News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by okasaki on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:44AM (#28680908)
We're not supposed to question it, but in this case it seems salient: your account was created just to post this and it's got a lot of upvotes for something seemingly banal.

Is this part of a competing "diplomatic program"?

Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by qsort on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:57AM (#28680977)
No, it's not salient at all. It's a research report from the University of Oxford:

https://demtech.oii.ox.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/sites/127/20...

If you want to criticize something, criticize that. We can do without baseless accusations.

Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by boomboomsubban on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:04AM (#28681024)
First, there point was that this post seems to engage in similar tactics. The report existing doesn't mean this isn't some counter information campaign.

Second, the post links to an article about that report, and though the article mentions 189 twitter accounts the report only lists 62. Similarly, they don't show close to the 62000 tweets mentioned in the article from what I could see.

Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by qsort on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:12AM (#28681062)
1) The point is bogus. The upvote trajectory is typical for a HN frontpage submission. If you think there's an upvote ring, the appropriate behavior is to message moderators. The expected value of throwing around a random accusation without proof is zero.

2) I don't know where they took the 189 from, but the other numbers match what the report says. It could be that the article is garbage, but that is a very minor point. It's referencing research from a reputable institution, if you want to criticize the research or methodology, do so upstream.

Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by boomboomsubban on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:17PM (#28685129)
1 is a fair criticism of that post. Posting the report isn't.

>It could be that the article is garbage, but that is a very minor point. It's referencing research from a reputable institution, if you want to criticize the research or methodology, do so upstream.

It's not a minor point, the article was what is posted here for discussion. No matter how reliable the report is the article may be suspect.

I figured out how they got the 98000 too, it's the total number of interactions the Ambassadors tweets got. Using that number in the bullet point when the report claims well under half of them were part of the campaign is intentionally misleading.

Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by Chris2048 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @09:11AM (#28682343)
> The report existing doesn't mean this isn't some counter information campaign

But it uses the name/rep of an actual university, and presumably is data is open for peer review? a "counter information" campaign that fights falsehood with truth is fine in my book. I'd call that an "awareness campaign".

> this post seems to engage in similar tactics

In what sense?

Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by boomboomsubban on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:05PM (#28685016)
You are only looking at the report. As a comparison, the report is like the Ambassador's tweet, though it may be biased it's unlikely to be part of any disinformation campaign. The article and the article being posted here are like the bot retweets and replies, taking one legitimate piece of information and both distorting it and spreading it wider than it normally would go.
Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by reillyse on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:21AM (#28681112)
This. Even the website bitterwind just looks like an attack site against China. It seems to just have “articles” that just say negative things about China. This is just seems to be another play in an influence campaign.
Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by jackTheMan on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:44AM (#28681240)
... or just really nothing good happening on the religion side of China.
Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by Chris2048 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @09:18AM (#28682396)
And Amnesty International rarely publishes good new either.
Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by starfallg on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:53AM (#28680952)
A lot of people are concerned about their online history based on what is happening in Hong Kong with people being arrested and charged for things they said in the past.

Once you set foot in China and now even Hong Kong, all bets are off.

Re:False Pro-China Accounts Invade Twitter in the UK by bserge on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:06AM (#28681032)
Remember when Wikileaks revealed the US has plans for cyberattacks that would be blamed on another country?

These days it's China this, China that. I bet it's West this, West that in China, too.

Everyone's been so polarized on this, this is exactly what warmongers in power want.