Why do you assume Americans are more deserving of Apple's manufacturing jobs than the Chinese?
> If I pay premium dollar for quality and durability, I would rather that support local manufacturing and local economies, than have that sitting in Apple's vaults.
Unfortunately, the Chinese also pay premium dollar and would also rather support local manufacturing and local economies. As China is deemed to become Apple's largest market, it makes sense for Apple to support the Chinese economy rather than the US one.[1]
[1] http://blogs.computerworld.com/18517/apple_crazy_china_will_...
Because the consumers of every nation on earth, deep-down, are superficially patriotic. We don't want to recognize that the global economy is post-nation state. We want to pretend that when we buy an American company's products it is, American. Just as if we decide to buy an Italian sports car we want it to be Italian. Companies prey on these emotional ties to our identities in all manner of ways. In the parent thread's example, Apple does that by labeling their products' packaging, "Designed by Apple in California."
I don't necessarily blame companies for these emotional ties. There was a time when those ties really meant something.
There are great benefits to the US market and many, such as Apple, have taken advantage of it. They also take advantage of the system and keep their money overseas so it won't get taxed.
But when I really look at it, I don't feel connected to any country as much as to history and the ideals of Silicon Valley.
So to me it seems to weird to hold the place I was born as anything special.
counter-point first: I've heard good things about Sears stuff, but it's not available here
I've never considered American manufacturing to be high quality or premium. My experience is mostly based on American cars - which tend to have appalling build quality and reliability - and a few "made in America" bits I have, all of which are pretty average.
I tend to associate American manufacturing with things like welding huge bits of iron together. durability? sure. attention to detail and care? not so much
Most of the American bits never really leave the US because logistics cost the same everywhere. A big heavy washing machine from china loses its cost advantage once shipping and duties are added to the price. A high-end laptop has most of the price in labor and parts. Shipping costs next to nothing for it.
American cars haven't really impressed me. For a while I also questionned the quality; why settle for something with a 3 year warranty when the japanese and koreans have 7 and 10 years. I believe the American car makers have learned a lot about this after getting trounced in the market. They have been extending there warranties and covering parts that weren't covered before.
But it's not until you get into the really high-tech stuff that American builds even show up. Like 7-10 layer circuit boards, aerospace equipment, military hardware, and extreme environment hardware. To put it another way, the Americans, Japanese, and Germans sell the equipment to China to build the stuff they sell.
Now combine that with this article and people like Mike Daisey's views that Apple is somehow uniquely responsible to blame for the plight of blue collar workers in China.
Apparently Apple is the cause of all pain in the world. Sheesh I thought they just sold electronics.
OSHA and the associated regulations legislated us right out of the market.
Wait, you think this is bad?
Do you really think America can only compete on being the lowest cost manufacturer?
And the scenario shows, the iPhone could be manufactured in the US and still be profitable (50% margin).
Finally, there aren't a finite number of businesses; those who think the EPA's regulations are reasonable should have no problem starting a US business to demonstrate the point.
But what ends up happening then is that Singapore for example actively works to import entrepreneurs because their best and brightest went into government.
Apple makes and builds high-end products and has the fat margins that goes along with it - instead of outsourcing all manufacturing to China, it could choose to build everything in the US, employ the locals and use that as a selling point. If I pay premium dollar for quality and durability, I would rather that support local manufacturing and local economies, than have that sitting in Apple's vaults. In the end, this is not unlike the the local food movement - people would rather pay extra and support local farmers and economies.