News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by ahevia on Thursday September 23, 2021 @11:30AM (#28630647)
2. The alternative could be not using oil at all here. I don’t remember our ancestors needing plastic packaging to eat fruit.

Plastic packaging doesn’t always get buried either. Landfills aren’t exactly a solution because of toxins they leech into the surrounding soil. It could end up in bodies of water. It could end up burned in an incinerator which releases the CO2 + volatile organic compounds stored inside it (and volatile organic compounds are quite bad for human health)

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by gruez on Thursday September 23, 2021 @11:47AM (#28630862)
>Landfills aren’t exactly a solution because of toxins they leech into the surrounding soil.

1. how much "toxins" are we talking about here? You'd think that if they were toxic enough to cause problems with the surrounding soil when buried along with tons of other stuff, that they'll make the food they're in direct contact with absolutely inedible.

2. Landfills are lined to prevent this specific issue.

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by ahevia on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:26PM (#28631387)
1. Toxins over large timescales.(also I’m assuming they aren’t the only thing in the landfill) Most modern plastics won’t leech toxins onto your food in the short time it takes from field to fridge. However microplastics are a concern and they do end up on fruit and vegetables that are in plastic packaging. The amount of course varies.(factors such as type of plastic, temperature, friction, shipping method all impact this) The study of microplastics on human health is quite young but initial results don’t paint a pretty picture.

2. Good point! Errors in foundations or any permeable gaps can still cause leachate to escape. There is also the concern of gases escaping during the lifetime of landfills as well.

You also have an issue of land usage. We have a limited amount of land and that amount is expected to decrease as sea levels rise. I think landfills don’t provide much bang for buck in terms of land value as opposed farms, parks, (I’ve heard of landfills being turned into parks but we still have the concerns of low to moderate containments in the surrounding soil) nuclear/solar/wind farms (although luckily you can still use landfills for these since contact with the public would be minimal), and wildlife habitats. Any ban on plastics, even if it reduces the waste going to landfills by a tiny or fractional amount. Sounds like a win to me

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by gruez on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:04PM (#28631967)
>Toxins over large timescales.(also I’m assuming they aren’t the only thing in the landfill) Most modern plastics won’t leech toxins onto your food in the short time it takes from field to fridge.

What about the plastic wrapped foods that last for years? Are those just low in toxin and the plastic clamshell packaging for fruits/vegetables loaded with toxins?

>Errors in foundations or any permeable gaps can still cause leachate to escape. There is also the concern of gases escaping during the lifetime of landfills as well.

Without getting more specific about what what "toxins" consistns of, it's hard to know assess the actual risk of them. eg. for BPA wikipedia says:

>Despite a rapid soil and water half-life of 4.5 days, and an air half-life of less than one day, BPA's ubiquity makes it an important pollutant.

It's probably fine even if it leeches out into a landfill, and there's some cracks? By the time it leaks out it would have degraded already.

>We have a limited amount of land and that amount is expected to decrease as sea levels rise.

America is definitely not running out of landfill space anytime soon. For asia/europe incineration is an alternative

>I think landfills don’t provide much bang for buck in terms of land value as opposed farms

That sounds like a non-issue given that we have a functioning market for land?

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by labawi on Sunday September 26, 2021 @04:15PM (#28664248)
> a rapid soil and water half-life

One should keep in mind that degradation and half-life are technical terms with specific meaning - while the original substance is no more, in no way does it mean the products are less or more toxic. Often they are less toxic or even degrade fully (into CO₂, H₂O etc), for the most part, but not always and all of it.

Landfills are one of those places where numerous funny reaction take place, creating wondrous chemicals, that people haven't even dreamed of.

That being said, I don't worry much about chemical composition of fruit packaging and their degradation products in non-smoldering landfills.

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by ahevia on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:15PM (#28632107)
These are all great questions, but I am out of my element here. Microplastics & land usage aren’t my areas of expertise (just a casual interest) so I'm hoping someone else can come along and give you informative answers.
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by rualca on Thursday September 23, 2021 @04:29PM (#28634870)
> What about the plastic wrapped foods that last for years?

I appreciate a good whataboutism as the next guy, but please keep in mind that fruit already has short shelf life, and plastic packaging is not used for longevity or higiene but to protect the product from mechanical actions and to prebundle items.

> It's probably fine even if it leeches out into a landfill (...)

The whole point of using paper-based packaging is that this problem simply does not exist at all, it's recyclable, and the timespan it takes to biodegrade is not measured in geological time.

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by gruez on Thursday September 23, 2021 @07:02PM (#28636692)
>I appreciate a good whataboutism as the next guy

I fail to see how that's whataboutism. I'm not trying to justify one form of plastic packaging with another. I'm merely questioning how much stuff actually leeches out and how it compares to how much leeches out during normal consumption.

>plastic packaging is not used for longevity or higiene but to protect the product from mechanical actions and to prebundle items. The whole point of using paper-based packaging [...]

I'm not sure about you, but buying pre-packaged fruits from opaque bags does not sound very appealing to me.

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by rualca on Friday September 24, 2021 @02:37AM (#28639283)
> I fail to see how that's whataboutism. I'm not trying to justify one form of plastic packaging with another. I'm merely questioning how much stuff actually leeches out and how it compares to how much leeches out during normal consumption.

