The other challenge for America is that it gets drastically more applications than Canada does (not to mention that IIRC Canada does have a bottleneck). I think putting region restrictions/incentives for immigration might be better, so that you give preference to residency outside of already populated areas/less populated states.
If you want to make it attractive to live in some region, just create good jobs there and people will follow. Trying to force immigrants to live there if there are no good jobs sounds like a terrible bandaid.
I'll preface this by saying that this my anecdotal understanding of the Canadian immigration process. Essentially provinces can nominate the immigration of certain desirable professionals, boosting their cases to the top of the queue for an immigrant visa. It comes with a requirement to live and work in the sponsoring province for a minimum period of time - something like 3 years. Immigrants are also eligible to apply for citizenship after 3 years of residency, and citizens have the right to live and work anywhere. From my understanding of the provincial nominee system is that they strongly prefer that you have an existing social and family network within the province, encouraging you to stay put even after you become a citizen.
You could ask for proof of purchase from local stores, check the address of the employer to see if the employer is located in that area. Check train/bus tickets.
> if there are no good jobs sounds like a terrible bandaid.
It depends, maybe you need workforce in some occupations in that area, so you tell immigrants who have expertise in that domain to stay in that area and fi you spend X years you will get the citizenship after that you are free to move in the country.
Its a fair deal, if the immigrant does not like he/she just wont come.
Secondly, you know how you fill out taxes every year & you have to say where your primary residence was for tax purposes? That's how you enforce it.
My understanding is that there's one province (Quebec) that select it's own immigrants (quotas are per province).
They can't force anyone to stay so they tune their selection algorithm to match profiles that are most likely to stay.
[1] https://www.canada.ca/en/immigration-refugees-citizenship/se...
As the current system is being abused by Indian consulting companies plahying the numbers games and filing for as many people as possibly to place them at low(er) income roles
https://www.epi.org/blog/new-data-infosys-tata-abuse-h-1b-pr...
Right. Trump tried proposing a merit-based immigration system while he was in office. It quickly got shouted down and fell off the radar, by people and factions who didn't want to consider that different people have varying levels of merit to offer society.
It's to avoid people using passports of convenience to game the system.
> He's been in the India backlog for a decade.
Truth is, a lot of that backlog is self-imposed. H1B are supposed to be for real employment for a specialty occupation. There are "Body Shops", mostly Indian owned, that will submit fraudulent applications to import cheap underqualified labor in the country. [0] [1]
If the people working at these body shops or their owners simply decided to start following the law, this would clear the backlog almost instantly.
> What the US needs is top-down immigration reform and a points-based program like Canada and Australia. Those countries get to cherry-pick the most skilled immigrants and the most likely to thrive in their new homes.
And yet how does it explains the brain drain these two countries have towards... the US!
[0] https://www.nbcbayarea.com/news/local/silicon-valleys-body-s...
[1] https://cis.org/North/Indian-Body-Shop-Indicted-Abuse-H1B-Pr...
Yes I'm sure people looking to immigrate to the US are checks notes becoming British Citizens. A country with notoriously difficult immigration requirements. Citizenship requires 5+ years in most instances to obtain (with a few small exceptions). Generally speaking all first-world countries have stringent rules.
> Truth is, a lot of that backlog is self-imposed. H1B are supposed to be for real employment for a specialty occupation.
I'm not sure that's what self-imposed means.
> And yet how does it explains the brain drain these two countries have towards... the US!
Immigration to the US is effectively suspended. [0] These days those folks are going to Canada. [1]
'"While the States has gone, 'Let's make it difficult to get the employees here on a visa,' Canada's gone the exact opposite, and it's beneficial for Canada," says Alex Norman, the other co-founder of TechToronto. "You had a fast-growing ecosystem here that's been getting a shot of steroids."'
That's what it looks like when you hang a "NO VACANCIES" sign in the window.
[0] https://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en/News/visas-news/s...
[1] https://www.npr.org/2020/01/27/799402801/canada-wins-u-s-los...
First world might, other countries don't. So it would be easy to get citizenship from one of those and then use it to bypass the cap.
> I'm not sure that's what self-imposed means.
Indian nationals applying for fraudulent visas.
> and it's beneficial for Canada
Is it really? How's the VC ecosystem? Unicorns? Not long ago the government bragged to investors that Canadians devs were worth 50K less than their American counterparts. [0]
[0] https://globalnews.ca/news/4178326/amazon-vancouver-tech-wor...
In this case I was saying that quotas and caps would still apply but be basted on citizenship instead of place of birth. If everyone started buying Cayman Islands citizenship instead, the quota would fill up fast.
> Indian nationals applying for fraudulent visas.
Again, that's not self-imposed.
> Is it really? How's the VC ecosystem? Unicorns? Not long ago the government bragged to investors that Canadians devs were worth 50K less than their American counterparts. [0]
This is a new phenomenon, and it takes time to turn a boat. I think it would be pretty myopic not to see the trend, however. The ecosystem will follow in time.
[edit] I think Shopify was the defining moment when things started to turn. If an Ottawa startup can reach a $200B market cap in a few years, that's going to create a lot of wealth, spawn its own startups and an investment ecosystem in its own right.
Who cares if India and China become the majority of immigrations? What difference does it make?
What the US needs is top-down immigration reform and a points-based program like Canada and Australia. Those countries get to cherry-pick the most skilled immigrants and the most likely to thrive in their new homes.
Who cares where they were born?! That's literally the least interesting thing about an immigration petition.