News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by frostburg on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:48PM (#28486156)
"Creso" wheat, which is a popular cultivar in its native Italy and has been used around the world to create other variants, was obtained from seeds irradiated with neutrons and gamma rays.

I always mention this to people irrationally worried about eating GMO food featuring precise edits.

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by beaconstudios on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:58PM (#28486248)
I'm only vaguely familiar with the GMO debate, but isn't the primary concern that they make food into controllable IP, locking farmers into a SaaS-like subscription lock in, not allowed to replant their own seeds?

Although I'm sure there are people who are just worried about the scary-sounding nature of "genetic modification", the IP angle struck me as a reasonable concern when I heard it.

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by frostburg on Friday September 10, 2021 @04:09PM (#28486354)
What you mention is a genuine concern (however as far as I understand the issue is not precisely that one - it's not generally efficient for farmers to use their own seeds anyway), but I'm talking about people that think that GMO food is going to harm their health for nebulous reasons.
Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by amanaplanacanal on Saturday September 11, 2021 @11:02AM (#28492507)
> it's not generally efficient for farmers to use their own seeds anyway

This would certainly seem to be true for commercial farmers in the first world. I don’t know if it applies as much in the third world though.

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by R0b0t1 on Friday September 10, 2021 @05:10PM (#28486925)
No, it's not the main concern usually. Most people who are anti-GMO are against the gene editing part and its potential effects on the human genome.

If you probe deeply enough you realize there's not much there.

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by CapstanRoller on Friday September 10, 2021 @08:43PM (#28488429)
The other concern is about genetically engineered glypohsate-resistant "Roundup Ready" crops, which facilitate increased and imprudent usage of glyphosate.
Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by boibombeiro on Friday September 10, 2021 @09:15PM (#28488620)
Haven't the usage of glyphosate been linked with the decline of bees population?
Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by progre on Saturday September 11, 2021 @02:30AM (#28489835)
Not directly, I think. The recent debate over declining bee population has has been over pesticides from the neonicotineide family.

But I think the current concensus is that the decline in bees populations is due to a combination of

- Pollen sources being increasingly from monocultures (yes, roundup use is a factor in this) possibly making bees kinda malnourished

- Bee populations are themselves getting less diverse due to comercial breeding practices making bees less resilient to changes in the environment

- Mites and decieses that has been around since forever

Anyway, declining bee populations, while sad, is a tiny part of the problem: Insect populations across the board is vanishing.

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by theptip on Saturday September 11, 2021 @03:41AM (#28490118)
From the source: https://www.greenpeace.org/usa/sustainable-agriculture/issue...

A summary of their concerns would be:

* GMO tend to be “pesticide resistant” (eg roundup-ready) and more pesticide is bad for humans and the environment

* GMO has not been proven to be safe for human consumption

* GMO turns agriculture into IP which threatens the sovereignty of farmers

So yes, the IP concern is a big one for anti-GM campaigners, but I’d not say it’s the primary one.

(As an aside, I think the pesticide concerns are quite strong, but not all GM crops encourage pesticide use, so I’d rather restrict pesticides than GM. I don’t find the human safety concerns convincing. And the IP concerns are quite compelling to me, but again I think these could be better fixed elsewhere in the system, for example by state funded GM research or IP law reform, rather than banning GMOs.)

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by amanaplanacanal on Saturday September 11, 2021 @11:04AM (#28492526)
Isn’t there also a concern about these genes escaping by cross pollination into wild plants?
Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by tialaramex on Friday September 10, 2021 @04:43PM (#28486669)
For modern industrial farming (ie not you on a patch of ground you manage with tools you can pick up and carry) seeds are usually anyway purchased in bulk from a specialist. What you've described is a problem, but it's coincidental to the existence of GM.

AIUI The spectre of GMO preventing seed saving got into the picture by the following route:

1. GMO opponents feared a GMO could spread in the wild, which sure enough can happen, and as with the whole "Vaccine might turn me into a chimp" (the Astrazeneca vaccine is based on a virus that infects Chimpanzees) thing they exaggerated the resulting risk, they argued that it's possible for genetics from the GMO to be copied into other things. So, maybe your weedkiller resistance gene gets copied into the weeds by some means.

2. GMO developers went OK, we can make a "terminator" feature so the modified plants don't reproduce, mitigating the problem. Nobody relies on self-seeding of crops for industrialised farming anyway and that'll fix your concern right?

3. Terminator is now an excuse to say the GMO seeds are deliberately broken to prevent seed saving.

This is especially remarkable because Terminator is a specific feature, not included in most GM organisms, so, if that's really what you're afraid of then you'd only be opposed to those GMOs not the whole concept.

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by User23 on Friday September 10, 2021 @07:47PM (#28488126)
Regular old hybrids also don't grow true from harvested seed. That's pretty much the whole point of heirloom plants. For example, it's not as if Big Apple intentionally sells apples with worthless seeds, that's just how fruit trees work.

It would be pretty cool though if some scientists actually did engineer plants with desirable properties that grow true from seed, but with the perverse incentives currently in place I'm not holding my breath on that one.

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by beaconstudios on Friday September 10, 2021 @04:55PM (#28486779)
Thanks for the clarification, sounds like the usual rationalisation dance from when people are resistant to something new.
Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by Tuna-Fish on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:08PM (#28487454)
And just to expand on the above, modern farming heavily exploits heterosis (1) for greatly improved yields and healthier crops, even when not using "GMO" crops.

This means that while seed saving is, strictly speaking, possible, it is uneconomical -- properly fully heterozygotic seeds coming from an organization dedicated to making them will yield so much more than the second generation descending from those seeds (or any other natural seed stock) that everyone will gladly pay for them.

(1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heterosis

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by a1369209993 on Friday September 10, 2021 @06:06PM (#28487442)
> isn't the primary concern that they make food into controllable IP, locking farmers into a SaaS-like subscription lock in, not allowed to replant their own seeds?

That's a concern (along with IP trolls suing farmers for infringment after cross-pollination and "terminator" features of GM crops's pollen interfering with self-seeding of said cross-pollinated crops), but IME it seems like the primary concern (ie, of most people complaining about it) is the stupid scary-soundingness one. (Which is annoying, because the former is a very real and serious problem, as it exacerbates existing centralization of food production.)

Re:Atomic Gardening (2017) by MomoXenosaga on Saturday September 11, 2021 @06:02AM (#28490724)
It's more that people don't want things to end up like the US where the food industry has gone completely insane.