News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twenty percent of a picture of a dog by dcolkitt on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:48PM (#28474472)
Digital replications of paintings are perfect. So it’s just as easy to say:

If I buy an NFT, I have a monkey as my Twitter avatar. You don’t (not the same monkey, anyway).

Re:Twenty percent of a picture of a dog by mattnewton on Thursday September 09, 2021 @04:58PM (#28474571)
Everyone can have the exact same monkey down to each bit, it’s just that you have a note on a blockchain that says you bought the monkey and no one else did.

It’s like if we had matter replicators from the Star Trek universe and anyone could print a van goh copy down to the same molecular structure and hang it on their wall, but you bought an impractical-to-forge piece of paper that says yours is the original.

Re:Twenty percent of a picture of a dog by marcus_holmes on Friday September 10, 2021 @03:18AM (#28478652)
I could write "I bought the monkey picture" on a piece of paper and put it in a sealed envelope and hide it in a drawer - same effect.

It only matters to people that it matters to. Anyone unconnected to the blockchain that stores this information doesn't give a monkey's about it.

Imagine that I and the monkey-picture-owner use the monkey picture as an avatar. They say "you can't use that, I bought it - look at this blockchain". I say "no I bought it - look at this piece of paper in the drawer". In general in society we would then have a court case and a judge would decide, and the police would enforce it. In this case - nothing. There's literally nothing the "owner" can do. If you can't enforce your ownership, in what sense do you own anything?