News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When patents attack Android by davidu on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:00PM (#2842761)
Drummond is very smart. And he's always been friendly to me. But that's not to be confused with Google being the good guy. They tried to buy these patents and failed.

And they claim that they aren't litigious with patents, and they haven't been yet. But to paint them as the victim is disingenuous -- while they don't use patents offensively, they have many other tools at their disposal that they do use offensively, market share in advertising and search amongst them.

Google is a massive company with massive resources. They happen to be exceptionally smart and know how to use tools outside of litigation to achieve their means -- but that doesn't make them any less a monopoly or anti-competitive company; far from it.

It's impossible to view Drummond's post in a box -- it's not just about how patents hinder innovation -- /everybody knows that/ already. But Google does everything for a reason, they are very strategic. Since Google knows it has better tools to be competitive outside of patents, it is in their interest to eliminate patents as a source of pressure from competitors.

And if you invent something amazing, and you patent it, and then Google decides to copy you -- you may not feel that patents hinder innovation as much as you do right now. But since they are a behemoth with lots of other tools at their disposal, they want to eliminate a favorite weapon of their competitors. Smart, but altruistic it may not be.

Re:When patents attack Android by mithaler on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:19PM (#2842873)
I don't understand your comment. The OP is about Android being attacked through patents instead of through innovation, and you don't seem to be denying that that's what's happening. The article doesn't claim that "Google is always good", nor even that Google never uses anti-competitive practices. So what exactly are you objecting to? I don't think anyone here needs to be reminded that Google is a business and wants to make money.
Re:When patents attack Android by chocopuff on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:53PM (#2843023)
The hypocrisy is unbelievable: Google is a major investor in patent troll firm Intellectual Ventures.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_Ventures

http://www.techflash.com/seattle/2011/05/intellectual-ventur...

Amazon, Apple, Cisco, eBay, Microsoft, etc. are also investors but they are not acting like whiny babies and acting all high and mighty going around preaching about how patents are destroying innovation.

Fact 1:

-------

Google was willing to pay for $3-$4 billion for the same Nortel patents.

Fact 2:

-------

Google's page rank algorithm is patented. if you don't believe in patents then why the hell do you own patents?

Fact 3:

-------

Let me quote another commenter on another blog: "How many small and innovative companies has Google killed off by replicating what they do and making it available for free? Great way to keep the next Google from springing up."

Message to Google:

------------------

You can use other people's technology, you just have to pay for them. You are being sued left and right not because there's some organized propaganda against you, it's because you STOLE from other companies.

Re:When patents attack Android by chaz on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:31PM (#2843211)
According to PaidContent, about IV investors:

Also, some of these companies, including Google and Cisco, have been investors for many years, and in the early years IV had a very different tone. Back then, the giant patent-holding company, which was founded by ex-Microsoft CTO Nathan Myhrvold, billed itself as a “patent defense fund.” (Clearly, it hasn’t turned out that way. ) http://paidcontent.org/article/419-giant-patent-holder-intel...

IV was founded in 2000 and they didn't file their first suit until 2010. Companies certainly change their business model ("pivot," if you will).

Regardless, I'd like to see Google (and many others) divest themselves of their interest in IV.

Re:When patents attack Android by fpgeek on Thursday August 04, 2011 @01:51AM (#2844810)
I'm pretty sure their interest in IV these days would be more accurately characterized as "protection".
Re:When patents attack Android by dangrossman on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:00PM (#2843071)
1) Google needs patents to stay in business because other companies have patents to use against them.

2) See #1. Stanford owns the patent on PageRank because it was developed by Stanford graduate students on an NSF research grant. Not really relevant.

Re:When patents attack Android by juiceandjuice on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:25PM (#2843183)
Even more ironic: Stanford got a significant amount of shares from Google for allowing Google exclusive license.

Also, it is a mathematical algorithm in every sense of the word. A lot of patents aren't.

