News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by burntoutfire on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:43AM (#28311772)
Poland is doable if you stay out of major cities. You can rent a studio for $300 (incl. all utilities). Food, if you cook, will cost you $200-$250 ($300-$400 if you don't cook and want to eat out only). Wired Internet and cell phone will be around $20. State-provided health insurance is about $120 per month (this is "socialized medicine", so it provides everything with no deducible, up to treating cancer etc.), but can possibly be gamed - there are loopholes that de facto allow you to pay insurance only once you need it (may be too hard to navigate for someone who's not a native speaker though). Btw the health insurance is "free" if you get any kind of job, even working couple hours a week.

Also, Poland should be a great place to actually run your game studio company from, as the tax on "IT innovation" (should not be hard to include games in this category) is only 6% - everything after that ends up in your pocket (i.e. no further dividend tax etc is required).

Assuming you won't be getting a car, public transit and Uber/taxis are affordable as well - a 5 km trip via Uber should perhaps be around $4.

I suspect other countries in the region should have similar numbers. Healthcare system and tax incentives should definitely be the biggest differentiator.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by rich_sasha on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:09PM (#28319174)
As a Pole myself, I’d add two things: it is generally a lovely country, lots of beautiful countryside etc. Less “spectacular”, more “cozy” etc. People are a bit uncertain of new things (eg foreigners in a new town) but generally warm and helpful eventually.

That said, I’d you’re not white and straight, small towns could be very unwelcoming, from people staring, to telling you to go, to physical violence. Rare but true.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by cloudedcordial on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:12PM (#28320028)
Non-Pole here. Visited Poland in the past 10 years. Beautiful countryside for sure. Cities and roads were clean. Decent food.

During my last visit, wireless phone service was super in the major cities...even better than Canada's.

As a tourist, Poland was a pretty big bang on my money: Equivalent item from the west for 1/3 of the cost while enjoying modern amenities. But I can see non Polish speakers would have difficulties living there in the longer term. During my trips, I insisted on travelling with at least one native Polish speaker.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by coderintherye on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:47PM (#28321324)
The locals did stare at us funny when we didn't put ketchup on our pizza, but then we stared back cause why would someone do such a thing.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by exikyut on Sunday August 29, 2021 @08:46AM (#28346262)
As someone who has never done this before, *I'm* now wondering why someone *wouldn't* do such a thing :D that sounds awesome
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by bruceb on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:48PM (#28319703)
non pole here, knew a guy who wasn't white or European, not living in biggest cities, loved it there. sure its safer than many places.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by rich_sasha on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:56PM (#28319802)
Well I love it, and many places and people will give non-white non-straight people no issues.

But hand on heart can I say to someone outside that narrow blueprint it’s definitely fine? Nope.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by fhood on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:02PM (#28319882)
Haven't been, so I wonder how it compares with rural US, where, at least in some of the places I've been, people are quite intolerant in abstract, but almost universally friendly in person.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by rich_sasha on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:50PM (#28320538)
I think if people get to know you, they are indeed positively surprised that “despite” being foreign etc you’re actually nice etc. That wouldn’t be my concern so much.

It would rather be the odd skinhead on the bus or in the street. The current government is also quietly accepting such behaviours, as it is their voter base, so the few “bad apples” feel they can act with impunity.

I don’t want to overplay it, it’s not Nazi Germany, but for sure something to consider. Nice place one way or the other.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by bobthechef on Thursday August 26, 2021 @07:13PM (#28322222)
This is what I read in this response: "Is it safe to visit Poland? I hear you could get struck by lightening over there."

Also, the idea that the current government is quietly accepting skinhead violence is preposterous.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by lappet on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:54PM (#28320587)
Is that true even for visiting? I am Indian and have wanted to visit Poland and the region for quite a while. I did find rural Germany quite ok except communication.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by rich_sasha on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:32PM (#28321114)
You’ll be fine for sure in touristy areas and big city centres.

There are Indian people living and working in Poland, so it can’t be too bad. Right wing media say nothing of racist attacks. Left wing media describe them all the time. There are vocal nationalists, most of whom never go past their grumblings.

