News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by perl4ever on Sunday September 05, 2021 @01:33AM (#28421872)
"the pencil-making family that had been Schmidt ("smith") became Faber"

It's interesting to consider how many common names are forms of "Smith" that an English speaker might not recognize. I've idly imagined writing a story where all the characters' last names are some variation on Smith.

For instance:

  Ferraro
  Haddad
  Kovács
  Kowalski
  Herrero
  Kuznets
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by mkl on Sunday September 05, 2021 @03:34AM (#28422275)
Also Black, White, Green, Brown, for smiths working with iron, tin, copper, or bronze (https://www.surnamedb.com/Surname/Smyth, https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/9nwm60/why_h...). Those names seem to have multiple origins, but the metal connection explains why most other colours don't have an associated surname.
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by vrotaru on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:34AM (#28423863)
Stanislav Lem has a story about the attempts to change the history where the Einstein was never born but his theories were developed but

Unapietra, Odnocamenec, Onestone and so on..

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by ZeroGravitas on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:51AM (#28423972)
John Smith is the stereotypical boring/common name for english speakers, and I was similarly suprised at how many "foreign" names are really just variants of John, so you could have a story in which everyone is called John Smith in different variants (Ivan Kuznets, Juan Herrero, Janek Kawolski, Yahya Haddad, Euan MacGowan etc.)
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by agumonkey on Sunday September 05, 2021 @05:15AM (#28422698)
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by thaumasiotes on Sunday September 05, 2021 @02:25AM (#28422015)
> It's interesting to consider how many common names are forms of "Smith"

It's especially an interesting contrast to China, where common last names tend to be originally aristocratic.

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by gradschoolfail on Sunday September 05, 2021 @04:03AM (#28422394)
Yepp! Never read Guns,Germs&Steel, but premodern China never really had decentralized steelworking. a cursory google shows that the mongolian words for steel and iron are similar to the ones in Chinese, my conjecture is that the chinese words are actually loaned from a barbarian culture not the other way round.. (genghis khan probably came from a smithy family btw) Maybe this is why the post roman west has always been quicker to adopt bottom-uppitism instead of elitism. it runs in the families..
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by oefrha on Sunday September 05, 2021 @05:09AM (#28422681)
> a cursory google shows that the mongolian words for steel and iron are similar to the ones in Chinese, my conjecture is that the chinese words are actually loaned from a barbarian culture not the other way round.. (genghis khan probably came from a smithy family btw)

Your conjecture about etymology makes no sense as the Chinese character 鐵 for iron dates back at least to small seal script[1] from a cursory search[2], and small seal script predates Genghis Khan by about 1400 years.

Bronze metallurgy was in China for even longer,[3] pretty sure that was way before there was any meaningful contact with "barbarians".

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Small_seal_script

[2] http://xh.5156edu.com/hzyb/a20196b17789c99815d.html

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_metallurgy_in_China

Edit: I misread [2]. The character dates back at least to large seal script which is older.

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by gradschoolfail on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:14AM (#28423731)
Etymology is almost always speculative but phonetic loans have to be considered separately from typographic history.

There are at least 2 different chinese characters for iron, and the one in common use, the one you mention, has a different old chinese pronunciation (from the turko-mongolic word). The radical for the popular version clues one in to the original non barbarian pronunciation. (Maybe it referred to something else.) The radical for the other one means “barbarian”

https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/銕#Chinese

It is not uncommon for chinese characters to be written the same but pronounced differently (and meaning something else) throughout the ages. And for the meaning and pronunciations of different characters to mix or merge

Indeed according to historian David Wagner, “ The evidence presented thus far suggests that iron-smelting techniques developed in the West had by the eighth century BC been brought by nomadic peoples of Central Asia all the way to the Pacific coast, and that these techniques diffused to the smiths of the Chinese states by way of various non-Chinese peoples of the northwest, in what is now Xinjiang. ”

http://donwagner.dk/EARFE/EARFE.html

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by oefrha on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:53AM (#28423987)
Thanks for the link to the paper. 8th century BCE is earlier than long before the earliest meaningful contact between China and Central Asia previously known to me, in the form of the Silk Road. And that's two millennia before the Mongols started having written history!
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by gradschoolfail on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:11PM (#28425380)
Also wanted to mention that bronze metallurgy is often considered elitist compared to iron metallurgy because 1)tin ores are less abundant 2) techniques are more intricate. Iron tech is pretty much the first mass tech, if zeroth is fire/fermentation or if those were too easy to be considered tech.
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by thaumasiotes on Sunday September 05, 2021 @04:19PM (#28427410)
Tin requires a supply chain[1], but bronze requires no special technology to create. Refining iron is much more difficult, which is why we had bronze first.

Pottery long predates ironworking. So does agriculture. I'm not sure how you're defining "mass technology", but ironworking isn't the first one.

[1] It's not just tin. Copper has to be sourced from specific locations too.

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by gradschoolfail on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @10:46AM (#28457818)
Bronze: yeah I should have clarified that for bronze i mean the whole bronze business, including making moulds and such. Iron and steel is like photography compared to painting you need less raw skill to be commercially viable once you can get past acquiring the stuff to get started

Mass technology: I was thinking of programming. You have a class of people distinguished by their skill. Sometimes you even have a representative in the pantheon (Wayland)

Pottery and agriculture is “too easy”

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by BadInformatics on Sunday September 05, 2021 @01:52PM (#28426193)
Trying to interpret individual radicals of a character as standalone components using their original meaning is enticing, but more often than not incorrect. For example, the character for maternal aunt uses the same radical. Phonetic-semantic compound characters are very, very, common. The standalone pronunciation of 夷 doesn't appear to have turkic/steppe origins either [1].

