News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by pg on Friday August 22, 2008 @01:15PM (#283898)
Don't use a screwdriver to open bottles; use a bottle opener: http://tipjoy.com
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by axod on Friday August 22, 2008 @01:33PM (#283933)
I don't think the analogy fits perfectly though.

This sort of clickfraud is like using someone elses bottle opener to open the bottle vs buying your own bottle opener.

Clicking on adverts, you're using advertisers money to reward the website, instead of using your own.

Clearly it's not a good thing to advocate, but you can sort of see why some people may decide to do it.

A better suggestion IMHO would be for websites to use pay per lead/sale affiliate links, and just ask that if people were already going to buy something, that they use the websites links, thus giving the website a commission. That way no one is defrauded.

Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by derefr on Friday August 22, 2008 @02:29PM (#284008)
I had an idea for a browser extension that would rewrite all "sponsorable" links, whether they already were from a certain affiliate or not, to be from yours. You'd register at the extension's site and it would then automatically register you at all the sponsorable sites they supported. Best of all, the extension wouldn't be fixed to any individual donatee; rather, users would be able to click buttons on sites that read "sponsor me/us from now on", and switch the extension's target. There could also be a menu to select from previously used sponsors, obviously.
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by axod on Friday August 22, 2008 @02:38PM (#284026)
A more general idea for blogs/forums... When anyone points to a product that is recognized as having an affiliate program, modify the link to capture the commission and give it to the blog/forum owner.

Could quite easily be done just as a small javascript include and could work pretty well provided they get enough people posting links to products/websites with affiliate programs.

Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by derefr on Friday August 22, 2008 @03:32PM (#284099)
The last part of my idea, I figured, was essential to its success--if it wasn't the consumer's choice that caused already-affiliated links to be repurposed, it might break those "common carrier" rules that allow a lot of more questionable forums to exist (would an ISP be allowed to embedd an ad-blocker in their traffic proxies without then doing "decency filtering" censorship?). Additionally, users might not like the idea of their own links being hijacked in this way, filtering the scripts out with adblockers ;)
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by axod on Friday August 22, 2008 @03:33PM (#284104)
True, I agree it'd be best to be completely upfront about it with the users, and possibly give them a way to opt out of it.
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by breck on Thursday August 28, 2008 @12:41AM (#288858)
This is called "link hijacking" or another variant is "cookie stuffing". Generally looked at as unethical and dishonest. Though it is done quite frequently and very successfully by some people out there.
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by ivankirigin on Friday August 22, 2008 @03:46PM (#284114)
When you click on an Ad, the owner of the site gets only a fraction of the revenue. Tipjoy is much more direct and favorable.
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by axod on Friday August 22, 2008 @04:03PM (#284122)
Sure, but that is more than evened out by the fact that tipping is always going to be more work for the user than clicking an ad.
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by ivankirigin on Friday August 22, 2008 @04:14PM (#284134)
Clicking an add usually takes you away from the page. Tipjoy doesn't. You don't even have to pay right away - we trust that you'll pay eventually.

But putting money into a system is certainly a lot of work for lots of people.

Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by stcredzero on Friday August 22, 2008 @01:41PM (#283946)
No analogy fits perfectly. I hope TipJoy catches on in a big way everywhere. Voting the link up on social link sites is another good way to support what you like.
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by jamslevy on Friday August 22, 2008 @03:18PM (#284080)
As much as I like tipjoy (until recently I shared an office with them), I think that Seth brings up a very interesting issue.

We've got the metrics and acronyms down. But will we continue to deny the importance of emotional connection between a site's audience and its creator?

Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by ivankirigin on Friday August 22, 2008 @03:50PM (#284116)
I think that connection is really important. Tipjoy doesn't do a perfect job of accentuating it, but we try by pushing the tipping information out wherever we can, like friendfeed, twitter, and RSS.

Blogs are an interesting one-to-many-to-many dynamic where a content creator feeds an audience, each member of which feeds their social news services or friends.

Tipjoy could do a lot better to harness this relationship, and we have lots of plans, but Ads are so far removed from the relationship that I agree with Paul's analogy.

Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by mwerty on Friday August 22, 2008 @04:35PM (#284164)
Have you thought about doing a causes-donation type thing where the beneficiary is some advertised cause (eg: ACLU)?
Re:Seth Godin Advocates Click Fraud by ivankirigin on Saturday August 23, 2008 @11:27AM (#284655)
Yes. We actually already provide the functionality to dedicate your earnings to a non profit.

The issue here is that you need to make a marketing push into non profits. That hasn't been where we've focused our resources.