News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by mdorazio on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:53AM (#28314941)
To save you from reading to answer the clickbait title: insufficient supply combined with people abusing the system to sublet for profit or gift rent controlled apartments to friends and family.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by alistairSH on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:02AM (#28315069)
Title is also, potentially, not actually supported by data...

>Only around 8% of Swedes live in households spending more than 40% of disposable income on housing, compared to 15% in the UK and almost 40% in Greece, according Eurostat data.

Something is keeping rent low in Sweden (relative to a few other European counties).

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by melolife on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:15AM (#28315256)
Rent control does keep rent low. What it creates is a supply problem, which could possibly explain the decades-long wait list for an apartment in Stockholm.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by nivenkos on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:19AM (#28315305)
Those queues are for public first-hand contracts. You can always rent second-hand (for up to 2 years, from a private owner), private first-hand (more expensive queues from development firms), company rentals (in some cases, your company can be a guarantor, and you rent like a commercial entity with no time limit or deposit, etc. but usually higher rents), or you can buy a place.

The issue is there aren't enough first-hand contracts, or enough properties in general. But the rent controls as discussed only apply to first-hand contracts, which are the minority.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by epistasis on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:20AM (#28315308)
It potentially creates a supply problem, if certain assumptions are met.

However those assumptions rarely hold in practice. In the US, to get a construction loan, you can't assume a big rise in rents in coming years. So the financial decision to build new housing is gated by an effective assumption of rent control by the financiers.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by bjoli on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:25AM (#28315368)
There are other things at play. If the low prices were the only thing stopping new houses from popping up, the 5x price increase for buying apartments would have solved all the problems in Stockholm.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by kqr on Friday August 27, 2021 @02:04AM (#28324760)
The available space for building stuff in municipal Stockholm is what it is, so some part of the supply problem would still be there without rent control, I would assume.

Removing rent control would convert the decades-long wait list into a decades-long struggle to make enough money to afford rent, would it not?

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by nivenkos on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:08AM (#28315158)
There are separate controls on being able to rent out flats for more than 2 years.

So you can't really be an absentee landlord.

The rent controls apply to first-hand contracts (kinda like council housing in the UK). Which is basically non-existent for working people now.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by flavius29663 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:20AM (#28315316)
This reminds me of the grocery shopping in communist Romania. My family would spend so little on groceries every month...maybe 400 LEI out of 2 salaries of 2000, so under 10%. The catch is there was nothing on the shelves, if they would bring in bread you would have in instant queue for 2 hours. Same for cabbages, carrots etc.

If you just look at the expense you'll miss the fact that people don't get enough groceries, or apartments.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by bjourne on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:17AM (#28316035)
It may also be interesting to note that rent control is supported by 75 to 80% of the population. For a policy that "isn't working" it is strangely popular.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by ransom1538 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:03AM (#28315090)
"Something is keeping rent low in Sweden (relative to a few other European counties)."

Weather.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by merpnderp on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:56AM (#28314987)
How is something as simple as basic supply and demand still a shocker to so many people? Rent control is just the government picking the winners and losers, with those who are corrupt, play dirty, and generally antisocial being the winners.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by occz on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:27AM (#28315388)
> How is something as simple as basic supply and demand still a shocker to so many people? Rent control is just the government picking the winners and losers, with those who are corrupt, play dirty, and generally antisocial being the winners.

Because it's not just about supply and demand, and attempting to frame it as such is seriously reductionistic.

Essentially you're at Why #1 here, and you have at least 4 more Why's before you even begin to scratch the surface of the root cause

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by epistasis on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:36AM (#28315496)
This would be a far more convincing comment if you could hint at these other directions, otherwise it's just extremely condescending.

I'm a big supporter of rent control. But I also think the problem here is supply and demand. I've never met a supply-and-demand skeptic that would do anything except deny its applicability. They could ever explain why themselves or point to somebody else's explanation. And I've met a fair number of such folks.

I'm left thinking that they just don't want to see new homes or new people. But if you have an explanation, I'm all ears.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by occz on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:20AM (#28316069)
I was wary of trying to go down the rabbit hole of explaining more of the situation, as I don't feel that I'm enough of an expert in the subject. I was merely critical of the lack of nuance in the analysis ("it's just supply and demand").

But let's give it a shot!

There's no denying that there is a lack of supply in housing in some parts of Sweden, particularly in Stockholm, where there are very long queues to get a reasonably priced apartment to rent. There's no denying that rent controls are probably one contributing factor to why the supply is too low. But it's important to note that it's just one of many variables in this equation. So what other contributing factors are there?

Well, for one, acquiring permits is pretty damn hard in Sweden. It's a long process with a lot of NIMBYism, not entirely unlike what I've understood is the case in San Francisco.

There's also the issue of rental units being profitable on a far longer horizon, leading investors looking to make their money back quickly to look at the buyers market instead. Which leads us down the path of the very high prices in the buyers market. What's causing that? For one, very low interest rates in the housing loan market (about 1-2%), but also tax policy, giving lenders a tax deduction relative to their interests payments. Yes, you read that correctly - buying a home, ie being richer than average, comes with tax deductions.

