News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU plans to force OEMs to use a common charger for all ph... by rglullis on Thursday September 23, 2021 @06:43PM (#28636510)
Every system has failures. That much is a given. The main issue is about scale of these systems and its failure modes.

The problem of "big" systems - whether the EU, modern day US where federal govt taking over power from the states or Communist China - is that it fails in spectacularly catastrophic ways.

This is why you get crisis like 2008 and Dieselgate. Both are instances of "too big to fail" industries, protected by the government and that in the end screw with the people that they claim to serve and protect.

So it doesn't matter that you are not defending VW, or that you are against Apple. The point is that by backing this ever-growing centralization of power and influence by one single political entity, you make the whole system more fragile and easier to be manipulated by those elites that you so loudly claim to be against.

> there must be a place where such failure doesn't happen.

Switzerland. Local governments rule over any attempt at centralization. Direct democracy. Individual freedom but without forced globalization and universalization of values. Not involved in any wars. NOT AN EU MEMBER STATE.

Re:EU plans to force OEMs to use a common charger for all ph... by alwayseasy on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:25AM (#28639871)
Ok great you argued the EU is hypocritical when it comes to large local companies. I still don't see how encouraging competition and interoperability in the smartphone and electronics market is a problem... except for Apple's margins.

If Switzerland is your model, I'm even more confused about how you could be against a liberal economy using protectionist measures against an American company.

Re:EU plans to force OEMs to use a common charger for all ph... by rglullis on Friday September 24, 2021 @04:52AM (#28640021)
> I still don't see how encouraging competition

They are not encouraging anything. They are just playing a power game to see who can jerk more the other around. In the process, they create costs and bureaucratic obstacles that make it easier for any smaller player to have any chance of entering the market competitively.

> liberal economy using protectionist measures

Because it is a problem with the scale. There is not one economy in the EU states. There are many. By trying to apply a top-level, centralized solution to all member states, it ends up creating sub-optimal solutions for everyone. Or worse, it executes the decisions that benefits the member states with most power: Germany and France.

Systems that are designed bottom-up are more robust, have a more diverse set of tools to solve their problems and fail in more localized, controlled ways. Tell me how many times has Switzerland got into some kind of deep systemic crisis. Now do the same with similarly small countries that are in the EU.