News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by legerdemain on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:04PM (#28617984)
At my previous company, we didn't stop anyone from discussing pay. That's obviously illegal. What we did instead is make sure that everyone, including new college hires, understood that talking about pay almost always leads to interpersonal friction, resentment, conflict, lower work productivity, and slower progress of our company toward an IPO. In short, talking about pay would actively damage their bottom line, which is in not something in anyone's best interest. It's not a threat if you just explain how the real world works and that actions have consequences.
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by yupper32 on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:09PM (#28618059)
Is this satire?

Talking about salaries have always resulted in better or equal pay for everyone involved (except the higher ups, like you) in my experience, and the experience of everyone I know.

Your post sounds like companies claiming that unions would actually hurt you.

If you're underpaying people in order to get to an IPO, people deserve to be aware of that and know the risks involved.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by kube-system on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:02PM (#28618794)
I think the person you're responding to is referring to the social (not economic) outcomes that result when people realize they're paid differently than their peers. Depending on how diverse a team is (in terms of ability, experience, performance) this can open up discussions about what "equal pay" really means.

If ability, experience, and performance are part of how you pay your employees, then a discussion about comparative pay of employees inherently means you are opening up a discussion about the comparative ability, experience, and performance of employees.

I'm not saying that's a bad thing -- but -- some feelings might get hurt in the process.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by b3morales on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:44PM (#28619364)
Mostly agree, but I think there's a companion reason for the triggering of discomfort. The idea that pay is completely merit-based -- as you say "in terms of ability, experience, performance" -- is a comforting lie that we tell ourselves, in my experience. No company has truly objective decisions for salary. There is always a large handful of historical accident and personal relationships stirred in. (If nothing else, in tech a person's salary is partly determined by their previous salary at other companies!)

Discussing the raw numbers of pay exposes that fact as well.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by kube-system on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @01:49PM (#28619447)
For sure, pay is much more driven by immediate staffing needs for retention or hiring. This has more to do with the labor markets and work pipeline than anything about an individual employee.

But people say they should be paid based on ability, performance, and experience. So this is what the conversation will be centered around, whether it is the complete reality for the considerations made by the employer or not.

Alice won’t care that Bob was hired for $10K more because there was a labor shortage and the company was going to lose a contract if they couldn’t hire another person. She just wants her $10K. So, the marginal cost of hiring an additional employee is not only the cost of that employee, but the additional wage demand that would result from the rest of your workforce. This is likely why we see many companies giving bonuses in this labor crunch rather than higher base wages.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by usui on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:12PM (#28618104)
I'm not sure why you are interpreting the parent's comment as similar to "claiming that unions would actually hurt you". It's just a post talking about how management in companies works around the illegality of telling employees not to talk to about pay. It's in the first sentence.

It's not like the parent comment is defending the practice, just how it's done in practice to discourage employees. Yes, groups of employees that don't band together believe that it will hurt their own bottom line if they talk about pay.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by yupper32 on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:13PM (#28618119)
Are you saying that the poster is saying that they lie to their employees?

I'm honestly not sure what you're saying.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by mfogikds on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:31PM (#28618383)
"Talking about salaries have always resulted in better or equal pay for everyone involved"

What is the exact source on this? I highly doubt every company in existence has the budget to pay everyone "better or equal"

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by makeitdouble on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:56PM (#28618696)
You’ll need pretty solid justifications to lower salaries. In a case where a bunch of employees realize they’re underpaid, there’s only three natural outcomes:

- lower paid employees don’t get anything, and start looking for a better paying job

- lower paid employees get compensatory raises

- lower paid employees get nothing and the higher paid members are expected to get lower pays. They proceed to leave for greener pastures (and they only need to find at least equal paying jobs to make it worth it)

The scenario where salaries go down and employees don’t do anything is unrealistic.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by yupper32 on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:33PM (#28618404)
I address that in the second half of the sentence: "in my experience, and the experience of everyone I know."