I raise it as I’d be somewhat concerned sending a non-white or job-straight friend into rural Poland.

If you look at UK Foreign Office travel advice, the LGBT intolerance warrants a mention, but no other warning: https://www.gov.uk/foreign-travel-advice/poland/local-laws-a... . I guess attitudes to non-white people could get a similar treatment.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by lappet on Friday August 27, 2021 @02:55AM (#28325069)
Ok. Thank you so much for the advice.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by lostmsu on Tuesday August 31, 2021 @06:14PM (#28374334)
What about fiber internet at 1Gbps+?
[dead]
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by makeworld on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:39PM (#28319583)
>very unwelcoming, physical violence

>"I think that sounds great!"

>"Oh no why do people think I'm an evil person"

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by adekmm on Thursday August 26, 2021 @08:36PM (#28322929)
@41209 look at this: https://pl.usembassy.gov/abct/

I live in Żary (Tier-3 City), which is near Żagań. Quick overview:

- small city is quite cheap. Prices said by @burntoutfire are right

- there are around 2000 US soldiers hanging around here. So you won't be alone :) if someone told you that small cities in eastern europe may be intolerant (or unsafe or unwelcoming) for travelers - it's not here. Here Everyone thinks that every American met is a soldier with combat training ;)

- internet is cheap and stable. mobile is cheap and stable (comparing to US or western Europe). In almost every place you can pay using credit card.

- ecommerce is working great here. Delivery takes 1 working day. Parcel lockers are on every corner of Poland already :)

- it's close to Germany (10 miles to border, 100 miles to Berlin) so you can get two cultures in one visit.

- people in Poland are... mentally somewhere between Russians and Germans ;)

- most of the people <40yo understand english. But many of them have no practice and are just afraid to speak. The younger people you meet the bigger chance to speak english you have.

- it's the region with a lot of forests (like 70% of area). So the air quality is decent comparing to any large city.

- covid is not an issue here right now. We had 6 new cases in last 24h per 1 million people. There is no "next wave" coming. You should wear a mask in closed space, but except visits at hospital/doctors no one cares.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by bingohbangoh on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:27PM (#28319433)
It should be said that you will need to make some effort to learn the local language.

People will know enough English for you to get by, but it will feel very isolating. Learning just a little bit of Polish will make a world of difference, especially if you need to talk with a plumber or doctor (they're very unlikely to know much English).

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by bobthechef on Thursday August 26, 2021 @07:21PM (#28322297)
Doctors?
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by randycupertino on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:24PM (#28323655)
Generally most people over ~35-40yo won't speak English as it wasn't added to school curriculum until after the fall of the Soviet block.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by pelasaco on Friday August 27, 2021 @02:11AM (#28324798)
People over ~50-60yo maybe. 35-40 yo, spent not more than 10 years under Soviet control. Add to that, that Poles live quite often abroad and a lot of them spent years in Ireland/UK. We have even numbers to support that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_English-s... ... Poland in the top 20.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by isbvhodnvemrwvn on Saturday August 28, 2021 @01:17PM (#28339706)
There's ability to speak English, and willingness to speak English in a professional setting - a doctor with no professional training might refuse to use English just in case they misunderstand something. Same with officials (who if they knew English well in the first place, would work in a corporation of some sort).
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by mathgenius on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:48PM (#28319700)
I'm an Australian in Krakow & I'd recommend it. Plenty of people understand English, and it's a small enough city that the vibe is fairly relaxed.

Places like this will help with a visa for a more extended stay so you can run your "startup":

https://twojstartup.pl/

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by pzduniak on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:12PM (#28319231)
That 6% tax is... complicated. Bug fixes are not innovation IIRC - I just end up paying 19%, which isn't that much anyways.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by tomwojcik on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:11PM (#28320831)
Exactly, its almost impossible to use the R&D tax relief. Also, starting with 2021, we will pay more than 19% in taxes but the gov cant make up their mind on the changes so we dont know the details yet.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by randycupertino on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:36PM (#28320353)
I would also add that air pollution is something to consider regarding living in Poland long term:

https://notesfrompoland.com/2020/11/25/poland-has-eus-worst-...

https://www.sustainability-times.com/clean-cities/battling-t...

