News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by Gustomaximus on Monday September 27, 2021 @02:18AM (#28667612)
That's incredible, cost of war aside, you'd think solar and batteries would be used if only for the: 1) ability to redeploy 2) one-time shipping event for setup 3) ability to self sustain on supply issues.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by chefkoch on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:56AM (#28668189)
That would be a massive amount of solar, if a tent AC has 7kw and a standard panel has 180w theoretical output.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by londons_explore on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:39AM (#28668440)
A standard 2x1m panel now has an output of more like 450-500 watts. Technology has moved on since the days of 9% efficient panels!
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by bborud on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:07AM (#28669265)
So if we assume the sun was shining whenever the AC needs to draw 7kW, that would mean roughly 30m^2 of solar panels per 7kW AC.

So roughly one (american) football field of solar panels for every 180 or so 7kW AC units. (Rounding generously since this is just a thought experiment to look at some lower bounds.You'd probably need a lot more solar panels than that (3x?), plus battery infrastructure, plus some way of cleaning the panels etc. for this to be practical)

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by londons_explore on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:13AM (#28669297)
If you actually wanted to solar power the military, you'd design stuff the be energy efficient from the start. That would probably consist of all buildings having 3 inches of insulation on all sides so that you need far less cooling. Then you have the solar cells built into the roof, and the batteries built in too, so the whole unit is "dump this anywhere in the world and it makes habitable space".

Grid connection optional - and if provided can be used to automatically balance electrical load between buildings.

This probably weighs less than a tent plus generator plus fuel.

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by bborud on Monday September 27, 2021 @08:15AM (#28669705)
Have you taken some time to consider why forward operating bases make use of tents rather than what, for all practical purposes, would be houses?
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by Gravityloss on Monday September 27, 2021 @01:44PM (#28673748)
Even just putting two tents on top of each other already improves the insulation a lot, because of the air layer. This was used already during the second world war over here.

In reality in general it's hard to do things that make sense as a whole - large organizations can only optimize invididual parts.

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by nradov on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:19AM (#28669347)
It's not practical to build insulated buildings at forward operating bases. They don't have the time, materials, or equipment. Everything has to be flown in by helicopter, or transported in truck convoys over terrible roads under constant threat of roadside bombs. Tents are light and can be erected in minutes.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by matthewdgreen on Monday September 27, 2021 @09:41AM (#28670525)
"The Army has a $95 million contract to foam up to nine million square feet of building space in Iraq, of which about 60 percent has been completed. The Army also let a $29 million contract to foam structures in Afghanistan. So far, 150,000 square feet have been foamed. It takes a mere 26 days to recoup the costs of the foaming through the fuel savings." https://www.army.mil/article/20777/army_saves_fuel_and_lives...
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by newsclues on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:37AM (#28669460)
If an advanced invading army requires solar power, as an freedom fighter u I’m going to lob mortars and snipe those panels.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by Gustomaximus on Monday September 27, 2021 @11:08AM (#28671563)
Also exactly what was happening to the fuel convoys heading across Afghanistan.

I think better having people target your equipment in a base where its easier to have defence and a perimeter, than over a regular and long supply line.

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by newsclues on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @01:00PM (#28684958)
Better to have attacks on a base where you can mount an effective defence rather than letting your supply line get ambushed?

I don’t know if it’s better or worse but different with different risks.

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by garmaine on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:49AM (#28668825)
Not in 2003.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by kongin on Monday September 27, 2021 @03:57AM (#28668197)
Solar pannels don't work at night and you can't ask the enemy to attack on sunny days.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by throaway46546 on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:25AM (#28668351)
I think there might be a correlation between sunny days and AC usage.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by kongin on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:27AM (#28668713)
You also use AC to heat the tens at night in the desert.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by nix23 on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:53AM (#28668507)
There's that crazy idea called batteries. For "bigger" stuff one could produce hydrogen during the day (for fuel-cells or straight up burning in combustion engines).

But yeah i would too, not use solar-panels in a warzone.

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by bborud on Monday September 27, 2021 @07:15AM (#28669315)
Why would you want to introduce complex, hard to move storage technology that produces and consumes enormous amounts of explosive gas, and has much, much higher energy loss than both thermal and electrical storage?

