what this argument boils down to, for me, is "we need to keep killing foreigners so that our economy doesn't suffer", and this is a morally reprehensible position.
Plus, how much of the money that we funnel to Iraq actually goes back to the US economy, compared to if we spent it in the US directly?
http://www.npr.org/2011/06/25/137414737/among-the-costs-of-w...
We are spending 20 billion a year to truck energy supplies across some of the worst terrain in the world so that we can provide AC to thousands of horridly inefficient tents for our soldiers in the field. For comparison, that's more than the entire yearly budget of NASA. And its only one of numerous logistics and support costs we incur in our active warzones.
This might be a good time to read Paul Graham's article on PR: http://www.paulgraham.com/submarine.html
(I don't mean this as an attack on araes or the suggestion to reduce military spending.)
The main point not being the specific final total, but rather that the cost, and other logistical costs like it, would be reduced or possibly eliminated if troops weren't in the field.
Once you realize that the military is not a collection of armed forces so much as it is the US's largest social welfare program, these policies and figures start to make more sense. Put it this way: We're paying our troops there so we don't have to pay them here.
Don't look for this to change anytime soon.