It's textbook whataboutism, in the letter and in the spirit. The proposal consists of replacing plastic-based packaging with paper-based packaging for fruits and vegetables, which have a notoriously short shelf life. You, on the other hand, tried to divert attentions to "plastic wrapped foods that last for years", as if it was relevant or meaningful. That's a totally unrelated usecase, which has zero to do with the discussion.

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by oneplane on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:38PM (#28631569)
Landfills are mostly just "lets push the problem forward and have the next generation deal with it". Yes, there is a lot of space we could use to fill up with trash, but everything is finite.

In the chain of raw resources -> refined resources -> partial assemblies -> assembled products -> used products -> waste all steps are finite, and it's just a matter of which limit we hit first. Instead of waiting and "hoping for the best" it would make much more sense to plan ahead and start limiting the growth and acceleration towards that finite limit so we have a chance at mitigation.

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by gruez on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:55PM (#28631846)
> Landfills are mostly just "lets push the problem forward and have the next generation deal with it". Yes, there is a lot of space we could use to fill up with trash, but everything is finite.

What timespan are we talking about here? Literally the next generation? Or a few hundred years from now? With the available space in the US I'm leaning towards the latter. With that in mind and recognizing the net present value of landfill space a few hundred years from now is close to zero, I can definitely get behind "lets push the problem forward and have the next generation deal with it".

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by rasz on Thursday September 23, 2021 @02:03PM (#28632775)
I have a handy clip demonstrating the problem as it exists today: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kZFKOzqptgE
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by fouric on Thursday September 23, 2021 @11:42AM (#28630789)
Clean incinerators have been around for at least a decade[1] - potentially longer, as the Japanese have been separating out their burnable garbage from non-burnable for years.

[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/13/science/earth/13trash.htm...

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by stronglikedan on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:13PM (#28631208)
A city near me does this, instead of recycling. Although, they still provide recycling bins, and still ask residents to separate their trash. I presume it's because it makes it easier for them to separate the burnable trash from the "wet" trash.
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by sysadmindotfail on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:32PM (#28631481)
I think indeed this is the likely future for the US. There's much stored energy potential in our waste that it seems like an eventuality.
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by ahevia on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:10PM (#28631157)
Hadn’t heard of this. Very cool! Thanks for sharing
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by fouric on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:12PM (#28632073)
You're welcome! And, to be clear, I share many of the concerns that you pointed out in your comment - plastic going into landfills and older, unclean incinerators is a problem, and it can be really hard (if not impossible) to tell its final destination. I just wanted to clarify that (the right) incinerators are a solution for disposal - but it'd be better to not use plastic in the first place (or, at least, not in disposable packaging - long-lived goods like phone cases and Legos are slightly better than one-time-use things like plastic bottles for sodas).
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by abandonliberty on Thursday September 23, 2021 @09:42PM (#28637742)
Everything here is a game of trade-offs, and we often get misled by instinctive/faulty reasoning.

Nuclear energy produces some of the most dangerous, long-lasting byproducts imaginable, but appropriately handled it's preferable to almost every traditional form of energy production.

While reducing our meat intake is vogue, the impact it will have on climate change is depressingly incremental. Dishonest ideological documentaries like Cow/Sea-spiracy frustrate scientists dedicating their lives to fix these problems. 92% of the carbon impact reduction of going vegan can be achieved by switching from beef to pork/chicken/fish, before considering that plants are grown in animal waste and vast parts of manufacturing rely on animal products. http://environmath.org/2018/06/17/paper-of-the-day-poore-nem...

We need to examine our assumptions here. Are we short on land? Can we build adequate containment facilities? Is the carbon impact of properly transporting/containing these long-lasting products greater or lower than fast-decomposing paper products that can immediately release carbon into the environment?

Unfortunately there are huge financial/personal interests here and it's hard to get past the misinformation. Recycling was one of the biggest lies sold by corporate interests. It's rarely a moral or environmental good, in spite of all the propaganda for it. (Aluminium and paper are exceptions).

The answer depends on having the right facilities to handle the waste products, whether hydrocarbon or paper-based.

Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by bennysomething on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:40PM (#28631600)
I don't know about you but I don't fancy the all potato diet of my Irish ancestors. Packaging does have benefits: prolongs shelf life thus reducing waste.
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by radu_floricica on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:15PM (#28631234)
It's food packaging. If we have to worry about food packaging leaking toxins, I think we have a much bigger problem than landfills.
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by kixiQu on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:17PM (#28631275)
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by JKCalhoun on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:18PM (#28631289)
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by ahevia on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:27PM (#28631409)
We do. Human consumption of microplastics :)
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by konfusinomicon on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:10PM (#28632042)
it's only a matter of time until evolution kicks in and gives us the capability to digest them
Re:Spain will ban selling fruit and vegetables in plastic co... by ahevia on Thursday September 23, 2021 @01:16PM (#28632139)
I cannot tell this if this is sarcasm or a misunderstanding of evolution, but I’m imaging a dystopian future where humans genetically modify themselves to consume plastic but are no longer able to eat the foods we eat today. Now that’s a good novel