Moreover, we know Mongolian writing (because of the geopolitics of the time and its status as a younger written tradition) borrowed quite liberally from its southern neighbours. Including, but not limited to, China [2]. So while Wagner's point about proliferation of ironmaking techniques from outside the (nominal) Chinese state at the time makes sense, the whole phonetic angle doesn't.

As for the points about centralization and family name elitism, the first lasted less than 200 years, by which time many formerly aristocratic family names had become _so_ diluted so as to be almost meaningless. One of the main conceits of a major character in RoTK is that he's an average Joe who only gets a modicum of respect for having the same surname as the dynastic family. It also completely ignores the existence of profession-based surnames like 匠 ("artisan", notably 1/2 of 铁匠/blacksmith).

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dongyi#Yi [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mongolian_writing_systems

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by gradschoolfail on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @10:02AM (#28457134)
Notably? I would say “artisan” is too broad and “carpenter” is the usual meaning. the profession based surnames are far from being dominant either compared to smith, which almost always means blacksmith in the west.

While surnames are diluted this kind of “joke” about surnames still exists today, so there is at least some meaning

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zhao_family_(Internet_slang)

FWIW according to Baidu wiki the character yi itself has a nomadic origin.

https://baike.baidu.com/item/夷/678050

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by thaumasiotes on Sunday September 05, 2021 @04:46AM (#28422573)
> premodern China never really had decentralized steelworking

There was formally a state monopoly on iron that would have made local smithing illegal, but there were not enough state smithies to serve that purpose, so the general assumption is that illegal smithies were common.

> genghis khan probably came from a smithy family btw

I have not heard of this and it is facially implausible; the Mongols were not a metalworking people.

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by gradschoolfail on Sunday September 05, 2021 @08:01AM (#28423655)
From wikipedia:

“ Paul Pelliot saw that the tradition according to which Genghis was a blacksmith was unfounded though well established by the middle of the 13th century.[27]”

It seems at least the concept of blacksmiths was familiar to the Mongols before or around the time they went into china.

Thats why I explicitly stated “steelworking” instead of “ironworking”. Although they couldnt do it in large quantities the common European smith could use it to enhance his iron products[1]

Whereas even the quality of the steel used by the experts in China (even by the 1600s) is questionable. [2]

[1] https://the-orb.arlima.net/encyclop/culture/scitech/iron_ste...

[2] https://www.tf.uni-kiel.de/matwis/amat/iss/kap_a/advanced/aa...

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by BadInformatics on Sunday September 05, 2021 @02:15PM (#28426404)
Bronson and Pigott were a nice read, but it's unclear where Föll is getting most of his conjecture from because they certainly don't talk about it. Frankly, the whole piece smacks of the same Diamond-esque "they made fireworks, we made guns" trope that has been thoroughly torn apart since. Now to his credit, he does claim ignorance at the top of the page, but that seems to be quickly forgotten given how much hyperbole is spewed later on.

[1] is a better lay overview of medieval-era steel-making. And for a great breakdown of forces behind European success in the modern era, see Brett Devereaux's series on EU4 [2]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5djVkOgu8vs

[2] https://acoup.blog/2021/05/28/collections-teaching-paradox-e...

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by gradschoolfail on Wednesday September 08, 2021 @10:54AM (#28457956)
It reads like Foell was mostly citing Wagner, not B or P. Did you read those?
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by gommm on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:10AM (#28424467)
In French, that would translate to forgeron, but it doesn't seem to be a very common name. On the other hand, boucher (= butcher) and boulanger (= baker) are very common name in France. Kind of interesting that certain profession would become common names in one culture and not in other? Or maybe I'm missing something?
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by Zababa on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:38AM (#28424658)
I just looked that up, and apparently it's "Lefèvre" that refers to smiths: https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lef%C3%A8vre_(patronyme).
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by gommm on Sunday September 05, 2021 @01:12PM (#28425860)
Ok, and that and Lefebvre are definitely very very common. Thanks for looking it up.
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by CRConrad on Sunday September 05, 2021 @03:06PM (#28426832)
And both are probably French forms of the article's "Faber"?

(Maker, AIUI, kind of could have been "Faire-ieur" in French? In stead it's related to factor, factory, manufacture etc.)

(Also mentioned above, in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28421872 )

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by mariuolo on Sunday September 05, 2021 @10:27AM (#28424587)
How about ferrier?
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by perl4ever on Sunday September 05, 2021 @12:33PM (#28425546)
To me, Lefèvre is the familiar one, as mentioned in the sibling comment.

Google translate doesn't always produce the "right" name for Smith, I assume because the typical name in many languages was "frozen" prior to modern usage.

Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by dmurray on Sunday September 05, 2021 @04:21AM (#28422468)
McGowan, if your story needs an Irishman.
Re:Why is a Dollar like a Neanderthal by toolslive on Sunday September 05, 2021 @04:06AM (#28422410)
I think the Portuguese name Ferreiro (iron worker ?!) can be added here. Nice list!