Re:Ask HN: Is anyone monitoring popular apps to check if the...
by fragmede on Sunday September 19, 2021 @12:29PM
(#28585603)
Shazam was bought by Apple several years ago, but identifying music is a different beast from picking out the phrase Hey Siri/Google/Alexa.
Re:Ask HN: Is anyone monitoring popular apps to check if the...
by kurthr on Monday September 20, 2021 @12:24PM
(#28595528)
Those are both additional proof cases, but I wasn't talking about either Shazam (which does a lot of processing remotely) or "wake words" although I'm familiar with the accuracy and compute power requirements for those. Multi-keyword detection for advertising with >50% FAR/FRR is much easier than either of them. A conversation is likely to hear the word (or related ones) mentioned multiple time by multiple parties and the matcher can be tuned to the individual locally.
However, your description of what it would need to work is woefully naïve. There were startup funded apps that matched entire recorded song libraries to ambient sound (along with location) in the age of flip phones to track copyright violations in clubs. They relied on matching compressed periodogram hashes with an error tolerant database. The databases were large, but not unwieldy, and the computational load reasonable in the early 2000s. The ability to craft a database to a person to match a large set of commercial words/names with very low bandwidth is not impossible. Machine learning has made it easier.