Indeed. Most fundamentally, they take their computing freedom for granted. There are powerful forces who want to take it away from us. There are powerful and rich people out there who think it's too dangerous for mere citizens to have access to unrestricted computers.
People focus on Stallman's software licenses as if that's what he's all about. They barely matter. People ignore the big picture: computing freedom. It's not just important, it's fundamental. Without this freedom, there is no hacking as we know it. There is no way to write and run our own software. What good is free software if a corporation or government signature is required to run it?
Stallman saw this coming before most if not all of us.
To an extent, I agree. I wonder whether the general move in the open source community will turn out to be a Faustian bargain. Are open source developers just a bunch of suckers being taken advantage of to provide building blocks for various proprietary business models? OTOH I'm thinking that more open source code out there is a public good, and we should rejoice in that regardless of 'proprietary free riders'.
> People ignore the big picture: computing freedom. It's not just important, it's fundamental.
No. What's fundamental is freedom for people. Computing freedom matters only as a means to that end.
I agree, and I'm going to guess the person you're replying to also agrees. In fact, RMS would also agree. It's just that we are narrowly focusing on a single aspect of freedom in this conversation, but yes: freedom to live, to work, to education, to health, are all more important :)
Perhaps. The whole point of the GPL is to give free software developers advantages and create leverage we can use against those who would exploit our labor. Permissive licenses allow that exploitation.
In the end, it's irrelevant. All this software, all this positioning for advantages and leverage, none of it will matter if the machine itself is taken away from us.
We'll never be truly free until computer manufacturing is as democratized as software development. Ideally we should be able to make computers at home.
> No. What's fundamental is freedom for people.
Absolutely. Computing freedom is a subset of personal freedom.
If we had a few NGOs that were committed to freedom, were transparent and produced good hardware it would be a more reasonable option. Sure I can dream about the future where I can 3D print all electronics at home, but that computer wouldn't run very good and we all know this.
NGOs are still centralized operations that can easily be targeted and corrupted. We need decentralized manufacturing. Anyone should be able to make functioning computers and it should be impossible to stop or even regulate it.
> the future where I can 3D print all electronics at home, but that computer wouldn't run very good
It would be better than nothing. They may have relatively low performance but they would still be computers that are guaranteed to be free and completely under our control. The fact they exist at all would provide significant protections against attempts at controlling us.
But I think more generally, wrt FSF there's not so much controversy [1] as disappointment in the FSF failing to stay relevant. Copyleft was a solution to the 80/90'ies software world. The FSF tried with the AGPL to answer the 'threat' of SaaS, but largely the world has shunned it except as a poison pill license to upsell a proprietary version. Similarly with the GPLv3 the FSF tried to answer to the threat of Tivoization, but again, largely failed to gain adherents in the low level components, like the Linux kernel, where this would have mattered.
[1] Well, the FSF taking RMS back on its board did produce a tsunami of corporate (financial) contributors leaving ship.
It's odd because it's worded in a way that sounds as if the FSF wasn't necessary now (or maybe even never), instead of thinking that the FSF is needed more than ever, now that there's a war against general purpose computing and against privacy and users' rights, and that if the GPL3 and AGPL didn't work -- which is possible! -- then how do we fix that?
Instead it's either apathy and even scorn against the FSF, which is alarming to me.
It's not just FSF, there's also ethical software types trying to destroy OSI from within. We are seeing so many attempts to dismantle important organizations now it leaves me baffled.
End result was that countries would spend millions just to be able to share documents across agencies. Things started changing when KDE/Slackware, Ubuntu, Firefox, OpenOffice and other software systems started to become user-friendly, with nicer and intuitive interfaces. From this point on, governments started teaching GNU/Linux in schools and universities, explaining the benefits, the rights, etc, and then switching to open-sourced and free-software systems.
The article raises interesting points, but the whole rant against GNU and FSF is weird. GNU (yes, and Linux) and FSF is why many of us are in this business. They played a huge role in the career and passions of many of us -- I feel entitled to say "us" just like the author of TFA carelessly speaks about "we" -- and misunderstanding the history of how we got there doesn't help.
To me it feels as if a new generation of tech minded people have started taking things for granted, "why do we even need all those movements fighting for users' freedom, if I am free now?". It's a bit depressing.
The different approaches and goals of Linus Torvalds and RMS are both valid, and only in hindsight can we say one triumphed and the other didn't, but the article makes it look as if one of the two was obviously wrongheaded.
So some interesting points, but it could do without the whole rant against GNU and the FSF, and without the accusations of cultishness.