Re:When patents attack Android by davorak on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @07:48PM (#2843770)
As far as I can tell all software patents are patents on math. Here is one example of a software patent reduced to mathematics and logic the extends it to all software patents: http://paulspontifications.blogspot.com/2011/04/patent-58931...
Re:When patents attack Android by joe_the_user on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:14PM (#2843135)
The thing about Intellectual Ventures is there seems to be a fine or maybe non-existent line between companies-investing-in-IV and companies-strong-armed by IV.

I'd agree it would be even better if Google never gave a dime to patent trolls but there's a little more to the story than just Google investing in IV.

See: http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/06_27/b3991401....

Re:When patents attack Android by hn_decay on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:07PM (#2843105)
Indeed. And once Google stocks up on thousands of purchased patents (humorously they just bought a bunch of database patents from IBM, which I have no doubt they're going to start leveraging against Oracle), you will be fully supporting it as they start demanding injunctions and stoppages against Apple and Microsoft products. Right?

Those products that, to put in your don't-understand-software-patents way, STOLE from other people's innovations?

Because it's coming, and it's going to be ugly for everyone. The patent nuclear war approaches.

Your facts seems to opine that Google should simply suffer the system. They didn't make the game, but they are a young company in a industry of longstanding titans. Apple nor Microsoft nor anyone else has a right to billions in quarterly profits for perpetuity.

Re:When patents attack Android by rabz on Thursday August 04, 2011 @07:50AM (#2845541)
Once Google has the patents to start injunctions and stoppages, they can get their competitors to the table. That's not nuclear war.

Google is a young company, but it's been in the phone industry at least since it bought Android in 2005. Apple created its iPhone and released it in 2007, so in the phone industry, Google's the senior.

No one has a right to billions of quarterly profits, but no one has a right to violate others' intellectual property, either. Apple and Microsoft are profiting at these levels despite the infringement of other companies.

Re:When patents attack Android by watty on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:04PM (#2842779)
They're being painted as a victim because they are. Patents are BS and continue to hinder innovation.

They may be anti-competitive in other areas (although I don't know specifics). Can you provide some sources?

Re:When patents attack Android by maercsrats on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:46PM (#2842993)
There is an anti-compete lawsuit going on between google and skyhook: http://www.engadget.com/2011/05/10/internal-emails-reveal-go...

There needs to be significant patent/ip reform in this country, there's no question about that. Google isn't necessarily a "good guy", though. There is a lot of money to be made out there and all of the big guys are using everything at their disposal to gain the upper hand.

Re:When patents attack Android by chocopuff on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:55PM (#2843038)
The hypocrisy is unbelievable:

Google is a major investor in patent troll firm Intellectual Ventures.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_Ventures

http://www.techflash.com/seattle/2011/05/intellectual-ventur...

Amazon, Apple, Cisco, eBay, Microsoft, etc. are also investors but they are not acting like whiny babies and acting all high and mighty going around preaching about how patents are destroying innovation.

Re:When patents attack Android by cma on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:08PM (#2842801)
They sure touted their PageRank patent.
Re:When patents attack Android by chaz on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:14PM (#2842846)
The patent is owned by Stanford. From Wikipedia:

The name "PageRank" is a trademark of Google, and the PageRank process has been patented (U.S. Patent 6,285,999). However, the patent is assigned to Stanford University and not to Google. Google has exclusive license rights on the patent from Stanford University. The university received 1.8 million shares of Google in exchange for use of the patent; the shares were sold in 2005 for $336 million.

Re:When patents attack Android by rtrunck on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:02PM (#2843084)
Being an exclusive licensee provides significant rights to Google, for example, they could sue for infringement of that patent.
Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:20PM (#2843430)
I'm not sure that they can. I don't believe patent law provides for anyone by the patent holder to sue for infringement.

Could be wrong, though, but I seem to recall a similar story in the news not too long ago.

