News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Screeching Voice of the Minority by robertoandred on Sunday August 29, 2021 @10:35PM (#28352332)
There are human reviewers at Google, Facebook, and every other organization that has to moderate content. Not a novel idea.

And why would the NCMEC give law enforcement info about people they know are innocent?

Re:A Screeching Voice of the Minority by breput on Sunday August 29, 2021 @10:53PM (#28352411)
> There are human reviewers at Google, Facebook, and every other organization that has to moderate content. Not a novel idea.

For unencrypted content uploaded to their servers. That makes it a "Them Problem". Apple's approach is to scan before it is uploaded (and like the article says, "for now" - this can change with only a configuration change for all we know). And this could be a per-jurisdiction option and again, no one would know.

You have a point that this is not completely novel problem but do we have actual data on the number of real vs. false positives on the "everyone but Apple" group? Matthew Green probably would know but he doesn't[0].

[0] https://twitter.com/matthew_d_green/status/14283829528580833...

Re:A Screeching Voice of the Minority by breput on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:07PM (#28352470)
There is an website[0] set up already to show to show how easy it is to find collisions with a photo of a beagle.

The left side photos are all apparently kitten photos but what if it was a photo of the Nirvana baby and, as a human reviewer, you had no access to the right side photo because it was just a hash in an anonymous database?

[0] https://thishashcollisionisnotporn.com/

Re:A Screeching Voice of the Minority by judge2020 on Monday August 30, 2021 @12:21AM (#28352787)
The Nirvana baby, as with many non-sexual pictures of naked babies, isn't considered CSAM and thus wouldn't be flagged. Even if it was, NCMEC reviewers (and Apple reviewers) almost certainly view the original CSAM next to the new photo when they receive potential re-circulations of the photo, if their task is indeed to verify the authenticity of a match. If reviewers had to make a CSAM judgement call on every incoming image, it'd be an extremely brittle system.
Re:A Screeching Voice of the Minority by robertoandred on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:09PM (#28352481)
No one would know? iOS is constantly analyzed by people around the world for security vulnerabilities, strange behavior, etc. Why would this be different?
Re:A Screeching Voice of the Minority by mastazi on Sunday August 29, 2021 @10:56PM (#28352423)
Oh well if there are human reviewers then we can be sure there will be no abuse.

After all, Youtube copyright strikes have never been abused thanks to the fact that there are human reviewers.

Also, no app has ever been incorrectly removed from the Apple App Store, for the same reason that there are human reviewers.

This is thanks to the fact that human reviewers never make mistakes, unlike the rest of humans.

What could go wrong if we adopt the same system for something that could potentially result in a criminal investigation?

Re:A Screeching Voice of the Minority by robertoandred on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:14PM (#28352501)
So your concern is that the automatic review fails, Apple’s human review fails, the NCMEC’s human review fails, and police go after you?
Re:A Screeching Voice of the Minority by mastazi on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:22PM (#28352532)
My concern is that those mechanisms that regularly fail in other domains, as we have seen time and time again in recent years, would also fail in this case.

Are you able to explain why this specific case would be different?

Re:A Screeching Voice of the Minority by breput on Sunday August 29, 2021 @11:13PM (#28352496)
Humans are the cause and solution to every problem.