News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by ForHackernews on Sunday September 05, 2021 @06:48AM (#28423198)
That's a self-correcting problem, isn't it? Either those cafes and shops will raise prices and pay their staff more, or they'll close down. I've never understood why we're supposed to feel bad for "small business owners" who won't find staff when paying peanuts for their crappy jobs.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday September 05, 2021 @09:13AM (#28424098)
Your solution is the problem. The house prices are a blood-sucking squid, and you are pay for them every time you get a coffee or get any service - half the money is going to the labdowner that contributes nothing to the economy. That's why a coffee costs £5 and a plumber charges £100 an hour

But we have fools that celebrate rising house prices because their nominal net worth went up

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by ipaddr on Sunday September 05, 2021 @09:39AM (#28424275)
If prices were going down would things be better? You bought a 500,000 and in ten years it will be worth 100,000 would you still make that investment?

Everyone wants prices to remain the same forever. That takes a neutral population growth or more supply

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:02AM (#28424409)
Certainly yes, it would be better - the value of a car goes down, do you still make an 'investment'? No, you buy a car if you need a car, we don't call buying a car 'investment', we don't encourage people to hoard cars they don't need, it contributes nothing to the economy.

The optimal situation is for cars and houses to be as cheap as possible relative to earnings, that's what we call economic growth and improved quality of life.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:22AM (#28424995)
Housing (the structures) depreciates in Japan now of days, and so they mostly don’t have this problem.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by tsimionescu on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:08PM (#28425358)
By this logic no one would buy food, as it drastically depreciates in a minuscule amount of time.

The real economy is the one that fulfills people's needs. Real-estate investment is parasitic to the real economy - it locks money away and artificially increases the price of a basic necessity. This has always been recognized in even basic economics with the concept of "rent-seeking" - unproductive activity that still makes money, such as literally charging rent.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by imtringued on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:09AM (#28424461)
>If prices were going down would things be better? You bought a 500,000 and in ten years it will be worth 100,000 would you still make that investment?

The idea that holding a property and doing absolutely nothing with it is an "investment" is absurd. The only people who would buy that home are those who want to live in it or who want to rent it out to someone who wants to live in it.

No I wouldn't make that "investment". I would just rent the property out without "investing" the property.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by mellavora on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:06PM (#28425346)
I've read that in many Asian countries houses are seen as a depreciating asset.

And I've noticed that in the US, the observations that cars are typically depreciating assets never really stopped people from buying them.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by andrepd on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:43AM (#28425167)
>investment

That's exactly the problem right there. A house can be a place to live or an investment, but not both. I myself think it's a bit to silly to spend labour and resources building a concrete box for the latter purpose, so I'd much rather houses fulfill their purpose as homes for people to live in.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by panarky on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:49PM (#28425665)
> but not both

Certainly a place to live can also be an investment.

Just like a work of art can also be an investment.

And a plumbing business can be an investment and also fix your pipes.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by ClumsyPilot on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:56PM (#28425728)
You missed the point - a plumbing business is an investment, just like a construction business. But no-one buys an old set of pipes and calls that an investment, and we understand that would be dumb.

If houses are to be an investment, their prices will keep rising and they become unaffordable. When consumer goods themselves are an investment, standards of living fall

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by limograf on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:23AM (#28423797)
Sure, they can raise prices but the customers who paid £350,000 for their charming holiday cottage won't pay £35 for a cup of coffee. The house prices are so out of touch with the rest of the economy, there's no way to catch up for normal people. So the cafe closes.

The self correction should actually be the house price crashing, but the UK government consistently props up, and pumps, the market.

The average house price in Salcombe (Devon) is £950,000! That's 30 average salaries.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by Spooky23 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @09:45AM (#28424311)
We’re in a suicide spiral where fiscal policy has staved off economic malaise by kicking the can down the road.

Interest rates have been kept low, which drives real property prices up. Everyone intuitively knows that collapse or high inflation is the endgame, so money flocks to property, which drives up demand.

The issue isn’t the coffee shop in the fishing village, it’s that the fishermen are selling real estate now and nobody actually lives in the village.

