Indeed, this article (despite many incorrect facts about the process) is right in that this is just a vocal minority 'screeching' to get the message out there to anyone willing to listen. The absolute majority of the population, or at least adult population, will always choose the path of least resistance - they just wants to live, work, avoid hardship, and partake in dopamine-inducing activity every day. There's a reason Google and Amazon are trillion-dollar enterprises and Hulu still has an ad-supported version that 70% of people choose[0] - people don't value privacy at all when dealing with these faceless companies. Society has always shifted the level of privacy they accept (think taxes, audits, search & seizure with probably cause), and this will just be another shift that people accept so that they continue on with their lives while not sacrificing any of their valuable time.
0: https://variety.com/2019/digital/news/hulu-ad-supported-subs...
Personally, I have no problem with ad-supported and generic/no-tracking. Ads themselves are not the privacy invasion, and have a reasonable history of helping to pay for things, and it is possible to rebuild ad companies to respect privacy (again). (It might take burning a few big players to the ground first, unfortunately.)
Maybe only a minority of Apple customers are aware of and understand the scanning issue and are giving feedback to Apple via the web. But here is a thought experiment: Does anyone think that if the majority of Apple customers were briefed on the issue and then asked if they agree/disgree with the minority of customers would they disagree with this informed minority.
"Tech" companies should know whats best for advertisers. They can be expected to ignore user feedback complaining about surveillance. OTOH, Apple should know whats best for users. Its users are telling the company and the company is irgnoring the feedback.
This kinda flies in the face of that except for the fact it's wrapped in, as you said, "common good" goals.
I've never been Apple, but I'm currently attempting to migrate to a LineageOS daily-driver mobile, although I still require some amount (nano) of Google to get by. Ironically, I needed a Windows machine to do this, whilst I'm already almost exclusively Linux (Ubuntu and Pop!_OS).
Hostile for sure, unbelievable, not really.
This type of "we know what's best for you" attitude is deeply ingrained in the DNA of Apple as a company.
The fact that they did get it right many time and that their batting average is above other tech companies is no excuse for the fact that the attitude is deeply flawed.
This was bound to happen.
You are holding it wrong. Here we go, we are removing "escape" but you have a touch-bar with customizable functionality, sorry this is the best laptop keyboard design - you will adapt to it.
We are removing ports - but you will have Dongles - lot of dongles and this MagSafe shit that you love so much - no more for you.
Innovation my TrashCan - not upgradable peace of trash, after 6 years - here we go MacPro - only for the Apple "elite hustler" club members, as a bonus 1000 dollars monitor stand.
We don't like MacOS - to much control for the user is not good for Apple Profits - we like iOS and we will make everything like it. You will adapt.
Now we are innovating on a geo-political stage, protecting our brand with the all time classic "Neural Cash" and bending a knee or two in the name of Apple dominance and antitrust avoidance. You will adapt, because you are trapped and we know you love us.
Privacy, my ass. :)
Happen to have any suggestions for what a privacy-conscious consumer should look into?
If I need a photo - I grab my old Sony RX. If I know that I will shoot - my old Leica MP240 with Summilux and 24mpx is enough. If I have to communicate with text - email or signal on computer. If I need in car navigation - Garmin.
Deleted Facebook/Instagram spyware long time ago. Flickr also. Self-hosting is the way to go.
I am using my iPhone for calls and sms with clear knowledge that everything is recorded. Banking apps when I don't have access to computer.
I have iPad Pro 12"WIFI with faulty WIFI and no Apple care which I use only for drawing and digital painting.
People around me are switching to deGoogled smartphones with Lineage/Calyx.
Pop!_OS (no Ubuntu telemetry and OpenSnitch) over MacBook Air is working flawlessly. Company MacBooks are with Arch/Manjaro. Will run Catalina for specific tasks without internet until it breaks completely.
The hostile design decisions of Apple are unbelievable. After 20 days of public backslash Apple is preparing for massive iPhone 13 campaign and pushing this obviously flawed intrusion with "common good" goals, normalizing surveillance on a new level. And all of this after Pegasus/NSO.
But actually I am glad. No more shiny toys and marketing illusions for me. Expect everybody to follow suit. Year or two down the road this type of scanning and control will be mandatory.
So the only way to respond is to invest in your privacy. Not in user-hostile, dark pattern designed products.