A lot of what you say applies to anything in the "entertainment" category. Mobile music apps seem to follow this same sales trajectory.
Re:Game Development: You Need $100,000
by davidwparker on Tuesday August 09, 2011 @12:15PM
(#2864562)
I would say that Angry Birds was an exception to this rule, however... and a lot of Indie games are similar. They may have a spike at first, but if and when they do get picked up by Joe Public, they have a slow but steady rise in sales.
It doesn't seem to apply to dwarf fortress or minecraft.
Obviously. But you will not be Starcraft, Dwarf Fortress, nor Minecraft. :)
Re:Game Development: You Need $100,000
by spacemanaki on Tuesday August 09, 2011 @10:33AM
(#2864141)
I don't know what the GP was specifically referring to, but one of those things is not like the other. If the GP was talking about lo-fi or procedural assets, then Starcraft doesn't fit in there, as it required a significant investment in asset creation. If the GP was talking about the kind of slow growth and relying on a sort of "long tail" of fans, Starcraft also doesn't make sense since it was a big budget game following several other hits from an established studio.
If you just mean that your game won't be a hit, that's a risk no matter what you invest in it, whether it's long nights in your free time or a 100 developers and artists and several years.
But I think Dwarf Fortress and Minecraft are examples of breaking out of the mold of big AAA titles laden with creative assets and a heavy script, which are closer to interactive movies than DF and Minecraft.
Many non-game applications have an adoption curve which looks something like the sales graph on BCC (100x now what it was at launch) or the famous YC "gradual adoption, spike, trough of sorrow, plateau, steady growth, traction" narrative. Games almost universally have a big spike at lunch, declining sales through the launch window, and then they fall off a cliff and never recover. The exceptions to this rule are so rare that even non-gamers know their names. My mom remembers Starcraft. You will not be Starcraft.
This greatly complicates post-launch marketing, iterating towards a game design which achieves fit with what customers will pay for, etc. (The ability to do that is one reason why social games work so well... that and fixing "our industry has no effing clue how to do customer acquisition" with copious helpings of spam spam spam your friends.)