Re:When patents attack Android by yardie on Thursday August 04, 2011 @08:09AM (#2845587)
I believe they can. Stanford is still the patent holder and is charged with enforcing their patent but they could put it into the exclusive contract with Google that Google is the enforcer under contract by Stanford. Of course when Google's attorneys send out C&Ds they will need to mention the stanford-Google relationship and not misrepresent that they are the patent holder.
Re:When patents attack Android by MikeCapone on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:15PM (#2842849)
To me, that one seems to actually be a non-obvious, patentable idea. It made the world a better place. This isn't 1-click checkout or clickable phone numbers on a smart phone...

But I don't think Google actually sued anyone when most other search engines started using that method. Correct me if I'm wrong.

Re:When patents attack Android by VladRussian on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:02PM (#2843081)
evaluating/rating articles on the base of references and citations of them in other articles has been a useful and known practice in academia. Applying it to web pages was innovative (compare with original _invention_ of such algorithm for the scientific articles), yet doesn't seems to be something that warrants involvement of government force to keep others from applying the same academia article evaluation principles to web pages.
Re:When patents attack Android by ldar15 on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:39PM (#2842955)
It is exactly the kind of innovative solution that multiple developers would discover independently. It is exactly the kind of idea that does not need a 17 year monopoly to incentivize investors to provide cash for its development.
Re:When patents attack Android by kenjackson on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:50PM (#2843008)
In fact multiple people did discover similar strategies at the same point in time such as: http://www.cs.cornell.edu/home/kleinber/auth.pdf
Re:When patents attack Android by azakai on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:12PM (#2842823)
They are proud of it, for sure. But have they ever used it to sue anyone?
Re:When patents attack Android by yanw on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:23PM (#2842892)
Having patents doesn't mean you agree with the state of the patent system, also they have yet to sue anyone over patents.
Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:31PM (#2842920)
They're "the victim" of patents only because they have chosen to pursue a pattern of willfully infringing on competing companies patents.
Re:When patents attack Android by ori_b on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:39PM (#2842958)
I'd like to challenge you to point to a single nontrivial piece of software that doesn't infringe on someone's patents. I'd submit that it's nearly impossible.
Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:05PM (#2843097)
Untrue by inspection. Patents have a life of 20 years, software written over 20 years ago not all trivial.

Totally irrelevant to the current conversation. No one thinks all patents are good or valid. Contrast with what Google does: (1) copy exactly what the leader does as close as possible, (2) not license any of the innovations we're copying and (3) push propoganda that any patents we might walk over are "bogus".

Re:When patents attack Android by ori_b on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:14PM (#2843134)
Sorry, what is untrue by inspection?

It is a fact that nearly all software infringes at least some patents. I do not believe I could write any significant program that was entirely patent free. As a result, I would say that I believe every software company is "willfully infringing patents". After all, they chose to ship software instead of spending years and thousands of dollars in a combination of patent discovery and crippling their software to avoid patents.

As far as walking over patents -- Google is being sued less than many other major players at this point:

http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4128/5061246255_45a015568b.jp...

Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:26PM (#2843188)
"I do not believe I could write any significant program that was entirely patent free."

Well that's a different claim then you made earlier. At any rate as I said above I don't think Google is just infringing on silly, obvious and clearly invalid patents. I think they willfully infringe on clear, major innovations.

Re:When patents attack Android by ori_b on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:34PM (#2843227)
Can you point to a clear, major innovation software innovation that they are currently being sued for? I can't think of any.

I'm also not seeing the difference between "It's nearly impossible to write a nontrivial program that doesn't infringe patents" and "I do not believe I could write any significant program that was entirely patent free."

Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:54PM (#2843320)
"Can you point to a clear, major innovation software innovation that they are currently being sued for? I can't think of any."

Java ("everything else sucks" - Google), miscellaneous mobile innovations belonging to all sorts of companies via proxy (because they don't actually ship phones). They haven't been sued over VP8 yet but it's likely coming barring licensing.

...

"I'm also not seeing the difference between ..."

