News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by duxup on Friday September 03, 2021 @12:43PM (#28406480)
What if the result is everything is a rental / SaaS?

For the record I really don't mind SaaS products, they work great in many situations.

I just am not sure the innovation is the innovation we want.

Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by Animats on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:29PM (#28407002)
What if the result is everything is a rental / SaaS?

That's the paper's conclusion. They see the beginning of the piracy-friendly period as the release of BitTorrent in 2001, and the beginning of the end in 2013 when Microsoft Office 365 came out.

Now everything is tied to central control, who can turn off your service any time they want to.

Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by matheusmoreira on Saturday September 04, 2021 @03:52AM (#28413039)
That's fine. SaaS is just a fancy way of saying the software is running on someone else's computers. They can do whatever they want with their machines, including charging money for access.

People will eventually get fed up with it and make free software that runs locally. It will take time but I have no doubt it will happen. I find this is a much more reasonable proposition than waiting the 100+ years it takes for copyright to be invalidated.

Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by jokethrowaway on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:10PM (#28406788)
Once we get tired of SaaS, the market will create standalone expensive software.

Even if I have to say that the subscription model is pretty good for B2B: fixed expense per month, someone to bother if things don't work, instead of spending my own employees time keeping infra up and debugging bugs.

I don't like SaaS for my personal use, I prefer to pay once, keep forever and fix on my own (for similar reasons to why I like cooking my own food instead of ordering take out all the time).

Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by duxup on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:36PM (#28407080)
>the market will create standalone expensive software.

Maybe even hardware, like a Pi server that serves up the app even...

Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by MeinBlutIstBlau on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:15PM (#28406850)
They suck for two reasons: primarily now I need an account for everything I use with separate billing charges. It becomes annoying to manage. The other reason the egregious costs these companies charge. For a compiled version of software back in the day, I could get something that worked for $30-$100 and it would last years if not a decade. Now, some of these places are charging like $3-$20/month! Software value has not increased that much. If I gotta start paying for TODO apps and calendar managers, I'm just gonna move to Org Mode. The majority of what software provides is a nice gui environment to manage text. No clue how this crap can be worth as much as it is aside from supporting multiple platforms and enabling web based usage.
Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by abj on Friday September 03, 2021 @01:24PM (#28406929)
We need a SaaS that manages all of these SaaS subscriptions and accounts! That's something I'd pay $10 a month for
Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by MeinBlutIstBlau on Friday September 03, 2021 @05:45PM (#28409778)
I think it's because software has finally reached a point where everybody is adequate at using computers that new problems have developed compared to the ones that existed 10-20 years ago. So now the people who have no idea how to use a computer (or are willing to learn) they just pay for a SaaS.
Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by renewiltord on Friday September 03, 2021 @02:20PM (#28407532)
The big guys are trying to get this in their store models so that they can pull their 30% cut.
Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by BigMajestic on Friday September 03, 2021 @03:19PM (#28408208)
I wish more companies would follow the way of open source, self-hosted free version and paid version hosted in the cloud. Win - win.
Re:Software Piracy and IP Management: Strategic Responses to... by MaxBarraclough on Saturday September 04, 2021 @05:20AM (#28413477)
Unless they get crushed by one of the major cloud providers offering a rival managed service powered by the original codebase.