News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Weird Languages by coldtea on Saturday August 28, 2021 @06:09PM (#28341952)
>I'm glad someone took time to disprove it

What do you think "disprove" means in this context though?

E.g. do you think they really settled anything, the way we can prove a math theorem or verify some physical theory to hold (as a predictive model) to the nth degree of precision?

>When I read the description, I understand "determines" as in, your thoughts internally work in terms of language processing, so their complexity is limited to the complexity of the language(s) you know.

That would mean that developing further language is impossible or even that developing the first languages would be impossible - as those nearly language-less peoples have no means to develop those more complex later concepts.

It's not like e.g. Europeans (let's take them as a model of "advanced" language) emerged in nature in fully formed ancient Greek, Latin, English, French, etc.

They started with the same or even more "constrained" languages (verbally and conceptually) as any primitive people, and - going back to our forefathers - even language-less.

Re:Weird Languages by TeMPOraL on Saturday August 28, 2021 @08:08PM (#28342728)
> What do you think "disprove" means in this context though?

What it means for every scientific hypothesis: it takes infinite amount of evidence to positively prove it, but it takes one counterexample to kill it. +/- the usual uncertainty caveats.

> That would mean that developing further language is impossible or even that developing the first languages would be impossible

Not necessarily. It would mean that you can't think about some concepts without first extending the language to support them. Languages still could be extended piece by piece.

Re:Weird Languages by coldtea on Sunday August 29, 2021 @10:29AM (#28346984)
>What it means for every scientific hypothesis: it takes infinite amount of evidence to positively prove it, but it takes one counterexample to kill it. +/- the usual uncertainty caveats.

Only in such soft sciences you can "prove" any number of competing hypothesis, and have fractions arguing about them for decades or centuries. And whether a "counter example" is valid and "kills" a theory, will be a matter of interpretation and endlessly debated as well.

>It would mean that you can't think about some concepts without first extending the language to support them. Languages still could be extended piece by piece.

If you can always extend a language to new concepts, the language is not limiting in the strong SWH sense. If it was it would be impossible to reach those concepts from a reduced set of concepts.

Re:Weird Languages by emodendroket on Sunday August 29, 2021 @12:24PM (#28348057)
> Only in such soft sciences you can "prove" any number of competing hypothesis, and have fractions arguing about them for decades or centuries.

It took millennia for spontaneous generation to be definitively disproven.

Re:Weird Languages by coldtea on Monday August 30, 2021 @03:29AM (#28353459)
That's exactly my point, as that was before we settled on the scientific method.

So this might have been relatedto biology (or in other domains physics, chemistry, and so on), but the matter was debated in the soft sciences way, not in the way we do biology in the 20th century.

Re:Weird Languages by emodendroket on Monday August 30, 2021 @11:12AM (#28356386)
It was actually a few hundred years after the modern scientific method because scientists attempting to apply the method failed to spot confounding factors and interpreted their results incorrectly, something I think is hardly impossible even today in even the hardest of supposed hard sciences.