Well now you're putting words in your own mouth. What you originally said was:

"point to a single nontrivial piece of software that doesn't infringe on someone's patents."

And I pointed to every piece of software over 20 years old, /hangs mission accomplished banner. Again this is excessively derailing...

Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:30PM (#2843470)
Java: it's far from certain Google is in the wrong here, and they could potentially win a court case. (Likely they'll settle out-of-court, sadly.)

VP8: the fact that Google has been using VP8 in WebM for 14 months now, with no clear allegations of wrongdoing, kinda kills your "willful" argument. If Google was fully aware they were infringing on patents, don't you think someone would have brought this up and/or sued them by now? (I could also start ranting about submarine patents, but I'll leave that alone.)

The parent poster also didn't really ask the right question. "Point to a single nontrivial piece of software that doesn't infringe on someone's patents" may indeed be solved by pointing to anything written over 20 years ago, but how is that a useful measure? We're not going to just say that we only need software written by 1991 and everything written in the past 20 years is useless. So sure, maybe "mission accomplished", but that's like saying "mission accomplished" for successfully going to the bathroom. Sure, well done!

The more useful question is -- "can you write a nontrivial piece of software today that infringes no patents?" I don't know the answer to that, but I suspect it's hard to do.

Re:When patents attack Android by fpgeek on Thursday August 04, 2011 @01:56AM (#2844824)
The answer is no. More interestingly, even 20+ year old software was not necessarily disclosed in a way that meets the legal requirements for "prior art", so you can be sued for using it.

I believe exceptions for prior usage are one of the things being messed with in the current "patent reform" legislation, though, IIRC, they're being influenced in a negative direction disappointingly and unsurprisingly.

Re:When patents attack Android by ori_b on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:21PM (#2843431)
Java (the language) isn't something that is patentable. They are reportedly being sued over the implementation of the VM, but the core ideas used in the VM (both Oracle's implementation and Google's implementation) are something like 30 years old. Sun just happened to be the first to try patenting the old ideas.

VP8 was designed to avoid patents, but there's so much stuff patented in the audio and video fields that it's nearly impossible to avoid infringing.

Re:When patents attack Android by slackerIII on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:36PM (#2842945)
How do you know it is willful? That is an important word when it comes to patent infringement.
Re:When patents attack Android by kenjackson on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:42PM (#2842970)
I think willful infringement will play a large role in this Oracle case. For that case, we'll probably know over the next year if it was willful.
Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:59PM (#2843070)
I don't claim to know anything. I assumed it's willful because it's been a repeated pattern of behavior and because of the full court propaganda press they have been making against patents.
Re:When patents attack Android by hn_decay on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:01PM (#2843079)
This is an incredible claim. Do you realize that Apple and Microsoft are being sued constantly as well?
Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:10PM (#2843119)
I don't know what's incredible about it. That a company that copies things might infringe patents?

Do I realize that Apple infringes patents? Yes. Are you aware that Apple doesn't cry about how it's the end of the world and we're all going to have to pay more for the next iphone because they had to write Nokia a check for Nokia's previous and substantial innovations to mobile?

Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:34PM (#2843491)
That a company that copies things might infringe patents?

Wow, seems like you have a pretty big bias here. That hurts your argument quite a bit.

Are you aware that Apple doesn't cry about how it's the end of the world and we're all going to have to pay more for the next iphone because they had to write Nokia a check for Nokia's previous and substantial innovations to mobile?

It's one thing to license a patent filed and wielded in good faith. Google already does that as well for lots of patents.

It's quite another to collude with other companies to buy up huge patent portfolios for the sole purpose of extorting your competitors and stifling competition. That's what Apple/MS/etc. appear to be doing here. Obviously I can't speak to their motivations with authority, but that's how it looks from the outside.

Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @09:04PM (#2844038)
"It's quite another to collude with other companies to buy up huge patent portfolios for the sole purpose of extorting your competitors and stifling competition.."

