News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by glitchc on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:22PM (#28618264)
While this is a cool idea, it's not terribly useful for anything more complex than a toy example. The fact that I need to physically wire the components and manually adjust coefficients every time I create a new program means that I can only really leave one complex program configured at a time. How do I switch between programs? Do I buy new THATs then?

It would be much more practical if the analog components could be configured digitally through a script, so that multiple programs could be constructed and run on the same compute platform. A hybrid platform of sorts.

Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by munificent on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:09PM (#28618892)
> The fact that I need to physically wire the components and manually adjust coefficients every time I create a new program means that I can only really leave one complex program configured at a time.

This is basically the reality of every musician making music with guitar pedals and modular synthesizers. And the answer is, yes, you physically make the thing you want. Once you're done with it, you tear it down to make the next thing. That's part of the magic.

It's like building something out of LEGOs. If you want to re-use the pieces, you need to take apart your creation.

Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by nextaccountic on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @05:58PM (#28622490)
Why can't it work like an FPGA? I set the coefficients in software, it programs the analog computer through a serial interface, and then I don't need to tweak knobs every time I want to change something.
Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by munificent on Thursday September 23, 2021 @12:09PM (#28631146)
That could be done, yes.

Perhaps a more interesting question is to ponder why an artist might not want that flexibility. How does it affect their creative process when in order to make a new sound the old one must be destroyed? Are there positives to that workflow?

Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by regularfry on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @06:23PM (#28622782)
It can do. Digital switching of analogue signal paths can absolutely be done. MAX335/336/337-type chips are one way of doing it, and they've been around for decades.
Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by buescher on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:32PM (#28618388)
A permanent analog computer is just an analog circuit. You can build a PCB with op-amps after you've proved it out.
Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by nereye on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:46PM (#28618564)
From a mainstream perspective, there are mixed mode ICs that contain a bunch of analog components (op amps, comparators, etc.) and allow you to configure them digitally. E.g. the whole PSoC series from Cypress (formerly, now Cypress is part of Siemens).

Slightly less mainstream, there is the concept of FPAA (field programmable analog array), which is the equivalent of an FPGA but for analog instead of digital.

E.g. see https://www.anadigm.com/fpaa.asp.

Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by throwawayboise on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:29PM (#28618353)
One of the features listed: "An interface for controlling THAT digitally to develop analog-digital hybrid programs"
Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by lambdatronics on Thursday September 23, 2021 @11:38AM (#28630747)
You're describing a 'field-programmable analog array' (FPAA), the analog equivalent of an FPGA.
Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by jazzyjackson on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:42PM (#28619349)
i’m not sure how to find the photos but on some old analog computers, the entire patch board is swappable. to run a program, you would choose from your physical library of patch-boards.

kind of like moving an AVR chip from one breadboard to another

Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by mpfundstein on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:34PM (#28618416)
so in your mind, are FPGAs also only useful for toy examples? also, how often do you think a pcb of an electrical product changes once deployed?
Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by djur on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @02:35PM (#28619993)
FPGAs are certainly far more useful due to the fact that you can design and simulate them digitally and then mass produce them from that design. You can work on as many FPGA designs as you want in parallel without having to physically set up and tear down each one in turn.

They also don't cost $350 a pop.

Re:The Analog Thing: An open source, educational, low-cost m... by jsilence on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @03:09PM (#28620423)
Might want to look into the Bespoke Synth.