There's already precedent for this. Cloudflare de-listed a major neo-nazi website a few years ago if I recall correctly.
As much as I might loath one website or another, I think basic web infrastructure, from DNS to certs to even cloud services should be treated as common carriers, and it should only be by legal order that they're allowed deny services to a particular site.
There's so much consolidation going on that we're not so far from a situation where a hand-full of corporations are the defacto gatekeepers of online life.
For instance, I don't think cloudflare is required to host a site. Millions of entities online are able to function without cloudflare or godaddy.
So where do we draw the line for basic web infrastructure? To me it seems like the ISP is a good place to start. If you have internet, you could host a site on hardware yourself, or with a minor hire
That said, a line? The line that should be drawn is anyone declaring that they have a right to financially coerce women to making adverse health decisions.
This would essentially prevent godaddy from limiting service to a customer because they would be required to work with all peoples
My argument, was that yes, I agree that some things should be governed more like public utilities, like ISPs. Other things should not, like CDNs, or DDOS protection, etc.
IMO once you have internet, that is what is obligated to be made available to you, all these other services might help you but they are private companies that can refuse service for any reason
Anyway, I doubt this discussion continues as the topic is stale now, but I wanted to clarify my comment regarding where the line was. I wasn't talking about morality of issues, I was talking about where common carrier status should start / stop
If the pandemic has taught us anything, the internet is the commons in the modern world, and currently we're ceding governance of it to private enterprise.
I have to say, since I moved to Europe I have become much less convinced of the inherent futility of democracy.
Sure it’s possible to get your own fiber connection, manage your own hardware and host a web company, but you’re never going to be able to compete with another party who has access to AWS or GCP to run on top of.
Except for all sorts of exceptions this isn't true. As a "principle" you could write everything you said above but substitute racial, gender, or sexual orientation discrimination and it wouldn't stand up, because businesses absolutely have to do business in these cases.
>has to vote Democrat
No, but has to not promote conservative political policies, thus supporting, just like voting does, Democrat political objectives. What's the practical difference? Democrat political power is mandated just the same.
Although the law disagrees with me, I'd say the same thing to them too. I do think it is unfair that GoDaddy might choose to boot me for my political beliefs but would get in to legal trouble for booting an LGBT group.
I see perfect parallels between GoDaddy expelling this site vs. GoDaddy expelling a site for LGBT advocacy. Both are stupid actions for GoDaddy to take, but both should be legal options.
this is one of the reasons for it's existance [1] and thanks to the federated nature, it still exists.
[1] probably also worthwile to lookup rir/lir in that regard https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regional_Internet_registry
Businesses don't have to do business if they don't want to. Tough for this website, sucks to be discriminated against for a political belief. It isn't like there is a shortage of domain registrars in the world.
If there is a legal technicality where someone has to vote Democrat to start a domain registrar then there is a problem here. VeriSign doing this would be a concern. Unless I'm misreading this it isn't troubling; GoDaddy is not that important.
It'd be sad if the DNS system becomes political. But at this point we should be bracing for it, there aren't a lot of future paths where it stays neutral.