I'm baffled by your comment to be honest; not very long ago I could buy a house in Bristol for the same or less.
Not really, people want to live there, and can now live there while working in a decent job, raise a family, send kids to school, etc.
Without remote work, villages like that are meaningless. Communication and social changes caused by covid have allowed people to actually live in remote villages.
> For a small village of less than 5,000 people nowhere near any sort of city or population centre, this seems like a lot.
Not really, people want to live there, and can now live there while working in a decent job, raise a family, send kids to school, etc.
Without remote work, villages like that are meaningless. Communication and social changes caused by covid have allowed people to actually live in remote villages.
House prices have shot up since the mid 90s as they become more affordable. A new 3 bed home in say east anglia is more affordable now (compared with median wages) than it was in 1980, despite being far far more expensive to buy. That's because
1) Most households have two incomes rather than one 2) Interest rates are much lower
House prices rise to the level people are able to pay for them. Remote work has allowed people to live in villages like St Just and continue in a decent job, which is great. Before it was mainly retirees and holiday owners, neither of which were good for the area.
Admittedly this includes households including people who are "retired" but I think that's reasonable as plenty of people have to keep working even though they're receiving a pension.
https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/personal...
That's £30k a year.
[0] https://www.ons.gov.uk/employmentandlabourmarket/peopleinwor...
This horrifies me. Even the slightest increase in interest rates will ruin a huge number of home owners.
On the other hand, home ownership in the UK isn’t normal either. It’s only since the 50s or perhaps 60s that the average person has been able to afford a home. And then again in the 80s with council houses sold off to tenants.
Is the situation very different in the UK? Do Britishers actually prefer variable rate mortgages for some bizarre reason?
Edit: I did my own research and was shocked to find that in the UK it sounds like variable is indeed more or at least as common as fixed and that even fixed tends to be fixed only for the first 5-10 years!This is the opposite of the US, where I know someone on a normal middle class circumstance who just secured a 3.25% 30 year fixed mortgage, and this is extremely common right now if you have good credit. Even the "scary and risky" variable mortgages in America are things like a 5/1 ARM which is fixed for the first 5 years, which sound like they'd be relatively low risk for the UK!
I am baffled. Is the great advantage for the American homeowner simply due to the wages of empire, ie dollar supremacy? Federal policy favoring homeowners? Or what? I did always wonder how banks could afford to provide such a good deal.
This is a vast difference really worth wondering about; I hope someone has some insight.
Source: https://www.money.co.uk/mortgages/should-you-get-a-fixed-tra...
You have little to no incentive to stick around as a long-term customer when there will be a fresh new deal enticing you to switch whenever your last contract expires. It's often more expensive not to switch as there's no benefit to being loyal to an energy or telecoms firm.
This arguably extends to mortgages too.
At the root of it all is that there's more competition between these elements and legislation has forced businesses to make it easy to switch providers at no cost. Anecdotally, I've been through three different ISPs in as many years in order to keep my internet costs down.
That doesn't directly address the question, it just highlights a mindset.
Mortgage rates in the UK are far lower than 3.25% though -- 80% LTV on a 10 year fix with nationwide is 2.8%, 2 year fix is 1.54%.
Drop that to 60% LTV and 2 year is 1%, 5 year 1.1% and 10 year 2%.
It all falls down if rates were to shoot up, or house prices were to shoot down. The UK government traditionally protects house prices like the US government protects the S&P though. A house price crash is bad for polling.
Now there are Australian type mortgages, basically repay as quick as you can, that are variable rate plus X. Or fixed and floating, or pure fixed. It generally depends on your personal position.
Note that the very low share of ARMs is a recent (post Great Recession) phenomenon. Prior to that, ARMs were typically a large minority of loans.
https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/research/curre...
The bank wasn't taking much risk on the adjustable rate.
And the slightest increase in inflation will benefit them.
A competent central bank would make sure that it all balances out.
