News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by matheusmoreira on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @03:54AM (#28680318)
I wonder why. It's not like Firefox is a bad browser.
Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by chii on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @04:23AM (#28680463)
> It's not like Firefox is a bad browser.

compared to chrome, firefox no longer has an edge. Chrome's restrictive addons is what made firefox stronger.

But ever since firefox removed the old XUL style addons, their utility has drastically dropped against chrome. I was very angry at their poor choice, as some really excellent, but unmaintained addons no longer work.

I put up with firefox, just so i can give them some boost (whatever that might amount to), but obviously not that many users would sacrifice their browsing experience for such purposes.

Firefox should be the premier customizable browser, with more addons than chrome. Instead, firefox chose to copy chrome. Thus, it is forever relegated to being second.

Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by progval on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @04:54AM (#28680623)
I also hate they had to kill XUL addons, but they had good reasons to do so: https://yoric.github.io/post/why-did-mozilla-remove-xul-addo...
Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by chii on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:01AM (#28680659)
Those aren't good reasons from the user's perspective. Those reasons were good reasons from a technical, and maintenance perspective (which, as a software engineer, i understand). Those reasons are what engineers give to product management in order to get a green-field rewrite.

But firefox's value add is their addon system - even if it is old, and difficult to use. It enabled some really great addons that weren't possible in the new replacement (as a simple example, the DownThemAll was rewritten using this new api, and it's shadow of their former self).

Firefox should have paid the cost to maintain the old legacy system, and replace it only when the webextensions api is sufficient to replace _all_ functionality (which, of course, won't because webextensions evolved from google trying to kill off addons https://developer.chrome.com/docs/extensions/reference/ ).

Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by imbnwa on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:15PM (#28685115)
Not to mention XULRunner/XPCOM was Electron before Electron. I remember using the Songbird app, as well as an IM client whose name I can't recall now, across Windows and Linux back in the 00s. So They literally decided to cede the cross-platform browser-based desktop software framework du jour to Chromium.
Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by MomoXenosaga on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @09:52AM (#28682791)
When they explained it I actually agreed with the changes. But that was on the condition that those extensions would be coming back.

But it's been years now and Mozilla's only solution is to switch to nightly.

Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by MomoXenosaga on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @04:52AM (#28680614)
Yes this is true. Mozilla neutered extensions on Android.

I'm using Firefox nightly and I have to jump through hoops to get the extensions I want. Far too complicated for most users I'm sure.

Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by tjpnz on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:03AM (#28680676)
On Android it's freaking fantastic. Everything feels snappier and I can utilise uBlock Origin to block all of the BS. I've set this up for family, friends etc and none have gone back to Chrome. I think the biggest issue is marketing.
Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by iggldiggl on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @07:34AM (#28681565)
The total rewrite might have given some performance boost and if that's worth it for you then I'm glad for you, but unfortunately it also caused loads of bugs and features that have gone missing, and now that the big push for the rewrite is over, tackling those remaining bug fixes and missing features is again happening at a rather glacial rate.

And the frustrating thing is that this used to be a problem even with the previous iteration of Firefox on Android, i.e. it seemed somewhat understaffed and had some surprising bugs (e.g. under memory pressure it would suddenly and silently stop remembering your current tabs) and missing functionality (it didn't remember your scroll position if the app was killed, you couldn't reorder tabs in the tab list) that were only fixed after years, and even then quite a few times only through outside contributions.

And now the rewrite means that all of this has been thrown away and judging from the current development speed it'll take once more years until we sort of get back to where we used to be.

Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by Mirioron on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:16AM (#28680744)
Have they fixed the scrolling? For years the scrolling in mobile Firefox felt bad/off. At one point I just gave up on trying to make it work.
Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by commoner on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @06:02AM (#28681009)
This was fixed for me in November 2017 when Async Pan/Zoom (APZ) was implemented:

https://hacks.mozilla.org/2017/11/async-panzoom-apz-lands-in...

Also, Firefox 79+ on Android (August 2020) performs significantly better than older versions, despite having lost many features in the rewrite. The current version might meet your expectations.

Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by nicoburns on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @07:10AM (#28681406)
Yes. They did a rewrite of the android UI layer that released last year, and since then the scrolling is on par with chrome. If you install ublock origin then Firefox now has the best android browser experience by some way.

(The 2017 update did not do it for me)

Re:Google sets burial date for legacy Chrome Extensions, fea... by prox on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @04:09AM (#28680384)
Not only is it not bad, it’s pretty good. I have been using it for a decade and its fast, superior privacy above Chrome, devtools do everything I need.

I test on Chrome, and I personally don’t think switching is that big a deal that some commenters make it out to be. It’s just as fast as Chrome or faster, the UX is similar enough not be stalled for long if you need to switch. It’s really worth a shot!