Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (...
by Moodles on Thursday September 16, 2021 @12:09PM
(#28553578)
> We're not talking about cancer. We're talking about things that involve human psychology and behavior.
Yes, it's a slightly different field. I don't see how that changes the point. The point is that plenty of people who aren't first hand victims of something still come up with solutions for it. This is just an example of someone who didn't. I don't really see how framing it about privileged vs not privileged inventors is helpful. All that matters is the technology ideas and how best to come up with them. And we all agree user research is good.
Re:The worst thing I read this year, and what it taught me (...
by GavinMcG on Thursday September 16, 2021 @06:55PM
(#28558860)
Bringing up privilege is important because someone who is aware of it can cut off this sort of mistake before they make them. We indeed agree that user research is good. So I'd imagine we agree that it's good to think "I should put the perspective and experiences of my users front and center." And that's exactly what it takes to not be privileged.
Privilege is why they didn't do "better user research": the person making the proposal doesn't even consider those they would impact.