Whenever hydrogen turns up in discussions about energy storage people tend to forget physics and the infrastructure reality of dealing with electrolysis, compression and liquefaction and powercells ... which ultimately charge batteries so you can buffer energy to deal with varying consumption.

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by nix23 on Monday September 27, 2021 @08:22AM (#28669754)
>which ultimately charge batteries so you can buffer energy to deal with varying consumption.

It's just one thing, storage huge amounts of energy in liq. hydrogen is easier then in batteries (who are explosive as well) and heavy.

But again...i would not use one of those technologies at all in a War-zone..all of them are way too complex for the field.

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by bborud on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:02PM (#28675328)
No, it isn't easier. Which you would know if you had bothered actually reading up on the matter.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by nix23 on Monday September 27, 2021 @06:58PM (#28677160)
So at tank is more complicated than a battery...tell that ~every single rocket.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by bborud on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @05:30AM (#28680831)
Storing energy as hydrogen involves a lot more than just a tank. Again, you obviously didn't bother reading up on this and you are guessing how hydrogen based energy systems work. You clearly don't.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by nix23 on Tuesday September 28, 2021 @08:56AM (#28682184)
BS, for liq. hydrogen you need to perfectly isolate it and that's it, the Adrianne rocket could achieve that with a 1.3mm think tank.

And storing compressed hydrogen needs nothing more then a Gas tank like the one under your Grill.

You even use compressed hydrogen for welding.

Again, you know nothing and try to blind everyone with your highly secret knowledge.

https://energies.airliquide.com/resources-planet-hydrogen/ho...

>>For example, the tanks on the Ariane launcher, designed and manufactured by Air Liquide, contain the 28 tons of liquid hydrogen that will provide fuel to the central engine. These tanks are a genuine example of technological prowess: they weigh only 5.5 tons empty and their casing is not more than 1.3 mm thick.

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by bborud on Wednesday September 29, 2021 @01:27PM (#28696978)
There is nothing "secret" about the challenges of turning energy into hydrogen and then back into heat or electricity. The challenges of each step along the energy chain are pretty well understood.

You make the naive assumption that you temporarily storing hydrogen in a tank with 1.3mm thick walls that needs to last for, at most, a couple of days, has any relevance for permanent energy installations.

If you are going to argue for an energy storage technology you have to consider what it would actually look like in practice. And since you only want to consider one part of the chain: I suggest you look into what it takes to safely store hydrogen in a vehicle and how this compares to your naive belief that hydrogen behaves like liquids that you have an intuitive understanding of. (Spoiler: you'd have a hard time convincing authorities to let you drive around traffic with a 1.3mm thick tank in the back of your car).

Then again, I don't think you want to actually know anything about this. I think you only want to argue and you are annoyed that someone called you out.

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by nix23 on Thursday September 30, 2021 @06:28AM (#28704801)
>Storing energy as hydrogen involves a lot more than just a tank.

The 1.3mm example was to prove that it's technological possible to isolate liquid hydrogen with such a tank. In a car you don't use liq nitrogen[1]. You just shift the usage-surrounding to make your point, it's like saying "but using kerosene in a rocket needs some additional measures too", true. Exactly like using a toilet in space needs some additional measures too.

[1] https://www.ieafuelcell.com/fileadmin/_processed_/e/e/csm_fc...

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by bborud on Thursday September 30, 2021 @12:34PM (#28708244)
You suggested that a tank used for ultra short-term storage of hydrogen was relevant in this context. I didn't. When you realized that your assumptions about hydrogen didn't hold you became unpleasant and childish.
Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by Someone on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:41AM (#28668447)
You can’t cover solar arrays and they have large area, so hitting them from distance is fairly easy.

How easy is it to design a solar array that stays operating (with reduced capacity) after a few mortar hits?

I would guess solar arrays in space that beam energy down are a better solution for military bases in times of war. The USA is actively working on that (https://www.livescience.com/microwave-beam-military-space-pl...)

Re:US military eyes prototype mobile nuclear reactor in Idaho by parineum on Monday September 27, 2021 @04:56AM (#28668523)
FYI, this is the "space laser" part of the "jewish space lasers" of Marjorie Taylor Greene that left everyone laughing about how (wrongly) absurd space lasers are and forgot about the anti-semitism.

She basically said that a system like you've mentioned was tested, misfired and started wildfires. It was then covered up by some Jewish guy on the board.