Also, if OP enjoys smoking pot, that might be an issue as per family who lives there it will be a big change vs coming from California.

Personally when traveling in Krakow and Warsaw I've found more racism against brown people lately vs 10 years ago... random cabbies and bartenders going on unprovoked rants against immigrants. Not sure if that's been one-off but that was surprising for me at least.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by dandigangi on Thursday August 26, 2021 @08:19PM (#28322760)
Would happily live there! Great country, people, and the 4 to 1 exchange range is amazing. Just outside of Krakow would be great. :)
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by soared on Thursday August 26, 2021 @06:47PM (#28322030)
Visit Poland before making a decision. As an American their social culture can come off as very cold and rude.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by xkqd on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:28PM (#28323682)
As far as working culture goes, it’s refreshing because there’s little tolerance for indirection and common corporate “colloquialisms”.

Certainly no song and dance to the way they do business.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by bobthechef on Thursday August 26, 2021 @07:25PM (#28322334)
That's because Europeans come across as cold and rude because Americans have a perpetual smile plastered on their faces. This causes Americans to come off as mentally deficient to Europeans.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by 8bitsrule on Friday August 27, 2021 @04:14AM (#28325444)
Here in the US, radio stations treated citizens to decades of Tony Bennet singing the song "Put On a Happy Face". It was from a 1960 musical called 'Bye Bye Birdie'.

By some magical coincidence, just a year later the black-on-yellow 'Happy Face' (Smiley) was introduced by the 'Good Guys' on NYC radio and used on badges for an insurance company.

Because it's early in the morning, I also wonder if there are other countries where the phrase "wipe that smile off your face" means you're in danger.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by xkqd on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:26PM (#28323665)
Thanks for the chuckle!

Yep. European’s view the perpetual grin dimly, and doubly so in Poland where direct communication is how things are done. It’s honestly nice because in general people there mean business and don’t care to save face. don’t think you’ll be catching west coast vibes from anyone!

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by wtk on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:22PM (#28319368)
regarding that 6% tax for innovation in IT - be warned, our governing idiot party is about to introduce a bunch of new laws, including a de facto increase of that 19% to 28%.
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by hdjjhhvvhga on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:22PM (#28319373)
> should not be hard to include games in this category

You better put aside the remaining 13% for 5 years, just in case the inevitable happens.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by vorpalhex on Thursday August 26, 2021 @02:51PM (#28318950)
Is car ownership pretty affordable overall? (Insurance, fees, etc)
Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by burntoutfire on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:32PM (#28319495)
Yes, very affordable. Yearly mandatory insurance, without any discounts for crash-free driving (as I doubt they'd honor insurance histories from foreign countries), is perhaps about $300. Mandatory yearly checkups are $30. Cars themselves are a bit pricier than in US - mostly due to VAT being higher than US's sales tax I guess. But, maintenance is way cheaper - there's plenty of cheap and skilled mechanics who will improvise fixes using scavenged second-hard parts (which they themselves will provide). Rebuilding an engine will cost you perhaps under $400 in labor, while I suspect it's in thousands of dollars in US.

Gas is currently $5.5 per gallon. Most people drive cars with low fuel consumption, so they're easy to get on second-hand market. Also, if one is particularly stingy about fuel costs, it's popular to own cars fueled by LPG. LPG is currently $2.5 per gallon.

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by xkqd on Thursday August 26, 2021 @10:30PM (#28323691)
> if one is particularly stingy about fuel costs, it's popular to own cars fueled by LPG.

I’ll add that it’s been popular for the last decade, up to 15 years. So don’t think it’s going anywhere, anytime soon!

Re:Ask HN: Where can I live off 1k USD per month? by kolinko on Saturday August 28, 2021 @09:44AM (#28337994)
It is, but you don't really need a car. Public transport and Uber/Taxis work very well in most cities.

Most of my friends don't have cars, around half doesn't have a driver's license. They can afford a car easily, but just don't see a need.