In Sweden, paying off your home loan for a long time wasn't even required - you just continually paid the interest, and perhaps lent even more money against your home when the value increased.

There's also the fact that the public housing providers have more or less been dismantled in many cases, and sold off to what essentially amounts to slumlords, attempting to game the ever-living hell out of the rent control rules. The playbook is more or less:

- Buy old public housing

Then - Spend as little as possible on upkeep, be actively hostile to current tenants - When anything goes wrong inside the rental unit, refuse to do anything but a full-scale renovation

And

- When any tenant moves out, perform a full-scale renovation

And finally

- Legally raise the price, as the standard of the rental unit has increased, often increasing the price as much as 50%

I don't pretend to know the answer to this complex issue, nor do I pretend to entirely understanf every part of it. Nor do I claim that rent control is the right answer or the wrong. But one thing is for sure - reductive arguments claiming that rent control is the root cause is wrong on the basis that it does not begin to understand the issue even slightly.

Hopefully this begins to cover some of the nuance of the issue.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by merpnderp on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:18PM (#28318535)
All you did was point out why there wasn't enough supply. We all know why big cities have a supply shortage and it is because regulations and existing property owners make it either impossible or too onerous to build more homes. What you did was just state the obvious take away from my statement in a long winded manner, while apparently under the misunderstanding that there's someone left who hasn't heard this all before.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by epistasis on Thursday August 26, 2021 @12:44PM (#28317293)
Huh, I didn't except to agree with you nearly 100% on this, but I do!

These are all very legitimate concerns. But at the heart of all this is still the supply problem, the lack of housing.

I also agree that blaming this on rent control is wrong. But the real problem is enacting rent control, then saying "that's enough, problem solved." Because at the core there is still the shortage problem, which makes al the other problems worse.

Has rent control "worked"? Both yea and no. It has worked at what it is meant to do, which is great. But it hasn't solved housing, as too many proponents say it will. Similarly, more housing alone won't solve everything, but it makes all these other problems much easier.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by imtringued on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:32PM (#28321118)
The people who are against rent control want to solve problems before they begin. The ones who want rent control want to appear to solve problems after decades of mismanagement.

Of course, abolishing rent control doesn't get rid of mismanagement but rent control is generally used to justify mismanagement.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by occz on Friday August 27, 2021 @07:26AM (#28326413)
I wish I could believe that, but it's evident that it's just not the case - at least not by all actors advocating against rent control. As mentioned in the article, the prime minister and his government was struck down because they were supporting removing rent controls - without any form of viable replacement.

In a perfect world I would also like to see rent control removed, as there certainly are negative consequences from the policy, but removal without viable alternatives literally means that a sizeable chunk of poor people will be out on their asses, more or less. I cannot in good conscience support that.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:25AM (#28315365)
Which only happens in housing, and not in - say - defence contracting. Or banking.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by tbihl on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:02AM (#28315074)
Typical populace, responding to incentives and trying to find ways to thrive.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by ahoy on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:55AM (#28314965)
so the same things that cause issues in NYC
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by dijit on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:58AM (#28315009)
Supply underpins most of the housing crisis'

London is having a hard time because supply is less than demand.

Stockholm, NYC, Paris for the same reason.

It's really one of the largest things that seemingly every developed country is struggling with right now.

I don't personally believe Stockholm is more affected than any other European capital except perhaps Berlin, which somehow seems to stay affordable (likely because of supply).

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by Nav_Panel on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:00AM (#28315052)
>It's really one of the largest things that seemingly every developed country is struggling with right now.

Not Japan! Tokyo rents are surprisingly cheap relative to other major cities.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by ilammy on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:33AM (#28315464)
The key here is considering housing a consumable with 20-year lifespan tops, as opposed to multigenerational investment vessel.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by kalleboo on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:31AM (#28316199)
Yeah this is the big difference. A home in Japan is not an investment. You buy a home to live in, the mortgage is around the same or a bit cheaper than rent, but the property depreciates like a car, and while the land has value, the house you built on it has negative value (since the next tenant has to tear it down).
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by jlokier on Thursday August 26, 2021 @12:13PM (#28316852)
> (since the next tenant has to tear it down).

In Tokyo?

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by nwj on Thursday August 26, 2021 @06:15PM (#28321675)
My understanding is that in Japan zoning restrictions are controlled at a federal rather than local level. I've read that this helps prevent local incumbents using the zoning system to exclude new construction.

In other words, Japan lacks the regulatory environment (common in all these other countries) that depresses supply.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by NovemberWhiskey on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:56AM (#28314981)
Right - "rent control not working because of predictable outcomes of rent control".
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by ahoy on Thursday August 26, 2021 @09:57AM (#28314997)
alternatively, "Rent control not working because government allows it to be undermined."
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by 988747 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:11AM (#28315198)
Rent control is not working because it cannot work - it is directly contradicting the laws of nature, such as supply and demand. Housing gets build in order to extract profit from it. If you disallow profit, you are disincentivizing new housing construction, and you create perverse incentives to work around rent control.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:24AM (#28315349)
Strange how rents were manageable in the UK while there was a national not for profit council house building program.

