News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:31PM (#2842920)
They're "the victim" of patents only because they have chosen to pursue a pattern of willfully infringing on competing companies patents.
Re:When patents attack Android by ori_b on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:39PM (#2842958)
I'd like to challenge you to point to a single nontrivial piece of software that doesn't infringe on someone's patents. I'd submit that it's nearly impossible.
Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:05PM (#2843097)
Untrue by inspection. Patents have a life of 20 years, software written over 20 years ago not all trivial.

Totally irrelevant to the current conversation. No one thinks all patents are good or valid. Contrast with what Google does: (1) copy exactly what the leader does as close as possible, (2) not license any of the innovations we're copying and (3) push propoganda that any patents we might walk over are "bogus".

Re:When patents attack Android by ori_b on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:14PM (#2843134)
Sorry, what is untrue by inspection?

It is a fact that nearly all software infringes at least some patents. I do not believe I could write any significant program that was entirely patent free. As a result, I would say that I believe every software company is "willfully infringing patents". After all, they chose to ship software instead of spending years and thousands of dollars in a combination of patent discovery and crippling their software to avoid patents.

As far as walking over patents -- Google is being sued less than many other major players at this point:

http://farm5.static.flickr.com/4128/5061246255_45a015568b.jp...

Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:26PM (#2843188)
"I do not believe I could write any significant program that was entirely patent free."

Well that's a different claim then you made earlier. At any rate as I said above I don't think Google is just infringing on silly, obvious and clearly invalid patents. I think they willfully infringe on clear, major innovations.

Re:When patents attack Android by ori_b on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:34PM (#2843227)
Can you point to a clear, major innovation software innovation that they are currently being sued for? I can't think of any.

I'm also not seeing the difference between "It's nearly impossible to write a nontrivial program that doesn't infringe patents" and "I do not believe I could write any significant program that was entirely patent free."

Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:54PM (#2843320)
"Can you point to a clear, major innovation software innovation that they are currently being sued for? I can't think of any."

Java ("everything else sucks" - Google), miscellaneous mobile innovations belonging to all sorts of companies via proxy (because they don't actually ship phones). They haven't been sued over VP8 yet but it's likely coming barring licensing.

...

"I'm also not seeing the difference between ..."

Well now you're putting words in your own mouth. What you originally said was:

"point to a single nontrivial piece of software that doesn't infringe on someone's patents."

And I pointed to every piece of software over 20 years old, /hangs mission accomplished banner. Again this is excessively derailing...

Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:30PM (#2843470)
Java: it's far from certain Google is in the wrong here, and they could potentially win a court case. (Likely they'll settle out-of-court, sadly.)

VP8: the fact that Google has been using VP8 in WebM for 14 months now, with no clear allegations of wrongdoing, kinda kills your "willful" argument. If Google was fully aware they were infringing on patents, don't you think someone would have brought this up and/or sued them by now? (I could also start ranting about submarine patents, but I'll leave that alone.)

The parent poster also didn't really ask the right question. "Point to a single nontrivial piece of software that doesn't infringe on someone's patents" may indeed be solved by pointing to anything written over 20 years ago, but how is that a useful measure? We're not going to just say that we only need software written by 1991 and everything written in the past 20 years is useless. So sure, maybe "mission accomplished", but that's like saying "mission accomplished" for successfully going to the bathroom. Sure, well done!

The more useful question is -- "can you write a nontrivial piece of software today that infringes no patents?" I don't know the answer to that, but I suspect it's hard to do.

Re:When patents attack Android by fpgeek on Thursday August 04, 2011 @01:56AM (#2844824)
The answer is no. More interestingly, even 20+ year old software was not necessarily disclosed in a way that meets the legal requirements for "prior art", so you can be sued for using it.

I believe exceptions for prior usage are one of the things being messed with in the current "patent reform" legislation, though, IIRC, they're being influenced in a negative direction disappointingly and unsurprisingly.

Re:When patents attack Android by ori_b on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:21PM (#2843431)
Java (the language) isn't something that is patentable. They are reportedly being sued over the implementation of the VM, but the core ideas used in the VM (both Oracle's implementation and Google's implementation) are something like 30 years old. Sun just happened to be the first to try patenting the old ideas.

VP8 was designed to avoid patents, but there's so much stuff patented in the audio and video fields that it's nearly impossible to avoid infringing.

Re:When patents attack Android by slackerIII on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:36PM (#2842945)
How do you know it is willful? That is an important word when it comes to patent infringement.
Re:When patents attack Android by kenjackson on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:42PM (#2842970)
I think willful infringement will play a large role in this Oracle case. For that case, we'll probably know over the next year if it was willful.
Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @04:59PM (#2843070)
I don't claim to know anything. I assumed it's willful because it's been a repeated pattern of behavior and because of the full court propaganda press they have been making against patents.
Re:When patents attack Android by hn_decay on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:01PM (#2843079)
This is an incredible claim. Do you realize that Apple and Microsoft are being sued constantly as well?
Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @05:10PM (#2843119)
I don't know what's incredible about it. That a company that copies things might infringe patents?

Do I realize that Apple infringes patents? Yes. Are you aware that Apple doesn't cry about how it's the end of the world and we're all going to have to pay more for the next iphone because they had to write Nokia a check for Nokia's previous and substantial innovations to mobile?

Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @06:34PM (#2843491)
That a company that copies things might infringe patents?

Wow, seems like you have a pretty big bias here. That hurts your argument quite a bit.

Are you aware that Apple doesn't cry about how it's the end of the world and we're all going to have to pay more for the next iphone because they had to write Nokia a check for Nokia's previous and substantial innovations to mobile?

It's one thing to license a patent filed and wielded in good faith. Google already does that as well for lots of patents.

It's quite another to collude with other companies to buy up huge patent portfolios for the sole purpose of extorting your competitors and stifling competition. That's what Apple/MS/etc. appear to be doing here. Obviously I can't speak to their motivations with authority, but that's how it looks from the outside.

Re:When patents attack Android by Steko on Wednesday August 03, 2011 @09:04PM (#2844038)
"It's quite another to collude with other companies to buy up huge patent portfolios for the sole purpose of extorting your competitors and stifling competition.."

Wait I'm biased but according to you, Apple is using this for the sole purpose of extortion? Come off of it. Back here in the real world Apple has probably paid out many times more in patent suits then it has or will collect any time soon. Why can't Apple be using these defensively as well?

Re:When patents attack Android by kelnos on Monday August 08, 2011 @08:58AM (#2859876)
Maybe they are, but I'm more concerned with their primary purpose, and the "everyone vs. Google" setup of the bid-teaming seems to point to the offensive nature as primary.