Technically the profits are a result of the computer code of the system, though. If they want to stick to their arguments that smart contracts are the law, then it’s just a regular payout from the system according to the rules of the system. Business as usual.
However, I suspect when the losses are in the tens of millions they’ll drop the pretense of “code is the contract” and start pursuing other legal avenues. The loss was about 1% of the total money locked in Compound.
But a mistaken payment is also not income and threatening willfully to mis-file a 1099 is completely inappropriate.
If they want to get the mistaken payments back, they can ask nicely, they can send threatening letters, they can sue in court; but they can't use the IRS as their cat's paw because the only tax situation that fits the facts here is gift.
If one wants to claim it's a mistaken payment, then the recipient needs to return the tokens - their legal ownership was never conveyed.
Additionally, you can tell the intent is not that of a gift because the transferrer immediately wants it back.
If you keep it, and it's over the taxable limit, you have to report it and pay tax.
https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
"Who pays the gift tax? The donor is generally responsible for paying the gift tax."
>For example, if you go on price is right, and you win a nice trip to tahiti
Those are prizes or winnings, not gifts. Totally different tax treatment.
And taxes on gifts are presumptively payable by the donor, not the recipient.
Disclaimer: not tax advice, YMMV etc.