We can make promises to each other. Essentially write debt contracts to each other at no fee. The problem is that we trust each other but if we want a more complex economy than a barter system allows, then we need to make it possible for a third party to trust the debt contract. Through the introduction of banks as middlemen they use their resources to check how trustworthy the debt contract you offer to the bank is. In exchange you get money, which is a liquid claim on your debt contract and thousands or even millions of other debt contracts. Thus the bank is primarily in the business of managing risk and the management of risk demands a net interest margin. If the bank didn't make money off of loans then any bad loan would lose the bank money and it would go bankrupt over the long term. In other words, the surplus profit that the bank made off your loan is its reward for correctly managing risk.
>This is why housing is so expensive to begin with.
Or it could be that housing is in high demand and banks offer financing so people have more money but since location is a monopoly, supply never catches up with demand in popular areas. Speculators themselves simply predict that there is sufficient demand for you to be willing to bay $400k for a house. Speculators didn't create that profit margin, it is the monopoly of land that created it and they merely exploit it.
I think mortgages are pretty competitive, especially for reasonably well-paid people and there isn’t really that much profit made by the banks (your interest corresponds to inflation and the risk that you default on your loan with the house price having fallen.
Money today is worth more than money in 25 years and you have to pay the difference.
Literally every loan a bank gives out is mostly made up on the spot, everywhere in the world.
In some countries, banks are subject to reserve requirements — typically from fractions of a percent to some percents of their liabilities to depositors. Basically: banks need to cover the savings of people.
In the UK (and many other countries), this is not the case; banks are not required to have cash on hand in relation to their liabilities to depositors.
Instead, they are subject to capital requirements, which means they need to have sufficient equities (cash, securities, other financial instruments) with sufficient liquidity in relation to their risk-weighted assets (credit and loans). In effect: banks need to cover the investments of the investors.
https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-...
Charging 0% interest means the bank is losing money.
Anyway, if you sign a contract that says you shall pay me every month for 30 years OR ELSE I get to sell your house (and whatever else you own, seize your income etc) then the document with your signature IS the value created and I can sell that document for what it is worth.
So the bank creates money not entirely out of thin air but against this contract.
This is a fantastic deal for them as there is almost no risk.
The seemingly few percent interest per year over 30 years quickly ads up to 2 or 3 times the initial sum.
I suppose this would be a reasonable amount roughly around the point where 3 out of 4 houses and the ground under them would just vanish in thin air with their owner stopping all payments after about 5 years on average.
The reality was that some people still had to pay rent for their flooded home.
So we are all suckers for putting up with the scheme, welcome to the club.
Rather than have 0% interest and 2% inflation there would be -2% interest and 0% inflation. Less need for endless debt growth and government stimulus.
> I don't get how people can keep saying this. Is it that people are told banks lend out money from depositors in school?
They don't? Where is the money from? Due to complicated reasons (ie. bundling mortgages into mortgage backed securities and selling them), it might not be the case that the mortgage issued by Bank A is funded by Bank A's depositors, but it is the case that it's funded by depositors/investors somewhere.
https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/022416/why-b...
However, saving does have one important function. It creates a hole in the economy and that hole can then be used for investment spending (motivated by a borrower taking on a loan) without causing inflation.
...except for reserve/capital requirements, right?
>However, saving does have one important function. It creates a hole in the economy and that hole can then be used for investment spending (motivated by a borrower taking on a loan) without causing inflation.
In other words, capital isn't free as the parent poster suggests.
It is created ex nihilo, limited by reserve concerns (which include hard requirements for some banks)
Note that the most of the money never exists in the form of currency, it is just accounting entries in the banking system.
That was the case. A colleague of mine, originally from St Just, moved to London for work as so many have to do. Another from near Cockermouth did the same. Both now work remotely full time from their 'home towns' on decent wages.
Covid has done wonders for local communities - good jobs are now available for people without having to move across the country.
https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/112353359 for example is under £300k. Assuming you got it for 300k (asking price is 285k) with a 15k deposit you're looking at £1,278.19 a month with nationwide on a 30 year rate, well within the range of a couple earning £35k each, which is a reasonable
Now sure if you didn't get the education to get a decent job. Hell even on 25k each, Nationwide can lend upto £275k for a first time buyer - just need that deposit.