That’s exactly where replay should shine. Stick a breakpoint in your error handler, then rewind when it breaks.

Actually it might be even easier — if your specific error shows up in the console, there's a handy rewind button right beside it :)

If an error causes an exception there is an option to suspend execution when one is thrown.

But typically it will throw an exception _after_ the interesting code happened. For instance it might throw a NullPointerException, but you want to know what set it to null in the first place. With breakpoints you have to suspend on exception, and then add additional breakpoints earlier in the code, and then rerun the code. With rewind you can just step backwards.