News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by NovemberWhiskey on Friday October 01, 2021 @10:22AM (#28718799)
Ehh, technically any transfer to another where full consideration is not received in return (in either money or money's worth) is a gift.

And taxes on gifts are presumptively payable by the donor, not the recipient.

Disclaimer: not tax advice, YMMV etc.

Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by PragmaticPulp on Friday October 01, 2021 @10:38AM (#28719002)
This is an interesting case because presumably they would want to write this off as a loss (in a theoretical world where they were paying US taxes) so it’s not a gift.

Technically the profits are a result of the computer code of the system, though. If they want to stick to their arguments that smart contracts are the law, then it’s just a regular payout from the system according to the rules of the system. Business as usual.

However, I suspect when the losses are in the tens of millions they’ll drop the pretense of “code is the contract” and start pursuing other legal avenues. The loss was about 1% of the total money locked in Compound.

Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by l33tman on Friday October 01, 2021 @10:43AM (#28719066)
You can make erroneous money transfers and it doesn't automatically count as a gift, the receiver can be liable if the amount makes it obvious it's an error for example and she won't return it. I'm sure this differs between jurisdictions in the details though..
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by NovemberWhiskey on Friday October 01, 2021 @11:03AM (#28719363)
No, of course a mistaken payment isn't a gift, and there's an appropriate mechanism for retrieving mistaken payments through the civil courts (if necessary).

But a mistaken payment is also not income and threatening willfully to mis-file a 1099 is completely inappropriate.

If they want to get the mistaken payments back, they can ask nicely, they can send threatening letters, they can sue in court; but they can't use the IRS as their cat's paw because the only tax situation that fits the facts here is gift.

Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by mindslight on Friday October 01, 2021 @11:37AM (#28719836)
It's not a gift - if you take the position that a smart contract is a binding contract, then the payment is pursuant to a contract that itself was entered into for full consideration. Nobody knew how the contract would develop, but the same applies for many contracts - eg options trading.

If one wants to claim it's a mistaken payment, then the recipient needs to return the tokens - their legal ownership was never conveyed.

Additionally, you can tell the intent is not that of a gift because the transferrer immediately wants it back.

Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by porknubbins on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:59PM (#28725048)
But does anyone take the position that a smart contract is a binding contract? I believe even Nick Szabo regrets coining the term since its just a program that can transfer value so including it term “contract” is misleading.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by mindslight on Saturday October 02, 2021 @12:35PM (#28729964)
To me, that's the entire point of them - a single source of truth in an extremely formal language.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by kwertyoowiyop on Friday October 01, 2021 @10:32AM (#28718913)
I love this thread! And what are the rules for unintended gifts?
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by ars on Friday October 01, 2021 @10:37AM (#28718993)
The same. You can return or throw out the gift if you don't want it.

If you keep it, and it's over the taxable limit, you have to report it and pay tax.

Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by NovemberWhiskey on Friday October 01, 2021 @11:05AM (#28719395)
Please explain why you think the recipient of a gift is the one that has to pay tax on it.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by 0x0 on Friday October 01, 2021 @11:36AM (#28719816)
Because otherwise you can come and build me a website and I can gift you $10k and wow nobody needs to pay income tax anymore?
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by NovemberWhiskey on Friday October 01, 2021 @12:14PM (#28720305)
No, because when you give me $10K because I made you a website, you're obviously paying me for my work. The IRS is not stupid, and doesn't look at the form you claim, it looks at the actual factual situation.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by throw123123123 on Sunday October 03, 2021 @12:59AM (#28734643)
The IRS doesn't look at any factual situation, its clerks in an administration building..
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by dnautics on Friday October 01, 2021 @11:28AM (#28719722)
is this generally not understood? For example, if you go on price is right, and you win a nice trip to tahiti, you still have to pay tax on it.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by NovemberWhiskey on Friday October 01, 2021 @12:12PM (#28720293)
If it's generally understood, then it's wrongly understood:

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...

"Who pays the gift tax? The donor is generally responsible for paying the gift tax."

>For example, if you go on price is right, and you win a nice trip to tahiti

Those are prizes or winnings, not gifts. Totally different tax treatment.

Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by stonemetal12 on Friday October 01, 2021 @12:48PM (#28720727)
Gameshow winnings are not a gift. I think it is considered gambling and taxed accordingly.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by kbenson on Friday October 01, 2021 @02:32PM (#28721941)
Well, most people might think any sort of Crypto is gambling too...