News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Forgetting My First Language by sinuhe69 on Friday September 03, 2021 @10:10PM (#28411465)
What a heartbreaking story. However, I believe it didn’t result from “wanting to be successful in America“ but from the estrangement from his parents and family. Millions other immigrants, who are successful in America, don’t lose their first language.
Re:Forgetting My First Language by tashi on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:17PM (#28411787)
I feel like I read a different article than you! I thought she was saying that she had a pretty good relationship with her parents overall (other than some teenage resentment about their not learning English), that she lost her fluency unintentionally just from not being around other Cantonese speakers, and that the story had a fairly happy ending, as she was now re-learning enough to have more meaningful conversations with them again.
Re:Forgetting My First Language by xyzelement on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:34PM (#28411847)
> hat she lost her fluency unintentionally just from not being around other Cantonese speakers

But how does this happen? If your mom and dad only speak Cantonese, then if you're having real conversations with them, you're maintaining that language.

The original poster must be right, she must have not cared to have deep conversations with them for a long long time to let things get this bad. Because he's right, plenty of people immigrate to the US and maintain their native language even if they never use it outside the home.

Re:Forgetting My First Language by tashi on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:50PM (#28411923)
Is that how it works? Deep enough conversations, periodically, prevent language attrition? I don't know anything about this phenomenon, so that could be how it works. But the fact that she seems to have love and gratitude for her parents and the fact that her brothers are in the same boat makes me not jump to blame it on a bad relationship.
Re:Forgetting My First Language by xyzelement on Saturday September 04, 2021 @12:03AM (#28411970)
> Is that how it works? Deep enough conversations, periodically, prevent language attrition?

Yes, that is exactly how it works. The logic in the article is that the author lost Cantonese because she wasn't speaking it. Atrophied.

The post we're replying to makes a good point. How do you not use the only language your parents speak? It means you're not talking to your parents.

Re:Forgetting My First Language by bmn__ on Saturday September 04, 2021 @10:25AM (#28415386)
> It means you're not talking to your parents.

The article admits that she

• rebelled and for a time would not speak (shout) to the parents other than English

• moved to the other side of the continent.

Re:Forgetting My First Language by tashi on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:26AM (#28412884)
You seem very certain, but that doesn't seem to be the consensus about how it works.
Re:Forgetting My First Language by xyzelement on Saturday September 04, 2021 @11:27AM (#28415924)
> You seem very certain, but that doesn't seem to be the consensus about how it works.

Just so I am clear, you're saying it's not an accepted fact that people don't lose a language they actively speak?

Re:Forgetting My First Language by tashi on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:47PM (#28418420)
Yes, to be 100% crystal clear, I'm saying the thing that feels so obvious to you that to deny it would be pure stupidity does not appear to be true.

There's a quick summary at https://languageattrition.org/use-or-lose/, from where you can get links to decades of research on language attrition. Apparently, for people who speak multiple languages, there's some kind of interference effect between languages that's very counterintuitive, which means there's not the correlation between time spent per language and fluency that you would think there would be.

Re:Forgetting My First Language by tasuki on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:30PM (#28418286)
I'm also pretty certain: deep enough conversations, periodically, prevent language attrition (I speak one language natively, three fluently).
Re:Forgetting My First Language by tashi on Saturday September 04, 2021 @04:01PM (#28418555)
That's a very impressive achievement, but I think this is one of those classic examples of the post hoc fallacy, "I succeeded by doing this, therefore those who do this will succeed." That logic is unsound.
Re:Forgetting My First Language by tasuki on Tuesday September 07, 2021 @05:34PM (#28450243)
Yes, that logic would have been unsound. It was not my reasoning, just a data point, and not a very impressive one :)

Deep enough conversations, periodically, prevent language attrition. How can I convince you? It's really just like anything else: practice helps. Is that a controversial claim?

Re:Forgetting My First Language by sinuhe69 on Friday September 03, 2021 @11:43PM (#28411895)
There’s often a significant difference between someone own perception/admission and reality. The fact that her parents have to call her and not vice versa in the context of Asian culture speaks volume. Also the typical content of the conversations she cited doesn’t suggest a rich communication. Anyway, if you speak a language regularly - in any language - you can’t lose it, not to mention your first language.
Re:Forgetting My First Language by Xplune13 on Saturday September 04, 2021 @04:48AM (#28413315)
My interpretation was similar to yours as I also thought that this resulted more from her estrangement from her family rather than... anything else to be honest. It is indeed sad.