You can see this in many places. Lake George, NY is a great example - beautiful village, great location, but can only support tshirt shops from Memorial Day to Labor Day. Manhattan is the same way — the Lower East Side is like a museum of what Manhattan was like, with $2M condo apartments being randomly dropped in and 1/3 of the storefronts vacant.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by imtringued on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:14AM (#28424504)
Low interest rates have made everything cheap but the supply of housing (specifically land) is extremely inflexible. You can make more cars but not land. The location value of your house skyrockets at the expense of everyone else.

However, make no mistake. The problem isn't money. Even if you buy your house with Bitcoin you will run into the same problem. The problem is that location is a a monopoly. You can tax it or let it run wild.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by Spooky23 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:00PM (#28425289)
I’m not making any mistake, cheap money is absolutely the biggest problem that we have today.

My former mentor bought a house on Nantucket for $150k in 1990, sold for $3.5M earlier this year. That appreciation isn’t due to inflation or the constrained supply of homes — it’s always been constrained. It’s due to increased demand fueled by excess capital.

There’s no money in traditional banking. Even with negligible interest, the spread is very tight. The only way to compete is with volume, aggregation and fee for service, and the only way to get volume is to lower standards.

IMO, we’re in an economic time period similar to the 1860’s.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by com2kid on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:51PM (#28425688)
> My former mentor bought a house on Nantucket for $150k in 1990, sold for $3.5M earlier this year.

That is literally a luxury good with a fixed supply. As the # of people who desire that good has sky rocketed generation to generation, of course the price went up.

There are limited production run cars from that era that underwent similar price inflation.

For someone who wants to live in Nantucket, there is literally no substitutable good!

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by Spooky23 on Sunday September 05, 2021 @02:09PM (#28426367)
> That is literally a luxury good with a fixed supply. As the # of people who desire that good has sky rocketed generation to generation, of course the price went up.

We’re arguing the same thing. Everyone wants to go to the beach. The ability to get cash to do so increased demand.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by afiori on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:54AM (#28431737)
But the number of people that can pay 3.5 million dollars for an house is much smaller than the number of people that can take have a 3.5 million house financed. If interest rates were sufficiently low (maybe negative) everybody would be in the second category.

Having more people willing to pay contributes to price increases

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by arwineap on Monday September 06, 2021 @04:34PM (#28437774)
Not a 19th century scholar; can you provide a couple links to the current situation?

Or reference the points you are trying to make to make it easier to search? For instance, most of my results right now are pertaining to the civil war economies of the north / south United States

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by Spooky23 on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @12:24PM (#28446628)
Sure, I’d start here. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_Depression

I think the the internet and technology is the equivalent to the railroads and industrialization in the 19th century. You also have the currency issues with silver and gold standards which may play out similarly to some of the crypto issues of today.

I’ve worked in a large enterprise for a long time, going from project to project that essentially automated away some semi-professional human work with automation at a 50-90% savings. Over 15 years, there’s about 35% fewer people doing 50% more work.

That trend is only speeding up. I don’t see how the current model of using cheap money to prop up real estate is a sustainable economic model.

Take with appropriate grain of salt. I’m not an economist, and my understanding is that of a layman.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by com2kid on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:49PM (#28425666)
> You can make more cars but not land.

Lots of land exists, the issue is desirable cities, and western countries have gotten really bad at making those.

China spent the first decade of the 21st century creating urban cities left and right, ignore the western propaganda of "ghost cities", and also spent time urbanizing what America would consider "suburban" towns.

Meanwhile western nations are dead set on never increasing the # of desirable urban environments, and then it is all surprise Pikachu when house prices skyrocket.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by mrkstu on Sunday September 05, 2021 @04:45PM (#28427617)
Whole states like Idaho and Utah have seen skyrocketing prices for homes- this is in no way limited to specific urban environments.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by pempem on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:12PM (#28428650)
If we take out the pandemic impact, does that still hold true for Utah and Idaho?
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by dragonwriter on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:15PM (#28428666)
> If we take out the pandemic impact

How do you reliably isolate the effect of the pandemic from other effects occurring at the same time?

