News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by simonh on Friday September 24, 2021 @03:50AM (#28639683)
A company keeping records of it's own interactions with it's customers is fine, nobody is arguing against that.

The problem is companies selling customer data to each other and snooping on customer activity outside the company's own web site or app. This is what is meant by tracking and Apple doesn't do this in their ad service.

It seems like what Apple is doing is trying to cripple tracking for other ad services to make their own service more competitive.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by rickdeckard on Friday September 24, 2021 @09:06AM (#28641766)
>> ...snooping on customer activity outside the company's own web site or app. This is what is meant by tracking and Apple doesn't do this in their ad service.

I'm sure Apple is going to offer exactly that, as the conversion-rate data of an Ad into an actual purchase elsewhere is where the big Ad-money is. Apple will just do all that without handing off any data to another party, providing only the persona of an end-user to the Ad-customer.

Their dilemma is that doing this today at an "Apple-price" has limited competitive value to Advertisers. But if Apple cripples the competition to become the ONLY company able to provide such data, they suddenly become a mandatory supplier for every Ad-campaign in the world, as only Apple will be able to provide effective Ad-analytics on iOS.

>> It seems like what Apple is doing is trying to cripple tracking for other ad services to make their own service more competitive.

Exactly. Which should be a strong sign that regulation is urgently required, but somehow people still are stuck on the wrong narrative.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by simonh on Friday September 24, 2021 @02:03PM (#28645819)
Legislation to ban tracking and respect customer privacy? Yes, absolutely. Discipline and integrity in this area should be the standard.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by LexGray on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:15AM (#28639819)
Even when that company is responsible for more than half of the mobile software installs in the US?

Amazon and Google have abused this data in the past to undercut the competition with their own better promoted offerings and make purchase decisions with data the competition just could not have access to.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by ryan93 on Friday September 24, 2021 @09:36AM (#28642158)
Facebook doesnt sell data they sell access to demographics generated based on data.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by simonh on Friday September 24, 2021 @02:15PM (#28645951)
First that's like saying a bar that gives away drinks with every bag of peanuts isn't selling alcohol. The fact that ad was only shown to a specific demographic reveals that the person clicking it is in that demographic.

But second, sure they didn't sell it, they gave it away. Facebook claims the data delivered to Cambridge Analytica wasn't sold. No, it was given away because facebook calculates that it benefits from research which improves targeting on their platform. Nobody is fooled by any of this, unless they choose to be.

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by vineyardmike on Friday September 24, 2021 @02:46PM (#28646322)
> reveals that the person clicking it is in that demographic.

But you don't know who that person is [ until they create an account or give you info ]

Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by scatters on Friday September 24, 2021 @05:30AM (#28640262)
That's how you end up with a single megacorp that does everything.
Re:Apple's Power Move to Kneecap Facebook Advertising Is Wor... by vineyardmike on Friday September 24, 2021 @02:45PM (#28646308)
> It seems like what Apple is doing is trying to cripple tracking for other ad services to make their own service more competitive.

This is exactly what they're doing to FB and i hope FB wins a maassive anti-competative suit. I hope they still don't get to track but i hope apple is given a slap on the wrist.