News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Olympic Medal Count, Adjusted for Population and GDP by ajross on Monday August 25, 2008 @03:37PM (#286319)
There's a slight anti-correlation with population size. Large nations with conventionally "successful" olympic programs (USA, China, Russia) are well below median in medals per capita.

My guess is that this is because there's an upper limit on entrants. The USA and China might be much more likely to get medals, but they're still limited to three per event at maximum. There might be events where a big nation (China and diving comes to mind) might be able to get even more medals, but can't because they only have so many slots.

Re:Olympic Medal Count, Adjusted for Population and GDP by timr on Monday August 25, 2008 @03:59PM (#286350)
That's the noise you'd expect from a random process. Any country with an Olympic program has some chance of earning a medal. Thus, given a sufficiently large number of small countries, you'd expect that a random subset of those nations would earn a higher number of medals per capita than the big players. That Jamaica is at the top of the list is a decent example -- without the unexpected, astronomical weirdness of Usain Bolt, they'd have half as many golds.

The larger programs have a greater number of chances to win, but normalizing by GDP or national population doesn't tell you anything about the overall probability of an athlete from country X winning a medal (which is arguably what you want to know). To get that information, you'd have to normalize by something else -- like size of team, or program expenditure, or some factor that's more directly related to athletics than GDP or population.

Re:Olympic Medal Count, Adjusted for Population and GDP by dejb on Monday August 25, 2008 @07:52PM (#286592)
Yes I agree. To make the list statistically valid you should probably only look at those countries with more than say 15 or 20 medals. I wonder who comes out on top then? :)
Re:Olympic Medal Count, Adjusted for Population and GDP by whatusername on Monday August 25, 2008 @10:21PM (#286684)
More than 15 total medals. Looking at GDP per Medal.

* Cuba ------- 1,879

* Belarus ------- 2,038

* Ukraine ------- 5,204

* Russia ------- 17,861

* Australia ------- 19,341

* South Korea ------- 31,674

* China ------- 32,990

* Netherlands ------- 47,181

* Great Britain ------- 59,000

* France ------- 62,875

* Italy ------- 73,857

* Canada ------- 78,111

* Spain ------- 78,611

* Germany ------- 79,488

* United States ------- 125,364

* Japan ------- 173,840

Who were expecting on top?

Re:Olympic Medal Count, Adjusted for Population and GDP by dejb on Tuesday August 26, 2008 @07:14AM (#286958)
I suspect you are deliberately missing the point for the purposes of mischief. I was talking about the population ones which would go like this

Population Gold

* Australia ---- 1,528,165

* Netherlands ---- 2,349,286

* Belarus ---- 2,422,500

* Great Britain ----- 3,052,632

* South Korea ----- 3,709,538

Population Medals

* Australia ----- 465,094

* Cuba ------ 469,500

* Belarus ----- 510,000

Huge Gap ....

* Netherlands ----- 1,027,813

Anything stand out to you about these? :)

Re:Olympic Medal Count, Adjusted for Population and GDP by whatusername on Tuesday August 26, 2008 @08:41AM (#287002)
To be honest - I was trying to prove that point with the GDP figures.. (but the pesky actual data got in the way)...

Good to see that Population proves it out though!

Re:Olympic Medal Count, Adjusted for Population and GDP by timr on Monday August 25, 2008 @10:40PM (#286697)
Tough to say. What this (perhaps) suggests is that there are more good athletes per capita in Cuba than in Japan.

But there are a lot of confounding factors, so I wouldn't read too much into it. For example, one needs to consider the amount of money invested into training and selection of athletes. The US is somewhat lackadaisical about selecting athletes at a young age, whereas the eastern bloc countries tend to be a bit more motivated....