Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by saagarjha on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:40AM
(#28639960)
Isn't it better to persist medical data on the device rather than putting it on Apple's servers?
Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by jonathanstrange on Friday September 24, 2021 @06:37AM
(#28640660)
What's funny about it is that apparently some of their WatchOS/device combos have FIPS 140-2 and FIPS 140-3 certifications. Pretty useless security theatre if you then shuffle the data around to other operating systems or into arbitrary servers with complex infrastructures.
Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by cybrox on Friday September 24, 2021 @07:57AM
(#28641184)
Not if your API design is so bad that any third party can access them, apparently.
Aside from that, I'm pretty sure they'll also get stored on their servers, if you have not declined all the nagging iCloud sync requests.
Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by evercast on Friday September 24, 2021 @06:09AM
(#28640478)
I have some doubt with respect to whether what author claims is "medical data" is indeed medical. Practically speaking, the data he mentions seems like the things collected by Apple Watch and stored in the Health app. There is indeed heart rate tracking, but can we really label this data as medical? IMHO "medical" would relate more to professional diagnosis, treatment etc. which according to Apple is stored in an encrypted form [1]. Garmin devices also collect heart rate, sleep stats etc. and I have never thought of these as medical (health-related yes, but not medical). The line is thin though.
Since you work in the industry, perhaps you could share your opinion how such data should be treated?
Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by the_errorist on Friday September 24, 2021 @06:37AM
(#28640659)
> menstrual cycle length, biological sex and age, whether user is logging sexual activity, cervical mucus quality, etc.
These are hardly data collected by Apple Watch, unless someone is being inventive with one. These come from HealthKit. Which is alarming as HealthKit can also sync your EHR from health providers.
Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by chmod775 on Friday September 24, 2021 @06:44AM
(#28640702)
Diagnostic data is a category of medical data. So yes, that stuff is considering medical data.
Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by mr_toad on Saturday September 25, 2021 @02:33AM
(#28650995)
> There is indeed heart rate tracking, but can we really label this data as medical?
The detailed data (ECG level) is medical enough that devices that measure it are regulated. That’s why some features aren’t available in some countries.
Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by kube-system on Friday September 24, 2021 @09:23AM
(#28641985)
Even if "health data" and "medical data" aren't synonymous, it's a distinction without a difference to their privacy importance.
Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by lazka on Friday September 24, 2021 @06:46AM
(#28640716)
According to the GDPR health data is a special category that needs extra care and heart rate falls in that category:
"Information derived from the testing or examination of a body part or bodily substance"
Re:Disclosure of three 0-day iOS vulnerabilities
by the_errorist on Friday September 24, 2021 @10:38AM
(#28643035)
"cervical mucus quality" sounds like it fits that definition.
I currently work in an IT health care company in Europe, and we must alway store the data fully encrypted with strict access control. We even decided to not make sure to not persist any medical data on user devices to not take unnecessary risks. And there, Apple logs everything on the iPhone? Why?