News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by nanis on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:01AM (#28366801)
> Is rationing ... bad?

Yes. When a good or service is always available to anyone who can pay the price, all one needs to do is find the money and one can get it.

When prices are set artificially low, both current and long term go down which results in perpetual shortages. Since getting the thing now depends not just on being able to come up with the cash, but relies on the pen of a bureaucrat, corruption seeps in and becomes endemic.

This charity is able to get it done by requiring adherence to a specific religion which serves both as a selection and an enforcement mechanism.

If one is tempted to think of generalizing this, I would recommend reading about both Western socialists waxing poetic about USSR's "solutions" to housing shortages and the reality of housing in the Soviet Union. Unfortunately, city & urban planning programs as well as architecture schools tend to produce a lot of credentialed people who parrot the former.

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by iSnow on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:14AM (#28366915)
But housing doesn't work like this at all.

"all one needs to do is find the money" is the mechanism that keeps some people out of the housing market, or at least makes their lives pretty hard. Middle-class families can find the money, but the poor do not and usually cannot (for whatever reasons) raise their value on the job market enough.

A case can be made for rationed housing at extremely low prices. If you let anyone in, you would get a cash-flow problem and distort the market, but not if you limit it to the poor.

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by nanis on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:34AM (#28367165)
> But housing doesn't work like this at all.

The incentives and the price mechanism is independent of the desire of some people to think this or that good/service is "special".

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by jorvi on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:12AM (#28366898)
> Yes. When a good or service is always available to anyone who can pay the price, all one needs to do is find the money and one can get it.

This sounds nice but breaks down because shelter is a human need, it is not a new iPhone.

I am aware that the solution to housing crises is build build build, and that the more profit is in developing housing the more there is being built, but pretending a place to live is like any other common good is cold and wrong.

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by luckylion on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @10:22AM (#28368466)
> pretending a place to live is like any other common good is cold and wrong.

Does it help if you pretend that it's not? Do you get more investments into housing, and in the end, more houses, if you consider housing different from other markets?

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by jorvi on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @11:03AM (#28368994)
I am not pretending anything, I am merely pointing out that shelter, like food an water, is a basic human right (although judging by HNs donwvotes, they'd be fine with starving and dehydrating people as long as someone is making a massive profit).
Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by luckylion on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @12:09PM (#28369780)
I think many here disagree with you about it being a human right, because unlike the earlier human rights, it's not "leave people be" at its core, it's "you have to do X for people". If anything, it's a human entitlement, but that doesn't have the same ring to it, I suppose.

And then there's the next part: how good and how much? What's the housing that everyone supposedly has a right to? 100sqft? 500? 1000? And of what quality, and where? Do they get to choose the location?

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by guerrilla on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @05:24PM (#28373880)
> If anything, it's a human entitlement, but that doesn't have the same ring to it, I suppose.

This is nonsense you just made up. Positive and negative rights are both rights, as is common understood in English but especially as defined within political science and philosophy. [1]

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Negative_and_positive_rights

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by luckylion on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @03:28AM (#28377245)
Yes, and positive rights in that context are entitlements. With a right to be housed, you're entitled to a house/apartment/shelter.
Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by jorvi on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @06:06AM (#28378027)
The right to shelter is literally in the Universal Decleration of Human Rights. There is no disagreeing about it, it factually is a human right.
Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by eesmith on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:25AM (#28367038)
You presume infinite resources.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Wave_(Arizona) has a rationing system.

> Due to the fragile nature of the formation and the large number of people wishing to visit it, a daily lottery system is used to dispense only ten next-day permits in person at the Kanab visitor center. Additionally, ten online permits for each date are available four months in advance of a planned trip.

There will be a perpetual shortage.

This is not a bad thing ... unless you don't care about preserving things for the future.

Do you still think rationing is bad? Or is my example not a case of rationing?

Bavaria is majority Catholic. "Demonstrate financial need" is likely a much stronger selection mechanism.

You didn't answer my question about why, if there's a wait list for this place, and since it's proven to be economically sustainable, other housing isn't built along these lines.

> corruption seeps in and becomes endemic

After 500 years, is the Fuggerei endowment fund corrupt?

Corruption can seep in whenever the person making the decision isn't the person making the profit. Even in a free market.

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by gruez on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:42AM (#28367264)
>Bavaria is majority Catholic. "Demonstrate financial need" is likely a much stronger selection mechanism.

According to wikipedia bavaria is only 49.6% catholic. I'm not sure how excluding more than half the population on the basis of religion can be justified.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bavaria#Demographics

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by Moru on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @09:01AM (#28367494)
German Catholic is pretty strong still. Church runs a lot of hospitals and kid/youth things, daycare and so on. They require Catholic employees, they frown upon non married couples and so on.
Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by eesmith on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @02:57PM (#28372047)
Then my source is out of date. As your source points out, 10 years ago that was 56.4% -- http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Bavaria&oldid=4369...

My point is that the requirement to demonstrate financial need is likely a significantly stricter criterion than the requirement to be Catholic, so the latter shouldn't be singled out.

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by sokoloff on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:36AM (#28367197)
It’s not obvious to me that this is economically self-sustaining, that is to say it could be recreated starting from scratch today (without the initial grant from the Fuggers).
Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by nanis on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:46AM (#28367309)
> corruption seeps in and becomes endemic

After 500 years, is the Fuggerei endowment fund corrupt?

I do not know about their internal workings. As I said, in this special case, verified adherence to the rules of a specific religion may help. However, history is filled with examples of catholic clergy dispensing with favorable judgements in exchange for things of value. How do you know if a more "deserving" person was not passed over for someone else who may be had a good connection or promised personal favors etc.

Regardless, I was referring to the situation when someone tries to replicate something which seems to work in a 160 person case at a grand scale.

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by eesmith on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @03:09PM (#28372173)
You implied the corruption was inevitable. Either the endowment fund is corrupt already, or your assertion about 'inevitable' is meaningless.

History is filled with lots of examples of corruption. Including in free markets.

You were referring to the existence of a years-long waiting list, as if it were a meaningful evidence they should raise rents in order to avoid the artificial scarcity you think is universally bad.

Who do you think they should kick out, and why?

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by mattcwilson on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @08:59AM (#28367467)
Whose definition of “deserving” is most applicable here, and why theirs?

Who is suggesting any intent to replicate this at a grand scale?

Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by nanis on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @10:57AM (#28368898)
I prefer not to have to prove that I am deserving according to someone's value system, just that I am able to pay the price.
Re:At the world's oldest social housing, rent hasn't changed... by mattcwilson on Wednesday September 01, 2021 @07:42AM (#28378571)
And that’s a perfectly valid preference.

What does it have to do with the Fuggerai, or the mentioned new settlements planned in Sierra Leone or Lithuania?