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by devdas on Sunday September 05, 2021 @04:39PM (#28427557)
Nothing that a wealth tax on the current value of land won't fix. Make property taxes to the value of the number of people that land should support in a highrise configuration, and let the current owners pay it.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by aikinai on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:14AM (#28423727)
You think those small business owners are packing away substantial profits they could use to pay staff significantly more?
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by emodendroket on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:22AM (#28423788)
If a business can only exist by having serfs it wildly underpays then maybe it deserves to lose out to the big chains.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by HelloNurse on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:46AM (#28423945)
Compared to a small business the "big chains" might be able to operate with smaller profit margins, or have lower non-labor costs, or profit from owned real estate, but it isn't enough for long term viability. Excessive rents are going to turn any neighbourhood into a desert like South Kensington.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by llampx on Sunday September 05, 2021 @09:58AM (#28424382)
Big chains aren't exactly known for treating unskilled workers with kids gloves. Amazon comes to mind, as does Walmart.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by emodendroket on Sunday September 05, 2021 @01:45PM (#28426148)
And yet they pay substantially better wages with better benefits on average. Even labor law compliance is much better (not to mention that small businesses are exempt from many regulations in the first place).
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by pempem on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:14PM (#28428662)
Not sure about that. The benefits are better and more structured and there are multitudes of articles about how they are much much harder to access, leaving most workers partially dependent on state benefits
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by emodendroket on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:47PM (#28429183)
Mom and pop shops often just don't offer benefits at all. Go slightly bigger and they'll have a health plan that's easy to enroll in but the premiums and co-pays will make your eyes water.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by pempem on Monday September 13, 2021 @04:33PM (#28516504)
Thats true, but they also arent usually sophisticated enough to use a LEAN scheduling approach and combine it with budgeted hours that keep you under the benefits line + an approach of expendability to their workers.

Until one of us creates a free-ish software to help them do that ofc.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:25AM (#28425016)
Or they could turn to automation, eliminate their labor costs substantially. Eg that cafe can turn into a bunch of vending machines.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by emodendroket on Sunday September 05, 2021 @01:46PM (#28426153)
Sure, they could do that too.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by imtringued on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:15AM (#28424513)
From my gut feeling it doesn't seem that small business owners actually get the funding they deserve from banks. Only big businesses actually get those low interest rates.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by spockz on Sunday September 05, 2021 @07:51AM (#28423585)
The point is that before there existed an ecosystem. That “peanuts” is what the business owner was able to afford to pay which was enough for the employees to make a somewhat decent living. Now that isn’t possible anymore. The objection is to the change/disruption of a local ecosystem by outsiders.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by chrisseaton on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:01AM (#28423654)
Blaming outsiders - classic strategy, can’t go wrong!
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by imtringued on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:17AM (#28424524)
We are blaming outsiders for giving us too much money. Where is all that money going if not into the hands of locals who are selling their property?
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by im3w1l on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:19AM (#28424962)
Consider a community of 10000 households. 5000 rent their housing, 4500 own their own place, and 500 own more than one place. Now outsiders enter the picture and buy property driving up the prices. The 5000 renting households are now in trouble. If rents go up they are squeezed that way. With rent control there are still issues: Their kids are unable to move out, and separations become tricky. For the 4500 it's a mixed bag. They have the same issues with splitting the household, but they also have advantages. They can do a reverse mortgage and live well. Or they call sell and live well elsewhere. For the 500 elite households it's a pure win, they can buy more yachts than before.
Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by chrisseaton on Sunday September 05, 2021 @11:29AM (#28425049)
> Now outsiders enter the picture and buy property

Buy it from who? Locals. So who gets the money? Locals.

But anyway the point was don’t divide people into insiders and ‘outsiders’.

Re:Dutch cities want to ban property investors in all neighb... by afiori on Monday September 06, 2021 @05:00AM (#28431778)
In the scenarion the 5000 were renting houses from the 500, so probably the outsiders would buy those properties first.

The 500 are also the most likely not to be local or own the land (which means a single sale can convert a low cost apartament building in a mansion).

Also the reverse is possible...