Perhaps there's a lesson to be learned from that.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by imtringued on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:37PM (#28321189)
Land is expensive and nobody wants to tax it.

More generally. Non reproducible assets/aka monopolies can extort more money out of people now that people have more money thanks to low interest rates. Notice how being rich doesn't make you rich because of abuse of monopoly power to do perfect price discrimination.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by occz on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:58AM (#28315773)
>the laws of nature, such as supply and demand.

This has got to be satire, right?

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by 988747 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:51PM (#28319742)
It is actually not. Basic laws of economy are much like the laws of physics: they work the same whether you believe in them or not. Trying to circumvent them with legislation such as rent control leads to various second order effects. For rent control that means limited supply and worse quality of the available apartments. Also: people unwilling to move, occupying apartments much too big for them, just because they are rent-controlled.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by occz on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:33PM (#28320301)
I know that the observable properties of economic systems happen regardless of belief. It's just seriously strange to equate them with 'laws of nature'. Next thing you know someone is going to call something like the law of demeter a law of nature. Just sort of absurd, really.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by imtringued on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:35PM (#28321159)
There is no such thing as non undermined rent control.

There are a thousand things to do with a property and the government decides, hey guys, stop that 1 thing out of thousands. Then people will do all the thousand other things. The government then acts surprised that its incomplete policy has failed.

You can also just tax the land.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by YPPH on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:00AM (#28315049)
It seems awfully hard to enforce all cases.

If a subletter voluntarily enters into an agreement with a lessee to pay above the rent control amount, who is the victim?

Is it not a victimless crime?

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by ahoy on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:12AM (#28315214)
The notion of "victimless crimes" has always been odd to me. The harm might be diffuse, or indirect, but I'm certainly hurt when illegal sublets drive up the cost of rent in my neighborhood.

Even if the "agreement" was "voluntary" for the parties who entered it, it can still affect third parties.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by danuker on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:45AM (#28315606)
> I'm certainly hurt when illegal sublets drive up the cost of rent in my neighborhood.

Would you be less hurt when there is nothing available?

All rent control does is favor "first-come-first-serve" instead of "who pays the most".

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by danuker on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:05AM (#28315112)
I suspect the subletter is breaking the law, due to charging more than is allowed.

The victim is the person not able to rent on a first-come-first-serve basis instead of someone willing to pay more than is allowed.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by YPPH on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:10AM (#28315194)
>The victim is the person not able to rent on a first-come-first-serve basis instead of someone willing to pay more than is allowed.

That's indeed the only sensible thing I can think of. But it's a very odd thing to me (that a mutual, consensual agreement between two people is governed by the interests of third parties).

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:32AM (#28315451)
That's because there's a thing called the social contract, which makes it clear to anyone who can parse situations like a mature adult that all policy has wider social consequences, and short term gimme gimme can have disastrous long term results.

And also because "consensual agreements" rarely are. Typically one party has more power than the other and can force terms.

By definition, you only get truly consensual agreements when the balance of power is equal - which it very much isn't in rental markets with deliberately restricted stock.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by exhilaration on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:06AM (#28315130)
Isn't the landlord the victim in this case? The extra money should be going to them, not the lessee that is likely violating their rental agreement.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by 988747 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:22AM (#28315335)
But the landlords are all greedy capitalists who do not deserve that money anyway /s

For the group of aspiring startup founders HN community has a very high percentage of Marxists in it :)

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by TheOtherHobbes on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:37AM (#28315518)
Not all. But these kinds of stories aren't as rare as they should be.

https://www.quora.com/What-is-your-worst-landlord-story

Of course some tenants are terrible too, but those stories seem to be rarer.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by mc32 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:00AM (#28315041)
How do you even monitor against fraud if even in communist countries this could happen? People will game it, if there is “profit” in it.

The only way to avoid it is a very tyrannical East German system where people rat on each other to, we’ll, gain something, maybe that coveted apartment…

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by oytis on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:15AM (#28315246)
How do you monitor that people are not working illegally? Or are not selling drugs?

It's hard to make sure either of this never ever happens, but it is definitely possible to make sure it's not happening as much as to become a social problem.

Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by mc32 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:19AM (#28315300)
That’s my point. It’s not possible and you can only get close if you use tyrannical methods of surveillance and invasions of privacy.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by oytis on Thursday August 26, 2021 @12:52PM (#28317406)
Even in a democratic country if the only jobs people can find are sketchy illegal ones without social protection you can tell the government has failed at its job.
Re:Rent control isn’t working in Sweden by nivenkos on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:30AM (#28315416)
It's not the same as NYC though. Most renters in Stockholm are renting second-hand or commercial and are not covered by rent control at all.

It's more akin to the council housing crisis in the UK.