I'm not claiming a universal truth. I do think that the original post is much farther away from the truth than my claim, though.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by mfogikds on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:34PM (#28618422)
Have you done an actual survey? I doubt you know the inner workings of every workplace of everyone you know.
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by gooseus on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:21PM (#28618244)
This approach works for all kinds of destructive conversations in the workplace.

You don't need to explicitly stop people from complaining about a manager's behavior or other toxic workplace features, you just need to explain to people how discussions around how they feel about a particular management style almost always leads to interpersonal friction, resentment, conflict, lower work productivity, and slower progress of our company toward an IPO.

You see, it's not a threat if you just explain how the real world works and that actions have consequences. /s

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by willcipriano on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:09PM (#28618067)
I don't think I ever talked about pay with my coworkers, but the first thing I'd do if someone gave me that speech would be talk about pay. The lady doth protest too much, methinks.
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by brandonmenc on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:14PM (#28618147)
> talking about pay almost always leads to interpersonal friction, resentment, conflict

You could take this as an indication that your pay scale is screwed up.

But I guess it's easier to just bully your employees.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by handrous on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:23PM (#28618280)
Telling—being very generous—a lie couched in exaggerated hypotheticals (the lie: if sharing comp harms the company, it's the fault of the person who shared it, not management; exaggeration: this will have some huge and harmful effect on the company such that employees are significantly harmed) to your employees to keep them from acting in their own best interest is—still being very generous—kinda shitty.
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by farmerstan on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:17PM (#28618191)
Sorry but this is complete bullshit. Everyone should be on an even playing field. Keeping secrets only helps the execs control the peons. The best places I’ve worked at was very open and transparent. I mentioned below that sharing salary helps everyone. It doesn’t hurt the company at all unless the owners want to save every penny they have for themselves.
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by antisthenes on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:11PM (#28618101)
> What we did instead is make sure that everyone, including new college hires, understood that talking about pay almost always leads to interpersonal friction, resentment, conflict, lower work productivity, and slower progress of our company toward an IPO.

I hope you've provided some very concrete examples how talking about pay delayed an IPO by a certain period of time, and quantified how much exactly hires were losing because of it, in exact dollar values.

Because otherwise, it's just a gaslighting scare tactic.

> It's not a threat if you just explain how the real world works and that actions have consequences.

One of the consequences of bullshitting new hires with vague examples of how the real world works is that you end up with people willing to drink the kool-aid, regardless of their skills and ability. Now maybe that was your primary goal in the first place, but somehow I doubt it.

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by nexuist on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @02:34PM (#28619983)
> talking about pay almost always leads to interpersonal friction, resentment, conflict, lower work productivity, and slower progress of our company toward an IPO

Try this one with your SO:

"Talking about chores almost always leads to interpersonal friction, resentment, conflict, lower work productivity, and slower progress of our relationship towards marriage"

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by jahewson on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:52PM (#28618651)
Ah so you gaslighted them, nice.
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by triceratops on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:25PM (#28618300)
Pro athletes' contracts are fairly public knowledge. Does that affect how professional sports teams perform?
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by legerdemain on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:40PM (#28618493)
Yes? Teams lose valuable players all the time, often to everyone's detriment, over failed contract negotiations. Pay in professional sports is an extremely sore topic. See US women's soccer last year.
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by triceratops on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @02:28PM (#28619917)
> Teams lose valuable players all the time

If they were that valuable, they should've paid them accordingly. Compensation is the most direct marker of "value". If you're valued more, you get paid more.

> often to everyone's detriment

Presumably not the acquiring team's.

> See US women's soccer last year

They played 1 game in 2020, which they won. This year, their W-D-L record reads 15-3-2, which is pretty damn good.[1] Their contract negotiations might have been fractious, but they still performed on the field.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_women%27s_nation...

Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by dmead on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:26PM (#28618307)
I make it a point to talk about pay on the regular. I want to know if I'm getting fucked or not.
Re:Workers are often told not to talk about pay. That's not ... by the_gipsy on Wednesday September 22, 2021 @12:36PM (#28618443)
This is hilarious!