Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by __m on Thursday August 26, 2021 @12:47AM
(#28310813)
Still less creepy than the pledge of allegiance
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by tluyben2 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:27AM
(#28312520)
Someone was downvoted to hell for a comment, but it did make me think; can I refuse, as a kid in the US, to do the pledge? I cannot imagine having something like that where I was born; I think everyone + parents would've knocked it out of existence pretty much immediately, but can you, in the US, refuse to do it?
Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by trangus_1985 on Thursday August 26, 2021 @05:37AM
(#28312598)
Yes. The child may face penalties and disciplinary action, but if the school does that, the parents can sue and will win. It's happened many times now. It's a church/state and compelled speech issue. The ACLU loves picking up these kinds of cases because it's such a softball. IANAL
Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Thursday August 26, 2021 @07:31AM
(#28313468)
At least when I was a kid and the whole "pledge" thing started happening, yeah you could skip it and no one did anything. However, I attended highschool in a very liberal town and the principal only ever played the anthem instead of the pledge anyway.
Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by southeastern on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:21PM
(#28320138)
I never did. Altho I was a Muslim kid growing up post 9/11 so I think that played into it
Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by pxc on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:26PM
(#28319421)
you can, but a lot of teachers and other adults in charge of watching and disciplining children are not aware that you can. So for a kid to successfully refuse, they or their parents need to be well-informed of their rights and willing to threaten the school with legal action
Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by codezero on Thursday August 26, 2021 @03:10AM
(#28311573)
How do you make a scale of comparison between the two?
Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by robert_foss on Thursday August 26, 2021 @04:01AM
(#28311897)
One has at leadt theoretical space for the transfer of knowledge. The other is pure propaganda.
Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by codezero on Thursday August 26, 2021 @06:19PM
(#28321724)
Interesting take, I don't want to assume which you mean, but it seems like the pledge is pure propaganda, that said I find it more troubling when knowledge is intermixed with propaganda. At least pure propaganda is not trying to convince you it is anything else, like a space to transfer knowledge :)
Re:China schools: 'Xi Jinping Thought' introduced into curri...
by jsrcout on Thursday August 26, 2021 @11:43PM
(#28324072)
One includes the Dear Leader's name, one does not.