News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by DeathArrow on Saturday September 25, 2021 @03:47AM (#28651325)
While Nim is for certain interesting and even pleasant to write code in, its small user base and environment discourage people to use it.

I don't write code only for myself.

How would I convince my employer to let me use Nim instead of a better known language?

And even I would convince my employer, if we want to start a new project how could we find programmers well-versed in Nim?

And even id we can find those people, it would mean we would have to write many things ourselves, which in other languages we can take for granted as they have libraries for almost anything.

So having a nice, performant and good language is just a small part of achieving your goals. You also need the people and the ecosystem.

Go, Rust, Kotlin, Swift and even Julia have the luck of having some industry heavyweights behind them, pushing the ecosystem and contributing with money and developers. Nim has only a bunch of passionate people behind it.

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by kgeist on Saturday September 25, 2021 @04:19AM (#28651455)
>if we want to start a new project how could we find programmers well-versed in Nim?

If a programmer can't pick up a language like Nim in a few weekends (from what I gather, it's similar to Python and not much different from most common languages, i.e. not something relatively exotic like Haskell) then I don't know. Our mainly PHP shop transitioned to Go quite effortlessly. Today we hire PHP juniors without any Go experience (easier to find), we teach them, and then they work on Go codebases already after a month of internship. So lack of "professional Nim programmers" doesn't look like a problem to me.

Lack of libraries is a good point but from what I read, Nim compiles to C, so I understand they can have access to tens (hundreds?) of thousands C libraries without writing everything from scratch.

However, indeed, if you are to choose between, for example, Nim and Go for a new project, then I am not sure why would anyone prefer Nim. I'm really interested to know.

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by iamcreasy on Saturday September 25, 2021 @01:15PM (#28654671)
I think it is true for people who have computer science/software engineering or any programming background, but for my statistician/data scientist friends - they skip a bit when they think they might need to learn a different language.
Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by sound1 on Saturday September 25, 2021 @06:09AM (#28651916)
> However, indeed, if you are to choose between, for example, Nim and Go for a new project, then I am not sure why would anyone prefer Nim. I'm really interested to know.

Same here, curious to know what HN crowd recommends between Nim vs Go for new projects.

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by _dain_ on Saturday September 25, 2021 @07:03AM (#28652126)
Nim has hygienic AST macros, so it has really good metaprogramming capabilities. An example of the sort of thing you can do with it: use pattern matching to implement a functional programming DSL:

https://nim-lang.org/blog/2021/03/10/fusion-and-pattern-matc...

This makes it really easy to reduce boilerplate and create low- or 0-cost abstractions for your problem domain. Example of this done in a microcontroller project here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j0fUqdYC71k

Async/await is also implemented by metaprogramming, rather than as a "core" part of the language:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i0RB7UqxERE

Unrelated to the above, Nim also compiles to Javascript. So you can use the same language for both the backend and frontend.

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by kgeist on Saturday September 25, 2021 @09:06AM (#28652859)
>use pattern matching to implement a functional programming DSL

DSLs have some use cases but generally I'd avoid being too clever and creating basically entire sublanguages for the sake of it - unless I really need to. Most projects don't need it, it's harder to pick up for novices (especially if there's a zoo of DSLs, different between projects). In Go the last resort is usually code generation, there are built-in tools for it.

>Async/await is also implemented by metaprogramming, rather than as a "core" part of the language

I guess most programmers don't really care if a feature is implemented in the language or in the library, provided it's easy to use. In Go, it's not extendable however; but so far, I've never had a need to extend the default goroutine scheduler.

>Unrelated to the above, Nim also compiles to Javascript. So you can use the same language for both the backend and frontend.

Go can be compiled to WASM, but practically I've never seen code that could be reused between backend/frontend because they solve different problems using different principles, so the idea of using one language for frontend/backend was never compelling to me. Maybe it's just me.

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by DeathArrow on Saturday September 25, 2021 @09:15AM (#28652927)
Nim is also faster than Go if we look at most benchmarks. Nim's memory management can be tuned quite a bit. Garbage collector can be even turned off. You can better tune to the underlying hardware if you need to.

https://nim-lang.org/docs/gc.html

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by dejj on Saturday September 25, 2021 @04:01AM (#28651388)
> How would I convince my employer Turntables: if you were an employer, what would convince you to use Nim?

Hiring for Nim skills can be a signal that a company has people who learn languages beyond the run-of-the-mill ones. A bunch of passionate people you might say. That would make the company promising to work for.

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by WJW on Saturday September 25, 2021 @06:03AM (#28651886)
Interestingly this was exactly the place Python was in back in the day: niche enough that anyone knowing it must've learned it because they thought it was cool rather than because it would get them a job. Those days are long gone of course.
Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by cnmlp on Saturday September 25, 2021 @04:01AM (#28651383)
In the case of Python, the "industry heavyweights" do very little and have a negative influence now.

Why the phrase "only a bunch of passionate people"? This is how software gets written, parasitical corporations and their unproductive developers who are installed in existing OSS projects come later and mainly associate themselves with the result (speaking of Python again).

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by Mikeb85 on Saturday September 25, 2021 @02:04PM (#28654976)
> And even I would convince my employer, if we want to start a new project how could we find programmers well-versed in Nim?

Nim's easy to learn if you have any experience with any compiled language and can understand anything along the line of C#, Kotlin or Python syntax. Also because it compiles to C and JS it makes it easy to add it to a project incrementally in many cases.

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by nimmer on Sunday September 26, 2021 @08:16AM (#28660276)
> How would I convince my employer to let me use Nim instead of a better known language?

This is a rephrasing of "nobody ever got fired for buying IBM".

Some organization prioritize innovation and technical acumen.

> So having a nice, performant and good language is just a small part of achieving your goals. You also need the people and the ecosystem.

Many applications don't need a large ecosystem. People can learn.

> Go, Rust, Kotlin, Swift and even Julia have the luck of having some industry heavyweights behind them

Python was never corporate-driven, thankfully, and it is successful.

Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by egwor on Saturday September 25, 2021 @04:14AM (#28651438)
You could make the same argument about rust right now., but rust is further along the 'programming language life path'.
Re:Why I Use Nim instead of Python for Data Processing by Zababa on Saturday September 25, 2021 @07:32AM (#28652283)
Not really, Rust is way more established than Nim. Lots of people use it, lots of companies use it, the community is very large. Maybe 5 years ago, Rust was at the same point as Nim, but even then I doubt it. Nim seems to be one of those languages that will always remain low-profile, because it's an incremental improvement and isn't pushed by a platform.