News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by mmarq on Monday September 06, 2021 @06:47AM (#28432400)
The very fact that my iPhone is lighter than my father’s calculator, should say something at least about raw materials.
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by i_am_proteus on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:14AM (#28432567)
Similarly, my bicycle is lighter than my father's horse.

Mass alone does not tell the whole story.

Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by taneq on Monday September 06, 2021 @09:25AM (#28433410)
I'm actually curious, which one DOES take more resources all up? And what do you count as a resource? ie. the bicycle would take far more coal and iron ore (neither of which the horse needs) but the horse would use up far more water and otherwise edible grains.
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by boudin on Monday September 06, 2021 @11:05AM (#28434373)
There's actually more to take into account to push the subject a lot. The human on a bicycle also needs food and water to move the bicycle. Which is the more efficient at converting those resources into movement and in which scenario ?
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by i_am_proteus on Monday September 06, 2021 @03:39PM (#28437174)
The horse also generates more power than a human on a bicycle.

The horse does not need improved roads the way most bicycles do, and is more reliable off road than most mountain bikes.

Lots of food for thought here.

Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by goatlover on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:25PM (#28439541)
A horse also needs food and shelter and they poop. An early argument in favor of cars over horses were that cars didn’t leave fecal matter everywhere in cities.
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by imtringued on Monday September 06, 2021 @05:59PM (#28438567)
An electric bike does not need to be fed with crops.
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by mmarq on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:06AM (#28432874)
And it also requires much less energy and maintenance to be produced and operated. Growth.
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by boudin on Monday September 06, 2021 @09:32AM (#28433463)
First, that might just mean that you live at a higher altitude than your father, but I guess you meant mass.

Then, it might just mean that your father's calculator use material of higher density.

More seriously. when building something, there's a lot more material than what comes in the final product: - the scrap generated by the by the manufacturing process. The more elements, the more it's going to be. - the number of defects, for every parts of the device (for some parts it will be extremely low, for some it would be quite higher, but there's always some). Granted, some defects can be re-purposed, but it's not always the case - The raw materials to actually manufacture (like water) - The average number of repairs required over a lifetime (replacing the screen on a iphone is quite frequent) - The materials required to build the supply chain that can build such devices. - The materials required to generate the energy required to build the factories.

And there's plenty of other things to take into account. In the end it's not about the volume of raw material as such, that doesn't mean much as it is. It's for each material, to take into consideration if it's renewable, what's the impact of extracting it and many other questions.

Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by mmarq on Monday September 06, 2021 @09:57AM (#28433660)
I think it’s undeniable that iPhone uses less materials than all the objects it replaces combined, even if it consumes more materials and pollutes more than a 1970s programmable calculator (and I’m not too sure about that), it certainly requires less resources than a calculator plus a mobile phone plus a stereo plus blablabla
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by boudin on Monday September 06, 2021 @10:58AM (#28434296)
It's not undeniable at all, you made an assertion without any base. This is far from being obvious, there's way too much things to take into consideration to be able to make such claim out of thin air.
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by dariosalvi78 on Monday September 06, 2021 @07:27AM (#28432648)
well, have you considered how much material is used for producing that iPhone? have you got an idea of how much water is used for that tshirt you probably wearing right now?
Re:People are realizing that degrowth is bad by mmarq on Monday September 06, 2021 @08:05AM (#28432868)
Lots of material would go into the production of all the tools it replaces. A programmable calculator, a mobile phone a GameBoy, a music player, my mother’s cook books, etc… combined will likely require more raw materials.