News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Physiognomic Artificial Intelligence by arketyp on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:00AM (#28669212)
You make a good point of distinguishing between a scientific model and a predictive oracle. I think the political use of pseudoscience isn't helpful though. There could be a lot of understanding to be gained from these systems.
Re:Physiognomic Artificial Intelligence by mdp2021 on Monday September 27, 2021 @08:15AM (#28669706)
> I think the political use of pseudoscience isn't helpful though. There could be a lot of understanding to be gained from these systems.

If you meant, using the label of 'pseudoscience' to undermine research (in the broadest terms), or to promote blind faiths (e.g. scientism) or "arbitrary requirements for social membership", of course it is deterior (though the economic/financial matter is more complex). But in the specific context, the attribution of pseudoscience is (though often with little care and an improper naïvety) to be a substantially legitimate warning of "do not encourage shallow beliefs amounting to prejudices".

Many of us believe that similar research may reveal interesting correlations which may then trigger good insights. But there has been a trend (especially in cultures that have shown very little appreciation of subtlety as an ideal) that seem to encourage a return to the archaic ignorant use of stereotypes. Apply that to law enforcement, and - sorry, just inventing a sufficiently acceptable example, after today's article about "Irish Baileys" - the idea subtly or less subtly emerges to arrest sober Irishmen just because.

Re:Physiognomic Artificial Intelligence by HPsquared on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:52AM (#28669545)
Perhaps there should be more of a hard boundary between science and politics (like the separation between church and state).