News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by NovemberWhiskey on Friday October 01, 2021 @11:03AM (#28719363)
No, of course a mistaken payment isn't a gift, and there's an appropriate mechanism for retrieving mistaken payments through the civil courts (if necessary).

But a mistaken payment is also not income and threatening willfully to mis-file a 1099 is completely inappropriate.

If they want to get the mistaken payments back, they can ask nicely, they can send threatening letters, they can sue in court; but they can't use the IRS as their cat's paw because the only tax situation that fits the facts here is gift.

Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by mindslight on Friday October 01, 2021 @11:37AM (#28719836)
It's not a gift - if you take the position that a smart contract is a binding contract, then the payment is pursuant to a contract that itself was entered into for full consideration. Nobody knew how the contract would develop, but the same applies for many contracts - eg options trading.

If one wants to claim it's a mistaken payment, then the recipient needs to return the tokens - their legal ownership was never conveyed.

Additionally, you can tell the intent is not that of a gift because the transferrer immediately wants it back.

Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by porknubbins on Friday October 01, 2021 @08:59PM (#28725048)
But does anyone take the position that a smart contract is a binding contract? I believe even Nick Szabo regrets coining the term since its just a program that can transfer value so including it term “contract” is misleading.
Re:DeFi bug accidentally gives $90M to users by mindslight on Saturday October 02, 2021 @12:35PM (#28729964)
To me, that's the entire point of them - a single source of truth in an extremely formal language.