Of course this supports the point even more that the article's premise is idiotic.
Funny enough you won't find many preppers in countries/regions that actually qualify as unstable, because it is very expensive to stockpile food reserves, water, medicine, generators, fuel, gold, valuables, guns, ammo, communication equipment. It is a very "first world" hobby.
Color me guilty! For me it started with cooking, that led to gardening, then hunting. Combine that with camping and here I am, part of a small group of very diverse people who like to spend time with as little modern conveniences as possible, as far away from modern life with the smallest possible food print.
We leave our homes with what we can carry, walk as far as we can, collect food en route and hide as good as we can.
If I would be a classic prepper, I would do this with the most important people in the world: my family, but I do not. It is just for fun and to meet different people and how to take care of each other without outside assistance. Challenging and suitable for everyone since you can do it for as long or short, as far or as close as your means allow you to.
Growing your own produce is a pretty good way to keep yourself busy (and i find it relaxing), learn more about plants in general, as well as lets you have a better idea of what actually goes into your meals (vs store bought produce, which might have certain pesticides or other additives).
The same goes for cooking, for which there are also very tangible and immediate financial benefits, when compared to eating out. So much so, that people have organized various communities around the idea of cooking stuff yourself and doing so in an efficient manner, for example: https://www.reddit.com/r/MealPrepSunday/top/?t=month
Hunting also makes you develop more appreciation for having meat in general - personally, after having to drag a carcass from the forest all the way home and to help my dad prepare the meat made me view it as something to have occasionally, not as often as other people might. Of course, learning firearms safety and a thing or two about how to behave in forests is useful as well.
Of course, some people might take it a bit too far - like having a bunker in their basement or stockpiling MREs for years, many of which will simply go bad, but i'd argue that most things, even having your own generator are pretty reasonable in the grand scheme of things, especially in regards to bad weather conditions and inconsistent power supply.
Not by definition. Maybe in practice.
You might be a 'prepper' even if you think the chance of society collapsing is only 0.1% because you think it's a prudent hedge against a highly unlikely worst-case scenario. This might be rational from a personal perspective if you have enough wealth to burn such that 'prepping' for this 0.1% situation only costs 0.01% of your net worth.
How can it be sensible if one thinks it's 'highly unlikely'?
If one is very rich, then prepping may be financially affordable, but that doesn't make it cognitively rational.
Hedging a highly unlikely situation can still be sensible. Those two things are definitely not mutually exclusive.
If all your net worth is tied up in your house, it's probably sensible and rational to get fire insurance on your house, even if it's highly unlikely that your house will burn down. This question has been studied extensively in utility theory.
Y = your net worth
You can trade-off one with the other.
People with lots of Y will be more happy to reduce Y in order to reduce X, because the marginal utility of Y declines with larger values of Y, whereas marginal utility of X remains roughly the same irrespective of values of Y.
> Fires happen often enough, but some events are low enough probability not to worry about.
This ignores the second part of X, which is magnitude_of_badness. Your house burning down has a smaller magnitude_of_badness than society collapsing which will likely lead to death.
It's also ignoring the marginal utility of wealth for large values of Y. Even if X is small, people with large Y will be more happy to reduce Y in order to reduce X.
On a sidenote, the talk of social collapse is a popular propaganda theme of the extreme right.
As others have noted, not necessarily - there are many shades here. Depending on your situation, being prepared for unforeseen situations is not paranoiac but sensible. The key point is how much time, effort, and mental energy you put in this. Having some cash, food and basic tools just in case is one thing - piling up tons of stuff and worrying constantly is something different. The former is actually something to be promoted as a healthy attitude in an ever-changing world. And even if noting serious happens until the end of your life, you have the comfort of knowing, "At least I'm a bit prepared."
Electricity may not be the best proxy for stability, but it's a huge deal in my life, and I think important for a lot of of those ~7.55B. Electricity also requires a lot of infrastructure.
I don't think it changes your analysis. I wanted to highlight Stability for a random HN reader is probably more complex than stability for a random human.
They romanticized self sufficient farming. Isn't that 'prepping' taken to the extreme ?
What would give an indication is how many there are. And the article references no polls or surveys or statistics on the number of preppers in Germany. The closest it comes is,
"There are around 20m preppers in the world today according to Bradley Garrett, an academic who has studied them; anywhere from 5m-15m are thought to be in America."
Let's say, 10M are in the US. That leaves 10M out of ~7.55B in the rest of the world. Assuming uniform prevalence, that's 0.13% of the population.
This is typical of much of modern journalism. Long-form emotional tone painting and little of substance.