slower target, might be much more serious for a target flying at high Mach speeds (not the mention the imminent "Columbia syndrome" of very hot air suddenly inside your vehicle).
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by sudosysgen on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:29PM (#28741074)
That only works if your rate of tangential acceleration is quite low. The reason why you'd make an airbreathing hypersonic instead of a ballistic missile is so it could manoeuvre.
Re:DARPA's hypersonic scramjet achieves successful flight by jhgb on Sunday October 03, 2021 @06:49PM (#28741212)
Your tangential acceleration is zero in a sustained flight. So it works, then.