News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Weird Languages by coldtea on Saturday August 28, 2021 @01:07PM (#28339612)
On the other hand, it's not like linguists are doing exactly a hard science, and their discrediting something means much, especially when it touches totally unrelated domains like psychology and neuroscience.
Re:Weird Languages by _emacsomancer_ on Saturday August 28, 2021 @02:07PM (#28340122)
Sometimes, when it's a field well outside of your area of expertise, not making pronouncements can save embarrassment later on.
Re:Weird Languages by coldtea on Saturday August 28, 2021 @02:47PM (#28340437)
My sentiments exactly (only on the other side).

You seem to respect everything labeled academic, but not all "areas of expertise" and not all "fields" are equally valid -- and surely not just because they are taught in universities, written about in "peer reviewed" journals, and so on.

Linguistics is closer to soft sciences than the opposite.

Re:Weird Languages by _emacsomancer_ on Saturday August 28, 2021 @02:58PM (#28340531)
> You seem to respect everything labeled academic,

I assure you, I really don't.

> but not all "areas of expertise" and not all "fields" are equally valid -- and surely not just because they are taught in universities, written about in "peer reviewed" journals, and so on.

Fully agreed.

> Linguistics is closer to soft sciences than the opposite.

"Linguistics" spans a range of things from the humanities to the 'soft' sciences (in the sense that psychology and cognitive studies 'soft' sciences) to logic/maths.

Re:Weird Languages by emodendroket on Saturday August 28, 2021 @01:26PM (#28339778)
If we want to take this into a more concrete and measurable realm, every programming language is going to get converted into the same machine code before it is run, so it is quite untrue that there is any idea that "cannot be expressed" in one programming language but can be expressed in another. It may be more or less convenient to do but nothing like the strong Sapir-Whorf hypothesis for human languages.
Re:Weird Languages by coldtea on Saturday August 28, 2021 @01:33PM (#28339838)
Well, in programming yes.

Though even in programming, there are e.g. non turing complete languages (e.g. simple regex languages), languages without certain high level facilities (making it much harder to organize your code in terms of certain concepts - analogous to organizing your thinking of the world around certain concepts -, which is a SWH-like effect), languages that can't express e.g. infinite loops and are certain to terminate (used e.g. for business logic, templating, etc), and so on.

Even if it all goes down to assembly, a language like Cobol might it much harder to write e.g. a 3D game. And that can be enough for games not be written in that language - it doesn't have to be impossible, just hard, which is enough to discourage most, aside from a few weirdos writing games in Cobol and compilers in bash.