Wait I'm biased but according to you, Apple is using this for the sole purpose of extortion? Come off of it. Back here in the real world Apple has probably paid out many times more in patent suits then it has or will collect any time soon. Why can't Apple be using these defensively as well?

Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Monday August 08, 2011 @08:58AM (#2859876)
Maybe they are, but I'm more concerned with their primary purpose, and the "everyone vs. Google" setup of the bid-teaming seems to point to the offensive nature as primary.
Re:When patents attack Android by nextparadigms on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:11PM (#2842820)
We're talking about patents here. Even if what you say is true, does that mean they "deserve" to be crushed by bogus patents? Bogus patents aren't helping anyone, and in at least several cases they have been used by others to hunt Apple and Microsoft, too.
Re:When patents attack Android by davidu on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:48PM (#2843002)
I think you are looking at it inside a box, as an isolated issues.

Patent litigation is simply a weapon used by companies offensively or defensively.

When in a fight with your competitors you look at your weapons and theirs. When evaluating the visible weaponry of their competitors they see patent litigation near the top of the list. When they look at their arsenal of weapons, they do not see patent litigation at the top of the list. Therefore, they have decided it's better to eliminate patent litigation as a weapon rather than to go into battle against it.

Their strategy is to change the rules of what weapons can be used in battle. :-) It's very smart.

Re:When patents attack Android by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:10PM (#2843392)
Isn't this like nation-states trying to prevents wars so that they can compete on building effective societies? It would be perversely cynical to suggest that the nations more confident in their ability to deliver effective societies were somehow cheating by trying to prevent the needless destruction and waste of wars.
Re:When patents attack Android by davidu on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:18PM (#2843420)
It's not like that at all. Your analogy is completely lost on me.
Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:39PM (#2843509)
He's merely pointing out that there are two ways (among others, of course) you can try to win in the marketplaces:

1. Build innovative products that your customers want, and keep iterating and innovating to keep your customers coming back for more.

2. Use the legal system to force your competitors out of your market, or make it so expensive to stay that it's harder to gain market share.

Apple has a long and brilliant history of #1, which makes it even more disheartening that it seems like they're resorting to #2 here.

While both may be legally valid, which is more beneficial to consumers and society as a whole?

Re:When patents attack Android by glenstein on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @09:00PM (#2844028)
I'm generally a lurker, and not a programmer, not highly opinionated on software patenting, but to me the analogy was perfectly clear.

Bogus patents = military power

useful innovations = effective societies.

Trying to remove bogus patents/military power and shift the center of gravity over to useful innovations/effective societies, isn't nefarious despite advantaging one particular party.

Re:When patents attack Android by WorkingDead on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:39PM (#2842957)
I think there is a big difference between litigating your competition away and out competing them. I also see a big difference between the way Google approaches vendor lock in and their competitors do. I also can think of a big name brand competing service for just about everything Google does. Thusly,I disagree with your statement that Google is a monopoly or anti-competitive.
Re:When patents attack Android by zmmmmm on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:48PM (#2843542)
> Since Google knows it has better tools to be competitive outside of patents, it is in their interest to eliminate patents as a source of pressure from competitors.

This is nonsense. Google has a huge number of smart people working for them - if they wanted to enter a patent war they are extremely well equipped to do so. Everything I've seen from them tells me that they simply culturally biased against doing that. They'd just rather spend their time inventing cool new stuff than suing about old stuff.

Re:When patents attack Android by yanw on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:10PM (#2842809)
Your innuendo doesn't prove any 'anti-competitive' practices, consorting to band a patent cartel in order to strangle opensource on the other hand is.
Re:When patents attack Android by coliveira on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:27PM (#2842907)
I don't think that either side is doing the right thing here, but saying that a group is trying to "strangle opensource" is just a distortion of the facts.

Android is just a very small part of the open source ecosystem, and the platform was clearly not created to promote open source, but to use it as leverage to quickly spread a free (as in beer) mobile operating system.