In many (most?) cases what we call "tastes" -- and especially distastes -- are a way for us to broadcast our identities to the world.
In an intimate, functioning relationship those broadcasts shouldn't be necessary because we know they are, if not fake, at least a proxy for what we want others to think who we really are. Intimacy is about shedding masks.
In a couple one should be able to appreciate, if not outright enjoy, what the other likes.
(Not to say there aren't limits; but it would be a symptom of an abusive relationship if one would insist they always watch what the other truly hates.)
Some years later I'm more appreciative of why other people might like different things now, and I've also picked up on nuances and contexts I used to miss.
But the things I like have barely changed. I don't spend much time "broadcasting them to the world" because why would the world even care what music I listen to?
There's enough overlap with my partner that we can have conversations about certain things we have in common, but there are things and activities that work for her that I'm utterly disinterested in, and vice versa.
We don't expect to share those, and that works for us.
> I don't spend much time "broadcasting them to the world"
Yes, you do. We all do. We build a personality and then we want the world to pay attention to it.
People get bored watching movies and it is not a mask nor identity - it is feeling. Some people genuinely feel bad watching horrrors and it is not identity, it is genuinely feeling bad. I hate cringe in comic super heroes movie and thus dislike them. It is not a mask I wear it is genuinely unpleasant and if alone I would never ever watch that.
The movies creators put a lot of work unto making you experience feelings while watching their movies in fact.
But it's not just about "taste", it's about values. I strongly suspect I won't have many shared values with someone who loves gore. And conflicting values are more likely to break a relationship than incompatible movie tastes.
One person likes superhero movies, the other does not. Is seems that by your worldview it will be an insurmountable barrier to forming a healthy relationship unless someone changes their mind, which seems to be a rather bleak attitude to me. Are you sure we couldn't find countless couples with different movie tastes (or movie values) who, despite this obstacle, are in happy and loving relationships?
Otherwise a marriage is a union of two individuals, not a project for a single joint life.
Of course the above is just a silly example but enlightening.
>> Because both of you are self-giving, you both say that the other can pick, you're thus in a deadlock.
> That is the mistake: thinking of watching a movie as a personal act.
Another mistake might be conceiving of one's "taste in movies" as fixed and unchanging when it isn't. You might be able to find something to like in your partner's preferences, when you didn't before; or find some new type of movie you both like. Making that effort may be what being "self-giving" is in this case.
That means your partner is not self-giving.
Assuming both of you are self-giving, I just don't see a resolution that doesn't involve a compromise.
In a parent/child relationship most wouldn’t call it a compromise to watch cartoons with their kid because a) some cartoons are great and b) even when they aren’t, just being with your kids when they are enjoying something is a wonderful experience.
Yes it’s possible for that to become pathological in a romantic relationship if there is no balance, but if neither partner has any personal fulfillment in letting their significant other enjoy something it’s going to get lonely quickly.
That said, I'm curious about the realism of all this. Just being with your partner when they are enjoying something is a wonderful experience. Is that true? Can this continue to be the case over many many years of a marriage?
The article mentioned a much more extreme scenario than movie watching, having someone walk you through the details of a geometry proof that they came up with. How many times can you enjoy having them walk you through a proof and still think it's a wonderful experience listening to them about this thing that you find so boring and soul crushing and might not even understand any piece of it, yet because of the passion in their voice, you enjoy the time and pretend to be excited and interested?
In my opinion, there's a bucket of how much you can do this for. Once the bucket is depleted, to refill the bucket, you need to either spend some time apart, have them spend time with you doing something of your enjoyment or spend time doing things you both enjoy together.
And so everyone is happy half the time, and you are mutually trying to make each other happy.
That’s fair, supportive, and a good marriage basically.
> Of course, we compromise: by taking turns
And the OP I replied to said that's not a self-giving attitude.
So in my case, taking turn counts as a compromise.
And so this is my point, I don't think compromising means that you're not in a self-giving relationship, in fact, I think it shows that you are, since both of you are considerate of the other and finding ways to please the other in turn.
Under a "self giving" regime, I want to spend time with my partner, enjoying her enjoying the movie she wants to watch. My partner wants to spend time with me enjoying the movie I want to watch. We can't both do that, so we each take turns letting the other one enjoy being with us while we watch the movie we want to watch.
Under the "compromise" option, we each get to watch the movie we want to watch, taking turn and turn about. That is what is important about the event: that we get to watch the movie we want to watch.
I think maybe the movie choice is a pretty trivial aspect of the relationship anyway, the GPs post around the willingness to serve your partner was a lovely insight to what makes a partnership work over the long term, far beyond how you both decide what movie to watch.
(sfbsab)
> Of course, we compromise: by taking turns
I used to love watching horrors. I watched them a lot and that made me less sensitive to them - I needed more scarier and badly looking to feel scared. And it is 100% legitimate for someone else to dislike horrors. To be sensitive to pain on the screen, to not be used to the tensions and anticipation of bad these movies create.
It has nothing to do with whether that horror has redeeming qualities. It does not matter whether it has deep philosophical meaning. The experience of watching it is deeply uncomfortable for some people and that is fine. It does not says anything bad about them.
So if you want to watch a movie together, I just don't see how you could both enjoy it without any compromise.
> So if you want to watch a movie together, I just don't see how you could both enjoy it without any compromise.
It kinda seems like you're setting up the scenario to force a particular result. If both your tastes are so fixed and incompatible that you can't like a movie without your partner disliking it, then maybe decide to do something else besides watch a movie?
This solution is part of the original comment; i.e.: “Or you compromise by not watching movies together, but seperately.”[1].
You recognise that it's not about the movie, it's about the activity you do together.
Really, the lengths the threads here are going through to facilitate poor interpersonal interaction are sort of mystifying. Perhaps being a good person (or even just a good friend) is not obvious to everyone, but the information on how to be one definitely is easy to find. How come nobody is finding it?
For example, you want to watch a movie together, but neither of you have the same tastes in movies. What do you do?
Because both of you are self-giving, you both say that the other can pick, you're thus in a deadlock.
At some point, there's going to need a compromise, because you can only pick one movie and neither of you happen to like the same movie.
So best you can do is compromise by alternating, this time you watch your preferred movie, next time there's.
Or you compromise by not watching movies together, but seperately.