News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by orwin on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:37AM (#28434748)
Agree, but the snark against nuclear is unwarranted.

As the author said, we don't need 100% today. And he acknowledge that problems exist, and they have to be solved. Wehn reading him, i have the impression that he acknowledge that some issues/blocks can take some time to clear. Why gamble? Just take nuclear as a crutch, plan for 100 year of pilatable nuclear + hydro baseload and 30 year of gaz peakers, to clear the blocks in front of renewables, and if the issues are fixed in the next 30-50 years, great, you can decommission the nuclear plants early!

If you really think GW is the biggest issue of this century, not using all available tools, however dangerous you think they might be, to help you with your issue is plain dumb.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by blumio on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:49AM (#28434869)
I'm trying to understand from what you got your snark from. Do you refer to:

"I think the renewable industry will end up better and cheaper than the current system but if I'm wrong about the renewables industry being good at optimising that bundle of benefits, problems and"?

As far as I know, nuclear fuel is rare and we don't have a solution to thorium reactors yet.

I would personally not mind more nuclear were it makes sense though. Germany is not very suited though as it's quite populated but there is plenty of empty space in USA.

There is a risk though as current nuclear power station have issues in drought situations.

Nonetheless I haven't read is arguments. Perhaps he wrote about it.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by FabHK on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:09PM (#28435117)
> I'm trying to understand from what you got your snark from. Do you refer to [...]

I think GP might refer to footnote 1 in the article:

> [...] one could technically replace fossil fuels with nuclear power. it would just be more expensive, more dangerous and slower - so probably only a few billion dead.

Personally, I think modern nuclear reactors (that are optimised for safety and efficiency, not for generating nuclear weapons material) and a tad more sensible regulation could make nuclear power safe and cheap, and turn nuclear (together with renewables, of course) into a formidable weapon against global warming.

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by lukeschlather on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:01PM (#28435020)
What do you think nuclear costs? I think you are probably unintentionally operating on a fallacy in this article, which is using decade-old costs. Renewables and storage have fallen in price massively. Nuclear was a great idea a decade ago but when you look at the costs there's no reason anymore. It's just too expensive.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by Manuel_D on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:03PM (#28435734)
Nuclear's cost is substantially less when built at scale. During serial production during the 1960s and 70s nuclear power costs averaged about $1B per GW of capacity[1]. And with a capacity factor of near 100% versus ~30% for renewables other than hydro this is very cost competitive. Furthermore the question of storage to make renewables feasible is typically met with assumptions that batteries will scale by a factor of 100, or that a breakthrough will be made in another form of storage like liquid metal batteries, hydrogen, compressed air, or something else. None of these have been deployed at scale.

1. https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Overnight-Construction-C...

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by acidburnNSA on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:30PM (#28435350)
Not really true when you consider systems costs [1]. The way Korea and China and Russia are making nuclear plants right now, nuclear still has a huge role to play. If you look at the current boondoggles only then I could see why you'd think what you say.

[1] https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joule.2018.08.006

Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by andromeduck on Monday September 06, 2021 @01:23PM (#28435922)
Renewables are only cheap because they can freeload on the variability of coal and gas. Start pricing carbon and QoS and things will change quickly.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by Aachen on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:50AM (#28434885)
What is GW? Something to do with nuclear I presume but I'm not sure who you're calling dumb.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by dredmorbius on Monday September 06, 2021 @12:40PM (#28435445)
Given that in energy discussion, "GW" usually means gigawatt, appropriating it for "global warming" as OP did was a poor choice.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by DFHippie on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:55AM (#28434941)
Global warming.
Re:Fallacies I have encountered when disccusing 100% renewab... by Aachen on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:59AM (#28434999)
Ah, I was thinking in the wrong direction. Thanks.