Re:Italy wants an exception to Europe's gas-engine ban for F...
by Ensorceled on Saturday September 25, 2021 @07:24AM
(#28652236)
That’s not “similar”. It would be similar if we granted emissions or safety exemptions to new cars from a different manufacturer. My uncles 1942 Jeep is exempt for historical purposes, not so rich people can play with fast, expensive cars.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Italy wants an exception to Europe's gas-engine ban for F...
by PaywallBuster on Saturday September 25, 2021 @07:29AM
(#28652266)
double standard
if your uncle can keep driving old, low efficient, highly polluting vehicles why can't a rich person buy a ICE ferrari?
Makes much more sense to charge on "pollution/gas usage"
Kind of wealthy tax but without intervening in the market and picking winners or the "right solution"
Re:Italy wants an exception to Europe's gas-engine ban for F...
by foepys on Saturday September 25, 2021 @07:41AM
(#28652328)
Because the general expectation (and current reality) is that old cars will break and be scrapped eventually. Only few remain and those few don't matter in regards to global emissions as they are mostly not daily drivers. They instead contribute to keeping tiny bits of history alive.
I'd compare it to old houses which are often designated as landmarks. We don't demolish them just because they are not energy efficient by modern standards.
Re:Italy wants an exception to Europe's gas-engine ban for F...
by Ensorceled on Saturday September 25, 2021 @08:18AM
(#28652544)
“We allow this thing that existed before the rules were made to continue to exist” and “we won’t allow only rich people to create new rule breaking things” is NOT a double standard.
Why are you trying to position high end sports car owners as oppressed?
Re:Italy wants an exception to Europe's gas-engine ban for F...
by PaywallBuster on Monday September 27, 2021 @05:25AM
(#28668703)
"gas engine ban"
Re:Italy wants an exception to Europe's gas-engine ban for F...
by Symbiote on Saturday September 25, 2021 @09:28AM
(#28653016)
I don't know the rules in every country, but to get the exemptions it's generally required that the vehicle isn't used much — driving only to shows or museums for the biggest discount, or limited to a fairly low annual mileage.
That will continue to be the case for old cheap and expensive cars, and we justify it to preserve industrial history. There's no reason to introduce a similar exemption for certain new cars.
Re:Italy wants an exception to Europe's gas-engine ban for F...
by Ensorceled on Saturday September 25, 2021 @01:15PM
(#28654668)
Ontario has historic plates ... lots of rules but generally what you just described.